Until recently, many attacks on U.S. Jews have stemmed from long-standing conspiracies and antisemitic tropes, but since Oct. 7, 2023 — when Hamas attacked Israel, setting off the ongoing Israel-Gaza war — such incidents are increasingly related to Israel or Zionism.
Attacks against the Jewish community have been growing for years, but increasingly, perpetrators are citing Israel’s war in Gaza, blurring the line between opposing the Israeli government and opposing Jewish people.
“For antisemites, the Israel issue has been a convenient tactic to pile onto the Jewish community,” said Oren Segal, a Anti-Defamation League senior vice president. Some people intentionally conflate being Jewish with support for the Israeli government, he said.
More negative Americans
In 2024, 58% of antisemitic incidents “contained elements related to Israel or Zionism,” according to annual antisemitism report released this year. That has risen since the group began tracking the data with a new definition two years ago. Since Israel’s post-Oct. 7 war in Gaza began, polls have shown that more Americans have negative views about Israel, and support for the Palestinian solidarity movement has grown stronger.
The overlap is complicating life for many U.S. Jews and Jewish organizations living with increasing antisemitism and the deep divisions sparked by the war in Gaza.
“People like me made arguments for years about how you should be able to criticize Israel and not be seen as antisemitic. Now that’s collapsed, and attacks on Zionism now target Jews. They see no difference, and so here we are,” said Joel Rubin, a deputy assistant secretary of state under President Barack Obama and Jewish outreach adviser to Sen. Bernie Sanders’ 2020 presidential campaign.
With antisemitic incidents at historic levels, some American Jews say they feel like a political football and that it can be agonizing at times to tell the difference between prejudice and criticism of the Israeli government.
Jews in the U.S. “have a real psychological challenge in this moment,” said Dove Kent, U.S. senior director of the Diaspora Alliance, a progressive group that works to fight the weaponization of antisemitism. “Whenever there is an increase in Israeli lethal action, there is an increase in antisemitism directed at Jews. But Jews don’t cause antisemitism.”
“Conversations about if and when these attacks [in the United States] are antisemitic are only useful to the degree they help us understand how to stop them,” she said. “Otherwise it’s almost just an exercise — a thing that has the potential to grab people’s attention and cause fractures among people who are otherwise completely aligned that we need to stop these attacks.”
More antisemitic events
This trend has become more apparent after a recent series of antisemitic events. In April, the residence of Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, who is Jewish, was set on fire by a man who allegedly blamed him for Middle East violence against Palestinians. A month later, two Israeli Embassy employees were fatally shot as they left a reception at a Jewish museum in D.C. by a man who yelled “Free, free Palestine.” And Sunday, Mohamed Sabry Soliman, 45, allegedly used a flame thrower to attack a Jewish event in Colorado.
All three incidents reflect rising antisemitism, but they also have a common feature: The alleged perpetrators cited their objections to Israel’s war in Gaza as part of their motives. Soliman “said this had nothing to do with the Jewish community and was specific [to] the Zionist group,” according to Boulder police.
While the war in Gaza has fueled criticism of Israel from some on the left, even among some politically left-leaning Jews, many U.S. Jews have also said the administration of President Donald Trump shares some blame for a more hostile climate.
During his last presidential campaign, Trump said Jewish voters would be to blame if he lost — despite being only 2% of the population. Harrison Fields, a White House press secretary, wrote that “the Trump administration is the most pro-Israel and pro-Jewish in our nation’s history, and the President’s record stands as a testament to this commitment.”
Multiple Jewish leaders have been critical of Trump and some administration officials for using antisemitism as a rationale for deporting immigrants and eliminating some diversity initiatives, stoking backlash.
“Since Trump came in they are weaponizing Jewish fear to advance a very specific agenda,” said Kevin Rachlin, Washington director of the Nexus Project, which advocates against antisemitism and for free speech. “What will you do to protect us? Shutting down and defunding schools, deporting people? That doesn’t protect Jews.”
What’s changed
U.S. Jews are wary equally of both conservatives and liberals, according to a 2024 survey by the American Jewish Committee. Asked “how much of an antisemitic threat” the extremes represent, 55% said the far right is a very serious or moderate threat, and 57% said that of the far left.
Jews outside of Israel have long been attacked by people trying to change Mideast policy, Rachlin said. But those attacks have taken on a new dimension in recent years, he said.
What’s changed is the very high death toll in Israel and Gaza, the growth among young Americans — compared with older ones — in sympathy for the Palestinian cause, and, Rachlin said: the internet.
“We see everything that’s happening. Nothing is hidden, and no amount of spin can turn away video. You can see bad actors in both camps.”
Michelle Boorstein is a religion reporter and Ben Brasch a National Breaking News reporter for The Washington Post.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.