A decade ago, conservatives said in unison “markets good, state bad.” Now they say “markets good, the state better.” Under President Donald Trump, America is embracing a new form of state capitalism, with huge consequences not just for the economy but the health of the republic.

The Trump administration has acquired equity stakes or a “golden share” in companies ranging from Intel Corporation and U.S. Steel to Westinghouse nuclear reactors and Lithium Americas. The U.S. Department of Defense is set to invest $1 billion in L3Harris Technologies Inc.

The collective value of these equity stakes is now in the low tens of billions. Bloomberg Intelligence expects that the administration will continue to tap into the hundreds of billions in federal funding meant for loans and grants to instead secure equity in public and private companies.

The administration has used its grip over the state’s regulatory apparatus to shape the economy. For example, it predicated Nvidia Corp’s sales to China of its H200 advanced chip on a payment of a 25% export fee to the U.S. government and forced Apple Inc. and Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. to pledge more investment in the U.S. if they wanted to continue doing business with China.

Advertise with us

Donald Trump has also taken to bossing companies around with the relish of a Soviet central planner — telling pharmaceutical and credit card companies to lower their prices and instructing defense companies to halt dividends and share buybacks and redirect the money to building productive capacity.

Following China

The most important reason for America’s embrace of state capitalism is the rise of China as both an economic peer and a military threat. Xi Jinping has boasted of his intention to challenge the U.S.-dominated world order and has set about fusing the state’s economic and military capacities and tightening his alliances with other autocratic powers.

Both Democrats and Republicans agree that the U.S. has no choice but to respond to this threat by expanding the state’s powers to regulate the economy. For example, by reshoring some manufacturing activities to ensure that the U.S. has an “arsenal of democracy” or by securing supplies of chips and rare earths.

Trump may be an instinctive rather than an ideological politician, but his two basic instincts — that foreigners are trying to rip off America and that he, Trump, knows best — add up to an ideology of national corporatism.

He is surrounded by ideologues such as Vice President JD Vance, who thinks that the economy should be rejiggered to promote moral virtue. And also by tech nationalists such as Alex Karp, the CEO of Palantir Technologies, who believes in “the union of the state and the software industry” to promote national greatness.

Advertise with us

Trump being Trump, politics is also always personal, and state capitalism is always in danger of turning into family capitalism. Donald Jr. is a partner in a venture capital firm, 1789 Capital, that took a significant stake in Vulcan Elements three months before the administration decided to back it with a loan of more than half a billion dollars and a $50 million stake by the Department of Commerce.

A new phase

Scholars from Lazard Political Advisory argue that America’s state capitalism is moving into a new phase, from the rules-based industrial policy that characterized the Biden administration to discretionary state capitalism.

Even at its best, the state is a problematic capitalist. Government officials tend to be fuzzy about their purposes (are they creating jobs or promoting growth?) and slow to pull the plug on failure (the Obama administration’s investment in the green company Solyndra LLC cost the taxpayer more than $500 million).

The International Monetary Fund estimates that the misallocation of resources associated with China’s industrial policies between 2009 and 2018 lowered aggregate productivity by around 1.2% and may have reduced China’s GDP by up to 2%.

Add feuding ideologists and a wayward president to the mix and you are in for trouble. Trump is the worst sort of state capitalist, an unpredictable one. He has wielded tariffs, his favorite and most important weapon, with abandon. He has taken to threatening not just individual businesses but individual businesspeople, like publicly demanded the resignation of the CEO of Intel, Lip-Bu Tan.

Advertise with us

Here to stay

State capitalism in some form is here to stay, not just because of the enduring rivalry between China and the U.S., but also because of deep-rooted changes in the economy, which is now dominated by giant tech companies increasingly intertwined with the state. The state is determined to use Big Tech to improve its ability to defend itself and these tech companies have also latched onto the nation-state as the next source of corporate growth.

The U.S. is also caught up in what academics call a “state capitalist spiral.” Countries are competing to impose tit-for-tat restrictions on trade and equip themselves with the new weapons of economic warfare, sovereign wealth funds and state-owned enterprises.

We are unlikely to unmake this new world of intertwined state and corporate power anytime soon, given the threat from China and the power of big tech. Indeed, Joe Biden’s response to Trump’s initial experiment with state capitalism was to reinforce it  with regulation rather than unwind it.

That may be an unlikely prospect for the current U.S. administration. Yet the rise of state capitalism makes the quality of government more important than ever, and the case for far-reaching reform even more urgent.

Adrian Wooldridge is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist and author of “The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World.” His previous article was “Europe is going down.”