By the simplest, most reliable measure we have — murder statistics — the U.S. has been getting less and less violent lately. The 2025 murder rate may be lowest since before 1960 and may turn out to be a 40% decline over the past five years.
But mass attacks and politically targeted ones are rare enough that it’s hard to make sense of the statistics on them. What follows is my cautious attempt to do so.
The statistics
Using Hamline University’s Violence Project’s database of political assassinations and assassination attempts in the U.S., Bloomberg Economics found that the five such attacks on politicians from 2021 through 2025 (which doesn’t include the killing of Charlie Kirk, who wasn’t a politician) was the highest number for any five-year period on record. The past two have been anomalously bad, but it’s hard to discern any pattern beyond that.
The databases of mass shootings maintained by the Rockefeller Institute of Government of the State University of New York shows a big rise over the past three decades but a decline in recent years.
The libertarian Cato Institute’s database of terrorist killings defined them as those that involve “use of illegal force and violence by a nonstate actor to attain a political, economic, religious or social goal through coercion, fear, or intimidation.” It’s dominated by the 1995 bombing of the Oklahoma City federal building and the Sept. 11 attacks.
This ability of just two events to overshadow all the rest combined is one indication of why risk statistics for things like terrorism aren’t super-informative. But to make them a bit more informative, here’s what the statistics look like without those two tragedies. The baseline level of violence looks to be higher these days than it used to be, and 2025 isn’t over yet.
The Cato data were original compiled for research into the immigration backgrounds of foreign terrorists. It found that those here on tourist visas were responsible for most of the deaths and illegal immigrants for none at all. Its study and an open-source database of terrorism prosecutions maintained by the Prosecution Project both show Islamists and those on the political right to be the main culprits of U.S. terrorist attacks over the past three decades, with leftists accounting for a relatively small portion.
For 2024 and 2025, Cato’s statistics do show a shift, though, with seven attacks to the left and three to the right. This is not enough data from which to draw meaningful conclusions, but it does indicate that conservatives who feel they are being targeted by leftist terrorists aren’t entirely wrong.
Also, the Republican targets of recent attacks — President Donald Trump and Kirk — have been nationally prominent figures, while the Democratic ones have been less so.
The Republican reaction
President Trump and other leading Republicans chose to play down and even make light of the latter. As a result, their reaction to Kirk’s death, while surely genuine, has come across as cynical and even downright sinister.
“It is a vast domestic terror movement,” White House Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller said this week. “And with God as my witness, we are going to use every resource we have to the DOJ, DHS, and throughout this government to identify, disrupt, dismantle, and destroy these networks.”
This is a justification for persecuting leftists, not a serious analysis of what’s causing political violence. None of the recent acts appears to involve an organized terror network, and many don’t align with coherent ideologies. Grown men with troubled lives, and a bent toward fabulism, are a recurring theme in recent violence, as are promising young men whose brains have been pickled by online discourse.
The New Year’s Day truck attack on Bourbon Street in New Orleans has been described as ISIS-inspired, but the culprit was an 42-year-old US Army veteran from Texas with an unraveling life and no known ties to the Islamic State.
The 57-year-old charged with the Minnesota killings had conservative political leanings but has also been described as struggling financially and having a penchant for making stuff up. The shooter of Trump last year and the accused shooter of Kirk last week were star students who spent a lot of time online, with the politics of the first still unclear and Kirk’s accused killer leaning left.
Isolation and dark rules
Anger at Trump’s return to power and Israel’s occupation of Gaza are two chief sources of online rage at the moment, but as journalist Derek Thompson argued in a useful summing-up of the evidence this week, the main drivers of mass shootings and political violence in the US these days seem to be (1) social isolation and (2) what he calls the “dark laws” of online engagement that reward negativity, extremism and animosity toward the other side.
Repealing those dark laws may not be possible in any case. Hoping for constructive action from a president who rose to power in part because of his adeptness at following them is probably a mistake.
Justin Fox is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. His previous article was “Crime in America is going down (except at one time of day).”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.