President Donald Trump’s military interventions in Los Angeles and Washington, D.C., foretell his plan for other cities. The Washington Post recently reported on the Pentagon’s plans for a “quick reaction force” to deploy amid civil unrest.
Broad mobilization of the military on U.S. soil could happen under the Insurrection Act, which Trump has flirted with invoking. That rarely used Act allows troops to arrest and use force against civilians, which is otherwise prohibited by longstanding law and tradition.
These developments should sound alarms for all Americans. It is time to oppose such misuse of the military and emergency powers.
New York, Chicago, Baltimore, etc.
Make no mistake, mobilizing the National Guard in L.A. and D.C. is a threat to other cities.
At his rambling Aug. 11 press conference, Trump implied that New York, Chicago, Baltimore, and Oakland are among the cities on his list. On August 12, Presidential Advisor Stephen Miller made clear on “X” that the attacks on “big blue cities” are part of an agenda, justified by the preposterous charge that “Democrats are trying to unravel civilization,” while “President Trump will save it.”
D.C. authorities did not request federal intervention. Trump justified the occupation with the false claim that city authorities lost control of violent crime. Yes, D.C. has a serious crime problem. However, violent crime is down 26% compared with this time a year ago and at a 30-year low.
In Los Angeles’ case, Trump’s deployment of the National Guard and active duty military troops in June was done under the false premise that protests there constituted “a form of rebellion against the authority of the Government of the United States.”
The presidential memoranda ordering the actions in L.A. and D.C. demonstrates both broad intent and overreach as local and state officials were bypassed and no clear “emergency” justified their issuance.
The June 7, 2025, presidential memorandum used to send troops to Los Angeles is so vague that it could be invoked practically any time for deployments anywhere. Neither L.A. nor California is specifically mentioned. It allows the activation of other states’ National Guard for “military protective activities” that the secretary of defense determines “are reasonably necessary to ensure the protection and safety of Federal personnel and property.”
The Aug. 11 presidential memorandum on D.C. gives the Secretary of Defense the same power. As of Aug. 16, it was announced that West Virginia, South Carolina and Ohio were deploying hundreds of additional National Guard troops to D.C. The National Guard troops now carry weapons, even though no serious confrontations with them have taken place.
A president has broad discretion in deciding to declare a state of emergency, and once done, a president can employ more than 130 statutory emergency powers. The recent presidential memoranda set a precedent for unbridled interventions, sending National Guard and active military troops wherever the President claims an emergency exists. That applies even when governors object.
Congress must say no
To protect democratic governance, abuse of presidential emergency powers must be constrained by Congress and the courts and opposed by the public.
California is challenging the legality of the ongoing military intervention in L.A. In June, U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer issued an order restraining the deployment, but it was reversed on appeal.
Judge Breyer conducted further hearings on August 13 to 15 on whether the troops’ activities have violated the 147-year old Posse Comitatus Act that blocks the military from civilian law enforcement. The outcome of the case will have national implications.
In D.C., the police are a focal point. Section 740 of the D.C. Home Rule Act allows a president, when “special conditions of an emergency nature exist,” to direct the mayor to order the D.C. police to provide federal “services.”
Attorney General Pam Bondi wrongly attempted to place the police under direct federal command. D.C. challenged her order before the District Court and the order was rescinded.
Under Section 740, the president’s initial order lasts only 30 days, unless the House and Senate extend the time. Trump has stated that he will seek a long-term extension.
Democrats have introduced the Limiting Emergency Powers Act of 2025, which would limit on presidential emergency powers. There is noteworthy bipartisan support for such measures. And groups like the Brennan Center for Justice and numerous other democracy advocacy organizations are working for related reforms, though reforms alone may be insufficient to constrain a president who acts beyond the law.
Members of the House and Senate need to hear forceful demands for the immediate enactment of effective limitations. Calling and texting them is in order. Related advocacy group reform efforts also deserve support. And, more than that is needed.
Future deployments
We may be headed to a circumstance where the military is deployed to one or more additional cities over local objections. L.A.’s mayor, police, and public managed to curtail violence without deadly confrontations between protesters and National Guard troops. That may not be the case in the future, and we cannot afford to play Russian roulette with military deployments.
That’s why the public should make clear that presidential deployment of troops to cities over the objections of state and local officials cannot be “normalized” and cannot stand.
Pat Merloe, a long-time resident of Washington, D.C., provides strategic advice on democracy and trustworthy elections in the U.S. and internationally.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.