What started as a call from President Trump to Texas Gov. Greg Abbott has become an arms race to win control of the House of Representatives. But the most troubling aspect isn’t the gerrymandering itself, but how willingly our leaders are abandoning the institutions they claim to defend.
Pay attention to how our leaders are presenting this institutional destruction. Texas Republicans openly acknowledged their plan was designed to “perform better for Republican congressional candidates” and justified it as a response to “Democratic gerrymandering elsewhere.” California’s Democratic governor Gavin Newsom declared “We have got to fight fire with fire. Don’t mess with the great Golden State.”
This is the language of leaders who are celebrating playing voters against one another and taking advantage of a flawed redistricting system. It represents a dangerous shift in our governance, where abandoning principles becomes a source of pride, not regret.
Obviously wrong
The story politicians tell themselves and us is that they didn’t want to abandon their principles — the other side forced their hand. This framing makes exploiting the process sound noble. It transforms compromising our values into a celebration of abandoning them.
The problem isn’t that it’s always factually wrong. It’s obvious that the responses are a political necessity within our current system. The problem is that we’re presenting institutional destruction as moral courage.
Texas hasn’t explicitly broken any rules in this redistricting, other than political norms. Indeed, similar mid-decade redistricting occurred in the state in 2003.
On the other hand, to engage in this fight, California would have to override its own independent redistricting commission, a reform structure added to the state constitution by voters in 2010 specifically designed to take partisanship out of redistricting. Yet, the state leaders feel comfortable ignoring good governance to fight bad governance.
The “fight fire with fire” mentality is now spreading to the Democratic states of Illinois and New York and the Republican states of Ohio and Missouri, each side insisting it’s defending democracy by undermining it just a little bit, just this once, until the other side stops being so unreasonable. This is how our democratic norms collapse.
Our narratives matter
The narratives we tell matter because they dictate what is acceptable. When politicians celebrate rule-bending instead of treating it as a regrettable necessity, they tell voters that institutions are nothing but tools for partisan advantage. When abandoning principles is a triumph, not a failure, the next abandonment becomes even easier.
A principled response from California would decry Texas and acknowledge the flaws of these mechanisms. It would be out of touch with political realities to demand that a state not counter redistricting.
We can’t just ask California, nor Ohio, Missouri, or Illinois, to just let Texas draw new lines. Rather, state governments must see their participation in a flawed system as a sign that we need to fix the system.
There are politicians trying to break this cycle. Republican Rep. Kevin Kiley of California introduced legislation to ban mid-decade redistricting nationwide. This measure would constrain his own party’s advantage in Texas while preventing Democratic retaliation in California.
Although it’s regrettable that these reforms are mostly pushed only by representatives whose seats are most at risk, they are most certainly a step in the right direction.
Our choice
The choice isn’t between being naive about political realities and abandoning all principles. It’s a choice between narratives that makes bending the rules sound heroic and narratives that drive us to work on something better. Politics can require straying from the right path, but we cannot paint these responses as noble crusades.
We can counter gerrymandering without celebrating it. We can protect our interests without pretending that institutional destruction is a defense of democracy.
The gerrymandering in Texas is wrong. The institutional destruction in California is wrong. We cannot glorify breaking the very systems we claim to defend.
Brayden Myers is a contributor with Young Voices and a student of economics at the University of Alabama.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.