The rivalry between the Philadelphia Eagles and Dallas Cowboys that opened the 2025 National Football League season on Thursday night was more of a game than many predicted.

Philadelphia, who held on against a sharp Cowboys offense to win 27—24, was coming off a Super Bowl win and has the personnel and leadership to repeat the feat. The Cowboys have spent the last three decades not winning much (except, maybe, the news cycle). On top of it, they had just traded away Micah Parsons, their best defensive player.

However, the game wasn’t just a clash between players. It was also a matchup between ownership philosophies that represent the past and the future of the NFL.

Jerry Jones vs. Jeffrey Lurie

Jerry Jones, the marketing genius who turned the Cowboys into the most valuable franchise in professional sports, is on one sideline. On the other is Jeffrey Lurie, the Eagles owner whose quiet competence attracts outside investors in search of financial returns.

Advertise with us

As the NFL continues to attract massive numbers of viewers and teams grow in value, it’s the latter approach to owning and managing a franchise that’s poised to win.

In its early days, the NFL didn’t generate billions of dollars, and teams weren’t considered good investments. Owners made money by putting together rosters that could sell tickets; losing made that harder.

As a result, NFL owners were either so rich that they didn’t need to lean on their teams for income, or they were entrepreneurs with micromanager tendencies willing to lay it all on the line to succeed. Jones, who made his fortune as an oil and gas wildcatter, falls into that second category.

He took a considerable financial risk when he purchased the then-money-losing Cowboys (and Texas Stadium) in 1989 for $140 million. Flush with confidence and vision, he appointed himself — a former college football player — as general manager, and promptly won three Super Bowls.

Off the field, Jones pioneered marketing, branding and sponsorship deals by - in part - leveraging his penchant for generating attention and controversy. As the team’s profile rose, so too did the sponsorship and other revenue. Today, the Cowboys are worth an estimated $12.8 billion.

Advertise with us

Analytics vs. gut instinct

Still, Jones continues to micromanage even as his players underwhelm, notching a 7-10 record last season. His insistence on personalizing contract discussions with Parsons — he reportedly tried to negotiate a deal without the player’s agent present — might have worked in an earlier era. But when contract values reach nine figures, owners need to take a more professional approach to retaining employees.

It’s not just the employees who feel that way, either. NFL franchises are now so valuable that institutional investors are clamoring to get into the action. Last year, sensing an opportunity, NFL owners voted to allow private equity firms to buy limited stakes in teams.

These companies are naturally attracted to disciplined, goal-focused and sustainable businesses. The Cowboys, for all of their commercial success, aren’t in that category. So long as Jones remains in charge, it’s any fan’s — or investor’s — guess as to what’s next for the team. The only certainty is that Jones will turn it into a headline.

The Eagles don’t operate that way. Since acquiring the team in 1994, Lurie has made a habit of deferring to his employees and, notably, data to make decisions focused on one goal: winning. The team is widely acknowledged to be a pioneer in football analytics, and Lurie isn’t shy about crediting number-crunchers for its success.

That doesn’t mean that the franchise is averse to taking risks — it’s taken many — but they’re calculated gambles. Gut-level decision-making, of the sort valued by Jones (who, in the past, has been dismissive of analytics), isn’t a part of the Eagles’ DNA under Lurie.

Advertise with us

Jones’ kind of intuitive management style is more often embraced by owners who like to meddle. However, those micromanagers generally don’t have Lurie’s recent on-field success, including three Super Bowl appearances (winning twice) since 2017.

The Cowboys haven’t been to an NFC championship game or the Super Bowl since 1996 (when they beat the Steelers), despite having many very good seasons along with many bad or mediocre ones. In that time, the New York Giants, now woeful, appeared in three Super Bowls and won two.

Successful Eagles

Lurie’s Birds haven’t just been successful on the field. In December, the Eagles sold minority stakes in the team to two family investment groups for what Lurie described as “the highest price in sports history.” That lofty rate, he noted, had nothing to do with “being the most profitable team.” Rather, he pointed to the Eagles’ long-term performance, reputation and ability to forecast its future prospects.

The Cowboys can’t compete with any of those metrics. The team doesn’t win consistently, the fans are depressed (indeed, a recent survey found Dallas fans to be the third most pessimistic in the NFL), and still, Jones won’t relinquish control of the Cowboys’ future.

Thursday night’s game might imply that Jones’ philosophy is as effective as Luries. But it isn’t — or the Eagles wouldn’t have so much more success in the last few years than the Cowboys. The future will underscore how Lurie is showing the way forward for the NFL’s next era.

Adam Minter is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering the business of sports and the author of “Secondhand: Travels in the New Global Garage Sale." His previous article was “Mike Tyson and Jake Paul’s fight should have been illegal.”