Elon Musk’s announcement that he plans to launch a new political party set off a firestorm of criticism, particulary from his former ally President Donald Trump, who called the idea “ridiculous.”
No third party has truly broken the two-party structure that has dominated American politics for over 170 years. Here are some examples.
TR and George Wallace
Theodore Roosevelt’s Bull Moose Party. When Theodore Roosevelt, president from 1901 to 1909, failed to secure the Republican nomination in 1912, he formed his own party, known as the Progressive or Bull Moose Party.
In its platform, the party said that the Democratic and Republican parties had become “the tools of corrupt interests which use them impartially to serve their selfish purposes.”
Roosevelt lost to Democrat Woodrow Wilson. But he came in second, garnering 27.4% of the popular vote, ahead of Republican incumbent William Howard Taft’s 23.2%, and 88 electoral college votes. He effectively split the Republican vote.
Adam Smith, director of the Rothermere American Institute, said the 1912 election was unique because Roosevelt was “an extremely popular, charismatic” former president while Taft was “very unpopular [and] uncharismatic.” But the Progressive Party disappeared shortly after the election.
The lesson, Smith said, is that as political parties have grown into bigger tents encompassing many ideologies, it makes more sense for insurgent candidates to try to “capture” one of the parties and its existing funding and campaign infrastructure than to try to start one from scratch, noting the success of Trump in 2024.
George Wallace’s American Independent Party. George Wallace, the four-time Democratic governor of Alabama, was a well-known segregationist who led the movement against the racial integration of schools in the 1960s.
In 1968, he ran for president as the candidate of the newly formed American Independent Party, with a platform focused on states’ rights, farmers, anti-elitism, and law and order. Although Republican Richard M. Nixon won the election, Wallace won 13.5% of the popular vote and 46 electoral college votes.
Perot, the Libertarians and the Greens
Ross Perot’s Reform Party. In 1992, tech entrepreneur Ross Perot ran as an independent, focused on fiscal responsibility and opposition to gun control and to the North American Free Trade Agreement.
His competitors were Republican President George H.W. Bush, who faced criticism for his handling of the economy, and Democratic candidate Bill Clinton, who was dogged by scandals, including allegations of a years-long extramarital affair.
Clinton won the election with 43% of the popular vote, and Perot got 18.9%, drawing in voters who could have swung the election for Bush.
“When he got almost 19% of the vote, both Republicans and Democrats came together and balanced the budget,” said Barbara Perry of the University of Virginia. “The success of his campaign was like a tip from the American people saying: ‘You better pay attention to this. If you don’t pay attention, then something worse is going to happen to you in the next election.’”
Perot started the Reform Party in 1995, and ran as its candidate in the 1996 election. He secured 8.4% of the popular vote, and Clinton was reelected. Perot eventually became estranged from the party and its leadership. In 2000, he endorsed Republican nominee George W. Bush over the Reform nominee, Pat Buchanan. But the party continued to exist, and in 1999, Trump even said he would explore running for president as its candidate.
Libertarian Party. The Libertarian Party was established in Colorado in 1971 and put forward its first candidate in the presidential election of 1972. It was created to promote small government and individual liberties.
In the years since, the party’s candidates have typically won about 1% of the popular vote or less. In 2016, former New Mexico governor Gary Johnson won 3% of the vote, the party’s best result in its history. In 2024, Libertarian candidate Chase Oliver received just under 0.5%.
Green Party. The Green Party formed out of several local and national environmental movements of the 1980s and ’90s and applied for recognition by the Federal Election Commission in 2001. It stands for “10 key values,” including “environmental justice,” “respect for diversity” and “feminism and gender equity.”
The party’s candidates typically get a low share of votes, Jill Stein in 2024 earned just 0.6%. But in 2000, lawyer and activist Ralph Nader won 2.74%, enough that many prominent Democrats, including Joe Biden, blamed him for costing their party’s nominee, Al Gore, the razor-thin election and helping to elect George W. Bush instead.
A spoiler party
“Generally speaking, over the last 100 or so years, the function of third parties in American politics has been as spoilers,” Smith said. In elections where the competition between two main candidates is close, a third-party candidate can tilt an election by winning just 2 or 3% of the vote.
Smith said that the most likely scenario for Musk’s potential new party —- which Musk has said will be called the America Party — is that he will create something similar to the Libertarian Party, and that it might be able to secure “two or three percentage points nationwide if it gets on the ballot in all 50 states and therefore can be a spoiler to one or the other of the main political parties — presumably, in this case, mostly a danger to the Republican Party.”
Annabelle Timsit is a breaking news reporter for the Washington Post's London hub.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.