When the Senate voted on a resolution to limit the president’s authority to continue military operations against Iran, Democrats largely supported the measure as a check on the Trump administration, while Republicans largely opposed it.
Only one Democrat broke with his party to do what was right for the United States. The senator is Pennsylvania’s John Fetterman, who voted with Republicans to oppose the resolution.
Over the weekend, he tweeted, “Why do Democrats now universally condemn what achieves a top, longstanding Democratic priority?” Because he represents the party’s older tradition that understood solidarity with democratic allies and confrontation with authoritarian regimes as progressive values.
Democratic divergence
Fetterman’s vote reflects a divergence within the Democratic Party over how to understand the Oct. 7 Hamas massacre and the war that followed.
For many Democrats, the years since that massacre have been politically disorienting. The immediate aftermath of the attack produced a brief moment of bipartisan clarity: Hamas’s atrocities were universally condemned, and Israel’s right to defend itself was widely affirmed. Yet, as Israel’s military campaign in Gaza unfolded and regional tensions escalated, the center of gravity inside the Democratic coalition shifted.
Progressives, campus movements and a growing number of elected officials increasingly framed Israel as the wrongdoer and aggressor. This inversion of reality has had profound ramifications.
Democratic members of Congress introduced measures to restrict arms transfers to Israel, authored cease-fire resolutions, and caterwauled against U.S. military involvement in any confrontation with Iran. The war powers resolution that came before the Senate last week reflects the inversion of reality: It is designed to restrain America and Israel, rather than the actual state sponsor of terrorism, Iran.
Fetterman approached the situation from a different set of values and beliefs. Since Oct. 7, he has consistently framed the conflict in terms that would once have been entirely familiar within the Democratic Party of not so long ago.
The party’s past
Those instincts would have sounded routine inside the Democratic Party a generation ago. While serving as U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, Daniel Patrick Moynihan gave an impassioned defense of Israel and Zionism while opposing the infamous and slanderous U.N. General Assembly Resolution 3379, which declared that “Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination.”
Moynihan correctly observed that Resolution 3379 “reeked of the totalitarian mind, stank of the totalitarian state.” After his tenure at the United Nations was complete, Moynihan went on to represent New York in the Senate for more than two decades as a Democrat.
These figures believed that liberal values — democracy, minority rights, political freedom — were not abstractions but commitments that required defending democratic societies against regimes that openly violated them.
The experience of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars fostered deep skepticism toward U.S. military intervention, particularly among younger Democrats.
The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has become one of the clearest arenas where that shift is visible. Within many progressive circles, Israel is now framed less as a democratic ally under threat and more as an occupying power deserving condemnation. In that framework, distancing the United States from Israel — or conditioning support for it — becomes a logical extension of progressive politics.
Newsom vs. Fetterman
Consider Gavin Newsom, the California governor who is likely to run for president in 2028. Recently, Newsom suggested that the United States might need to reconsider aspects of its support for Israel.
Newsom, who has previously been supportive of Israel, senses the political winds blowing in his party. His approach reflects the emerging consensus within much of the Democratic coalition, which is skeptical toward American power and uncomfortable with Israel’s military actions.
In contrast, Fetterman’s approach reflects a fading tradition within the party — one that views solidarity with democratic allies and confrontation with authoritarian regimes as natural extensions of progressive values.
When the Senate considered whether to restrict military action against Iran, the Democratic caucus largely aligned with the newer instinct: caution, restraint and distance from the use of American power in the region. John Fetterman stood alone on the other side of that divide.
Whether his stance represents the beginning of a broader reconsideration inside the Democratic Party — or simply the last echo of an older tradition that once defined it — remains to be seen. What is clear is that when the Senate cast its votes, the line separating those two visions ran straight through the Democratic Party itself.
Shabbos Kestenbaum is a political commentator at PragerU.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.