In a sweeping “Dear Colleague” letter in February, the U.S. Department of Education claimed that in the last four years, our educational institutions “have discriminated against students on the basis of race, including white and Asian students.” To combat this discrimination, the letter demands that educational institutions halt diversity, equity and inclusion programs or risk the loss of federal funding.

The assertion that white students are now a primary target of discrimination in U.S. educational institutions seems on its face to be inconsistent with the history of our country. But it is consistent with the belief, shared by the majority of Americans, that our nation has made rapid gains toward racial equality and that the gains have been so large that formerly privileged groups are now being targeted.

A false belief

I am a social psychologist. I study how mischaracterizations of racial inequality are widespread in society and distort policy related to discrimination, bias and racial equity.

Advertise with us

When asked in surveys, both Black and white Americans, as well as both liberals and conservatives, believe that society has progressed toward racial equality. They believe society is rapidly, and perhaps even automatically, becoming more equal between white people and other groups.

The picture is more complex. For instance, white Americans still hold advantages in wages, income, health insurance and wealth compared with Black Americans. Across each of these domains, progress has been slow or stagnant. The wealth gap between Black and white Americans is still around $13 for Black families for every $100 held by white ones, the same as it was in the 1980s.

In more recent recent, we have found that both Black and white working adults estimate that Black men and women are likely to be overrepresented in management relative to the populations of these groups in the U.S. Federal data indicate that manager representation is not moving toward racial equality, much less minority overrepresentation.

Anti-diversity illusions

These misperceptions create an illusion of American life suggesting that society is either rapidly approaching a racial utopia or rapidly changing into a country where white influence is waning. It is not.

Advertise with us

The Dear Colleague letter is based on these illusions. It asserts that structural racism is a “false premise.” This assertion has no grounding in history, science or lived experience. It also asserts that diversity programs “stigmatize students who belong to particular racial groups based on crude racial stereotypes,” but provides no examples of programs where this has occurred.

These events are clarifying. They suggest that resistance to anti-diversity efforts can come through public campaigns to combat the misperceptions of racial progress the efforts rest upon.

Helping people understand that history, science and personal experience are all consistent with the persistence of racism in the U.S. can help all of us reject narratives that America has achieved or overshot a racial utopia. Ideas that diversity programs discriminate against white people are inconsistent with the reality that our educational institutions, our health care facilities and our workplaces are diverse and require skills and competencies to navigate those dynamics.

Indications of hope

To be sure, grounding our understanding of racial equality in reality will not be enough, but there are some indications of hope. Many people value diversity in national polls, and belongingness at work is something that all people benefit from. Through combating these illusions with evidence, we can support our communities in rejecting these false anti-diversity narratives.

Michael W. Kraus is a professor of psychology and Morton O. Schapiro faculty fellow at the Institute for Policy Research at Northwestern University.