Business is the great unmentionable in the contemporary literary world, yet a tale of corporate drones turned green entrepreneurs is now garnering rave reviews. “Drayton and Mackenzie” by Alexander Starritt tells the story of two James Drayton and Roland Mackenzie, who disappoint their parents by going into the business world. It also tells the story of two very different types of business.
The two start off in the management consultancy goliath McKinsey & Co. Inc., seduced by its culture of “performative zeal” but soon disillusioned by the “onboarding,” “performance reviews” and blandly sinister HR speak.
Senior partners talk about the McKinsey Way as if it is a major school of philosophy when it invariably boils down to three bullet points. The two end up on a “restructuring” project in Aberdeen which amounts to sacking every second person and shuttering corporate canteens.
They toy with giving up on business life before being seized by an idea. Why not use their business skills to solve a real problem? Why not harness the fearsome current in the North Sea to generate power?
Their quest to establish a company that actually does something rather than just manipulating figures introduces them to a rich cast of characters: Scottish politicians who will throw money at a project as long as it is “Scottish”; a Peter Thiel who has a genius for summoning real businesses (offices, factories and hardware) out of abstract ideas; and an Elon Musk who insists on meeting them not in Mayfair, where most investors operate, but in the never-gentrifying neighborhood of chicken shops and motorway flyovers, Shepherd’s Bush.
The gripping story raises a question: Why are so few business novels being written?
The industrial novel
The 19th century gave birth to “the industrial novel.” The likes of Charles Dickens (“Hard Times”) and Elizabeth Gaskell (“North and South”) grappled with the great economic transformation of the era.
The information revolution is the most-far reaching revolution since then. Yet so far, we have only seen one first-rate “information novel,” Dave Eggers’ 2013 “The Circle.”
Many of the world’s best novelists once wrote about business. The French novelist Balzac includes all sorts of businesspeople, small and big, in his “La Comedie humaine” series. The English novelist Trollope’s “The Way We Live Now” (1875) is a brilliant portrait of an entrepreneur.
German Nobel Prize winner Thomas Mann wrote about the decline of a great Hanseatic merchant family in “Buddenbrooks” (1901). The titles of American Theodore Dreiser’s most famous novels, “The Financier” (1912) and “The Titan” (1914), speak for themselves.
But today’s big names, such as Margaret Atwood and Salman Rushdie from the older generation and Zadie Smith and Sally Rooney from the younger one, never venture into the world of onboarding and performance reviews, let alone the agonies of funding rounds.
Tom Wolfe provided one explanation for this neglect in his 1989 essay “Stalking the Billion-Footed Beast.” He argued that novelists were abandoning the greatest story of their time — capitalist civilization in all its buzzing confusion — and retreating into literary game-playing.
He tried to change the direction of literature by writing a succession of state-of-the-nation novels, two of which, “The Bonfire of the Vanities” (1987) and “A Man in Full” (1998), focused on businesspeople, a Wall Street trader and an Atlanta property developer respectively.
Alien cultures
Wolfe’s books sold in their millions, but his prophesy nevertheless remained true: Novelists left the great business stories of the era to be told by journalists such as Michael Lewis or to be fictionalized in TV series such as “Succession” and “Billions.”
The West is equally divided between two equally alien cultures, a literary culture and a business culture. The first is all about the left, or feeling side, of the brain. The second is about the right, or analytical, side.
This division is reinforced by professionalization. Today’s would-be writers study art subjects as undergraduates before attending creative writing workshops. Would-be captains of industry study science or economics before getting their MBAs.
The fiction departments of publishing houses are run by people who shudder at the thought of “big business” just as big businesses are run by people who regard novels as effete nonsense. One of the heroes of “Drayton and Mackenzie” boasts that he hasn’t read a novel since university.
Let’s hope that the publication of “Drayton and Mackenzie” helps to bring these two worlds back together. The literary world is stuck in a rut at the moment. It publishes all too many romances set on campuses or laboriously crafted novellas about trying to make a living in New York after winning a literary prize.
Tom Wolfe was right back in the 1980s when he argued that writers were crazy to leave the most exciting stories of their era to journalists and TV producers. But since then, the story of business has morphed from something that is just exciting to something that is existential.
The great 21st century novel
The new information capitalists are inadvertently posing profound questions about what it means to be human.
How far can companies go in commoditizing our desires or invading our privacy without compromising our essential humanity? What does the arrival of artificial intelligence tell us about human intelligence and human empathy? What is it like inside the companies that hold the fate of entire technologies in their hands?
These are surely the sort of questions that should engage our finest literary talents. The great novel of the 21st century will not be some exquisitely crafted piece of prose about authorial angst from an MFA program.
It will be a work that triumphantly closes the gap between the two cultures, a work that succeeds in conveying both the excitement of entrepreneurial capitalism while also worrying about what too much excitement means for our common humanity.
Adrian Wooldridge is the global business columnist for Bloomberg Opinion and author of “The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World.” His previous article was “The economy can’t depend on immigrant labor anymore.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.