‘Marcel Ophuls’ best-known work, “The Sorrow and the Pity” (1969), chronicled life in the central French city of Clermont-Ferrand during Nazi occupation. The film is a testament to the way even normally upstanding individuals can behave reprehensibly under extreme circumstances.
The son of celebrated German filmmaker Max Ophuls, whose movies confronted wrenching questions about conscience, memory and human nature, died last week.
Why did the French accept Nazism?
“It’s one of the most demanding films ever made,” movie critic Pauline Kael wrote in the New Yorker. “There’s a point of view, but judgments are left to you, and you know that Ophuls is reasonable and fair-minded and trying to do justice to a great subject: How and why the French accepted Nazism, and then rejected what they had done, so that it was lost even from public memory.”
“The Sorrow and the Pity” — more than four hours in length — featured interviews with public figures, but arguably more affecting were the workaday people Mr. Ophuls captured on film, including the elderly bourgeois man who says that his principal memory of the German occupation was the incredible hunting season of 1942.
When he rose to political power after the war, Gen. Charles de Gaulle — in a landmark speech on the steps of the Panthéon in Paris — said that France was a nation of resisters, words that became something of a foundational creed for a broken nation desperate to move on. “The Sorrow and the Pity” was a forceful, myth-shattering rejoinder to what had been collectively forgotten.
Following the radical student upheavals of 1968, French newspapers began publishing exposés of sitting government ministers who had also served in the wartime Vichy government. Scholars began examining the extent of that regime’s collaboration with Nazi Germany, in light of anti-Semitic strains in French society.
Shock waves
But nothing captured or provoked the public imagination more than “The Sorrow and the Pity.” Originally intended for French television, distribution of “The Sorrow and the Pity” was blocked in the country for nearly a decade, stymied by high-ranking critics. One said the film “fell into this concert of self-flagellation, and it was on those grounds that I found this film unjust and partisan.”
When it finally aired on French public television, “The Sorrow and the Pity” sent shock waves through a society that had yet to come to terms with its wartime past, especially the reality that French authorities had facilitated the deportations of some 76,000 Jews to Nazi concentration camps during the German occupation from 1940 to 1944.
For years, “The Sorrow and the Pity” was shown only in one Paris theater, although it became a cultural touchstone outside France almost immediately and a favorite of movie critics.
Mr. Ophuls continued examining his signature subject matter: wartime atrocities and how societies choose to forget them. In “The Harvest of My Lai” (1970), he explored the My Lai Massacre perpetrated by U.S. soldiers in Vietnam.
Six years later, he made “The Memory of Justice,” an acclaimed look at war crimes from the Nuremberg trials to Vietnam, featuring interviews with such disparate historical figures as anti-Vietnam whistleblower Daniel Ellsberg and Hitler’s chief architect, Albert Speer.
Mr. Ophuls received his profession’s highest honor for “Hôtel Terminus,” his film about the barbarous legacy of Gestapo officer Klaus Barbie. Nicknamed the “Butcher of Lyon” for his crimes, Barbie oversaw the roundup and deportation of French Jews in the early 1940s and later fled to South America. He was sentenced to life in prison for crimes against humanity and died in 1991.
“Making this film is like an intense fight for the survival of memory itself,” Mr. Ophuls told The Washington Post at the time. “I want Barbie to be judged so that what he did is burned into history and will never happen again.”
The film ends with a long interview with a survivor, a woman from Lyon who, as a child, was arrested in one of Barbie’s raids and ultimately deported to Nazi concentration camps. As her family was being taken, one of her neighbors, a French woman who was not Jewish, tried unsuccessfully to pull the young girl to safety. Mr. Ophuls ultimately dedicated the film to the neighbor.
We must always take sides
“It comes down to that, doesn’t it?” he told the Globe and Mail. “The realistic hope is that next time there will be more good neighbors. The possibly unrealistic hope is that next time there will be enough good neighbors to keep it from happening at all.”
In all his work, he said, objectivity was not his goal. “We must always take sides,” he told The Post in 2017. “Neutrality only helps the oppressor. Never the victim. If you want to defend your point of view, and not in some way lie down in front of the powers that be, it takes more courage.”
James McAuley is a Global Opinions contributing columnist for the Washington Post.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.