The sticker price is too damn high. Growing unaffordability of new vehicles in the U.S. is a problem not only for drivers but for Detroit itself. It demands a shift in strategy, one hinted at by Ford Motor Co.’s electric-vehicle event last week.

The latest inflation figures added more evidence of Americans struggling to buy new cars and trucks. While new-vehicle inflation in July was low, used-vehicle prices accelerated. Parts inflation is also picking up, and this was the first month in more than three years when used-vehicle and parts prices increased faster than headline inflation.

That subdued reading for new vehicles is a red herring. President Donald Trump’s tariffs aren’t yet pushing up those prices largely because the industry has shielded consumers, running down existing inventory and absorbing multibillion-dollar cuts to earnings.

High cost, low growth

That isn’t altruism. It is just tougher to raise prices when they are already so high. The average new vehicle scraped $49,000 in July, roughly $12,000 higher than six years ago, according to data from Cox Automotive. Over that same period, banks’ average auto loan rates rose from around 5% to nearly 8%. Almost a fifth of new buyers now pay more than $1,000 a month on their loan, and both delinquencies and charge-offs at automakers’ finance arms are heading up, according to Joel Levington, former director of credit research for Bloomberg Intelligence. Hence the renewed bidding for cheaper used vehicles.

Advertise with us

Inflation will bleed into new vehicles, too, especially as new-year models start hitting dealerships. This will blunt some of the benefit of the new tax deductibility for auto loans on U.S.-assembled vehicles. The disappearance of EV tax credits will effectively raise those prices, too.

This cuts against the direction taken by Ford and General Motors Co. over the past decade or so: Selling higher-priced, higher-margin trucks and SUVs and mostly leaving the rest of the market to others. Detroit’s average vehicle now sells for around $55,000, roughly $10,000 to $20,000 more than the average for Japanese competitors. This approach has worked well. In 2018, Ford and GM reported combined worldwide sales of 14.4 million vehicles and net income of $14.1 billion. Last year, they sold 10.5 million vehicles, and profit topped $20 billion.

The cost is growth. Sub-$30,000 vehicles have all but disappeared from U.S. dealerships, and annual sales remain subdued at around 16 million compared with the 17 million to 18 million that prevailed before the pandemic. Slowing adult population growth and a rising proportion of retirees, who drive far less on average, present a growing headwind. Trump’s inflationary tariffs compound all this, and his trade deals, such as they are, will not reverse Detroit’s retreat from much of the rest of the world, where bigger U.S. models aren’t popular. While GM and Ford have recently enjoyed bumper profits, consensus forecasts have neither company matching their 2024 earnings through the next three years.

Affordable moonshot

The added complication is chronic excess capacity. Utilization at U.S. auto factories has been below 80% for the past 32 quarters, Kevin Tynan, research director at the Presidio Group, an auto-focused investment bank, points out. “Oversupply doesn’t meaningfully impact demand even when throwing money at it,” he said, adding that sales are “very consistent regardless of inventory; what changes is the cost of customer acquisition.”

Incentives haven’t reached pre-pandemic levels yet. But sluggish growth and excess capacity sow the seeds of discounting, putting pressure on automakers to keep lines humming to defray fixed costs. And yet, discounting to move metal cuts into profits, which is why Ford and GM shifted toward a pricier product mix in the first place.

Advertise with us

Breaking out of this quandary brings us to Ford’s EV event. A curious aspect of this was that it dwelt less on product and more on production, touting a complete reimagining of the assembly line. In one respect, this was an implicit rebuke to Trump’s war on EVs, with Ford plugging away regardless.

But it also hinted at a broader shift. Ford aims for its first new EV built using a new platform to be a $30,000 small truck in 2027. Ford sells only a few regular models today at prices that even start with a 3, such as the Bronco Sport. Releasing a new model at that price point, and profitably, would represent a radical development as well as a moonshot. Even Tesla hasn’t managed to make EVs with anything like those economics, and its pivot away from developing cheap models toward six-figure Cybertrucks that have sold slower than the Ford Edsel looks ever more like a huge strategic mistake.

Through the Cybertruck’s first six quarters, Tesla sold 51,953 units in the U.S. according to Cox Automotive. Meanwhile, the Edsel, an infamous case study of new product failure, some 63,110 units were sold in the U.S. in 1958, its first year of production, according to MotorCities National Heritage Area Partnership.

Only choice

And yet, with the market sluggish and already saturated with higher-priced models, what choice but to swing for the fences? This isn’t just about trying to make a go of EVs; it’s about a step-change in production costs to make affordability an attribute rather than a liability.

It is also about China. Chinese rivals are making inroads across the world, and even fortress America’s high trade barriers are not expected within the industry to last indefinitely. Indeed, Trump’s mercurial approach could even produce a deal similar to the one struck with Japan in the 1980s for Chinese automakers to set up shop here. They could be expected to launch innovative, competitively priced models in a U.S. market that sorely needs them.

Advertise with us

Detroit’s focus on the higher end has served it well. But without a radical rethinking, it will ultimately pay a heavy price of its own.

Liam Denning is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering energy.