Zohran Mamdani won the Democratic nominee for mayor of New York City, running as a democratic socialist, with a variation on the Obama coalition (upscale whites, liberals, Latinos, and other non-white workers and small business people, and young voters) and an ability to get young voters to follow him on social media, to support him, and then register and vote.
Could someone like Mamdani win in Pennsylvania? New York is an atypical city, not like the state of Pennsylvania, but Pennylvania’s demographics, particularly its religious composition, is rapidly changing to become more like New York City. And in some senses, Mamdani-like politicians have already won here.
Changing Pennsylvania
Demographically, Pennsylvania is increasing in ethnic and racial diversity. According to the Pew Research Trust’s survey of religions, in 2007, 82% of Pennsylvanians identified as Christian; in 2024, that figure was about 62%.
Mainline Protestants went from 25% to 15%; Catholics from 29% to 22%; black Protestants from 7% to 5%. The proportion of white Evangelicals (19%) and Jews (2%) remained the same. There are now as many Muslims and Hindus as Jewish Pennsylvanians.
The biggest change, however, is in the religiously unaffiliated. In 2007, 13% of Pennsylvanians identified with no religion; now the percentage is 30%. One telling figure in the Pew survey is that the number who attend church services once a week has basically halved since 2007 (39% to 22%) while the number who never attend has doubled (25% to 53%).
The political effects of these religious changes are important. One example is abortion. According to Pew, in 2007, a majority of Pennsylvanians (53%) believed that abortion should be legal in all or most cases. In 2024, 68% supported that view. In 2007, 54% of adults thought that homosexuality should be accepted; today, 70% do.
Of course, not all these changes overlay neatly onto political ideology, as the same proportion of people in 2024 say that they are conservatives, moderates, or liberals as in 2007. Indeed, more now identify with the GOP: 49% in 2024 compared to 36% in 2007. But what conservatism or liberalism meant almost 20 years ago is quite different than what they mean today.
A Mamdani here?
So, could someone like Mamdani win in Pennsylvania? Candidates similar to him already have been elected.
Pennsylvania already has a state senator, among other elected officials, associated with the Democratic Socialists of America, including Allegheny County executive Sara Innamorato.
The other Mamdani-like figure is John Fetterman. Fetterman ran as a progressive who had endorsed Bernie Sanders. Moreover, his campaign had a dynamic social media presence that skewered his opponent, Dr. Mehmet Oz, as being out of touch and, worse, out of state. He broke with decades of Pennsylvania Democratic politics, running as unabashedly pro-choice and a progressive on climate change. He won voters under 30 by 28 points.
He has changed, of course. Two years later, only 28% of young voters support him. His social media team has long since decamped over his stances on Trump and Gaza.
As a candidate, Fetterman mocked West Virginia senator Joe Manchin for his relation to the Republicans. As a senator, he resembles his erst-while nemesis and consequently is increasingly unpopular with Democrats and supported by Republicans.
The point remains, however, that Pennsylvania remains fertile ground for a populist politician who can address the economic frustrations of an increasingly diverse citizenry. Certainly, Donald Trump proved that point in 2024 when he assembled a more diverse political coalition than he did in 2016 or 2020. His success was due, in no small part, to his command over text-based social media, like X.
Speaking the people’s language
Mamdani also shows the declining political power of traditional media. According to its former public editor, the New York Times continues to campaign against him on the opinion and news pages. Likewise, the airwaves before the Democratic primary were filled with Cuomo ads, but they didn’t seem to matter.
In part, we live in a more fractured media environment than Cuomo understood. Mamdani is a master of the digital media environment that is more fractured than X, and more visual than X.
Interviewing MSNBC anchor Chris Hayes, Ezra Klein noted that Cuomo’s campaign “was based on a tried-and-true strategy of buying attention. He had this gigantic super PAC with tens of millions of dollars purchasing all the advertising money can buy, absolutely dominating airwaves with negative ads about Zohran Mamdani.” Hayes described Mamdani as “totally native to the medium of our time, which is short vertical videos in the algorithmic feed.”
In any event, the number of people reading the Times is declining, and tends to be older and more educated than the young and the working poor who are watching videos on social media. Pennsylvania’s next populist politician, whether of the left or the right, will likely be able to speak in the language that Pennsylvania’s voters recognize as their own.
John Hinshaw is a professor of history at Lebanon Valley College. His previous article was “A history of voting in Pennsylvania, starting with William Penn.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.