President Donald Trump’s efforts to mute Voice of America and other U.S.-government-funded international broadcasters, stifling America’s voice around the world, strips the United States of one of its most venerable and effective instruments of soft power.
As with so many of the president’s decrees, the answers to many questions remained unclear, including whether Trump had the legal authority to cut off the outlets, and whether they would be revised or fully dismantled.
The “radios”
Global Media is an umbrella agency that oversees VOA and several other global media “radios,” as they’ve been collectively known — including the Office of Cuba Broadcasting, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, Radio Free Asia and Middle East Broadcasting Networks. Also under the umbrella is the Open Technology Fund, formally started in 2019, which supports uncensored internet access to over 2 billion people.
Collectively, the outlets reached more than 425 million listeners or viewers worldwide. VOA, which counted about 360 million of those people in nearly 50 languages, fell silent immediately.
No one would dispute that the radios, most with their origins in World War II and the Cold War, required updating for a rapidly changing world with rapidly evolving technology.
But they were emphatically not a waste of money or effort. For millions of people worldwide — especially in places like Russia, China, Iran and Venezuela, where access to information is jealously controlled by authoritarian regimes — the American radios were a source of trusted news and information about the world and, more important, their own countries. For many Russians, Radio Liberty was the main source of reliable information about the war in Ukraine.
The radios were also a window into America and a Western culture of openness, democracy, press freedom and civil liberties — the sort of outreach that defines “soft power,” the ability to influence the world and project American values without resorting to arms, threats, insults or punitive tariffs.
I spent many years as a correspondent in the Soviet Union and then Russia, and can testify to the extraordinary influence of the Western broadcasts — most notably the Russian-language broadcasts by VOA, Radio Liberty, the BBC and Deutsche Welle. In the Soviet era, all were consistently “jammed.”
People quickly learned how to listen anyway, either in rural areas free of jamming or by tuning to the edge of the frequency. Some recorded the broadcasts, and the tapes and transcripts quickly spread through underground networks.
Strict objectivity
I was especially familiar with the Radio Liberty broadcasts during my years in the Soviet Union because my father, Alexander Schmemann, an Eastern Orthodox priest and theologian, had a weekly program in Russian about religion and culture. The show was popular. Many dissidents I met tuned in regularly, Alexander Solzhenitsyn for one.
Most important was news, which was the central mission of all Western stations. While at college, I was an intern one summer on the Radio Liberty news desk, and the strict guiding rule was objectivity. The people behind the Iron Curtain who risked tuning in to a foreign broadcast, I was told, were allergic to propaganda, and would not take a big risk to get more of it.
Not surprisingly, Russia and China rejoiced at the news from Washington. “This is an awesome decision by Trump,” declared the editor of Russia’s huge state-controlled international propaganda network, RT. “We couldn’t shut them down, unfortunately, but America did so itself.” China’s Global Times gloated that the station had now been “discarded like a dirty rag.”
Russians who had relied on Radio Liberty, meanwhile, mourned. Editors of Novaya Gazeta Europe, successors to a newspaper banned in Russia, wrote on their site that their work “will become more difficult without Radio Liberty, and many Russians will lose access to important information about what is happening in their country.”
“During the Cold War, VOA was a lifeline for those living under tyranny, and its mission was equally relevant today,” Michael Abramowitz, the head of VOA, wrote me in an email. “Our agency was an important instrument for combating false narratives about the United States that are pushed by American geopolitical rivals like China, Iran and Russia. Those countries are spending billions on information warfare, and closing VOA will unilaterally disarm America.”
Musk’s chain saw
A recent White House statement referred to VOA as “the Voice of Radical America.” It appears, however, that Elon Musk — who declared VOA to be a nest of “radical left crazy people”— set his chain saw onto the radios first.
What next? Like other Trump executive orders, the legality of this one is moot. Congress chartered the agency as an independent one, and the lawsuits have begun. Many Republicans were supporters of international broadcasting, but this is another battle that they seem not to be fighting. The silence is deafening.
Serge Schmemann is a member of the editorial board of the New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “Putin has been very bad for Russia.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.