During the recent election season, pundits, politicians, and journalists to the left of center consistently referred to Donald Trump’s proposed tariffs as a tax on the American people. Many of those to the right of center, especially those of the MAGA contingent, seemed to think they are a pain-free way for the federal government to raise money and protect American companies.

The history of tariffs

The federal government essentially ran on tariffs for over 120 years. Alexander Hamilton, the first Treasury Secretary, implemented a tariff system to fund the young American government and protect young American businesses against competition from established foreign companies. The second bill President George Washington signed was a broad tariff bill.

While an income tax was imposed during the Civil War it was repealed in 1872 and the Supreme Court ruled it unconstitutional in 1895. The modern income tax did not come into effect until after the 16th Amendment to the Constitution was ratified in 1913.

While the concept of free trade and the related idea of each nation pursuing its own “comparative advantage” has been around for a long time, it did not become normalized in the United States until the mid-20th century.

Advertise with us

Trump’s tariff proposals obviously have some protectionist sentiment and thus are contrary to the idea of free trade. However, he has also suggested extreme tariff proposals intended to influence the behavior of other countries and to punish them for unfair trade practices.

Contrary to those on the left, tariffs are not a direct tax on Americans, and contrary to the MAGA element of the right, they are not pain-free. But where do they fall on that spectrum of being a direct tax on you versus a pain-free revenue source?

Tariffs are not a direct tax on the American consumer. They are a government-imposed cost to doing business with foreign producers. They are paid directly by the importer of applicable products, typically an American company, and not the foreign producer. At some level, the importer will simply stop bringing the product in because it will be too expensive.

If those foreign products are no longer imported, the American consumer demand will shift to competitive and substitute products made here in America. This demand applied to a lower supply will, in the short term, increase the price. It is not a tax on the consumer, but it is not pain-free either.

Not a tax nor pain-free

Over time, some of this price increase will be tempered because American producers will increase their volumes in response to the higher price — and by extension, new jobs may be created. However, in the end, American consumers will pay more.

Advertise with us

This is not exclusive to tariffs. Essentially all government activity increases costs to the consumer, be it taxing, spending, regulating, or levying tariffs.

What would happen with an increase in the tariff rate that did not stop foreign companies from selling them to America? If Trump implements a lower tariff, say 10%, on all foreign-produced widgets, what will happen?

Economics has a concept called the price elasticity of demand. The idea is that changes in price change consumer demand. Those changes in demand range from highly inelastic (a relatively small change in demand relative to the change in price), to highly elastic (a relatively large change in demand relative to the change in price). Price increases result in demand decreases and vice versa.

A product would have “unitary” elasticity if a given percentage change in price (say 10%) would cause a similar percentage change in demand. This measure is different for each product, depending on its nature and depending on other market conditions.

It is hard to say what will happen with any given product, but let’s look at a hypothetical for a widget that has unitary elasticity if a 10% tariff is applied. Assuming the importer and the rest of the domestic distribution system, including the retailer, pass this increase in cost along to the consumer, demand will decline by 10%.

Advertise with us

However, foreign manufacturers will not like how this affects their sales volume and profits. They may reduce their price to the importer by 3%, resulting in a net increase of 7% to the importer.

If this is passed on to the consumer, the demand now will only decrease by 7%. But the importer and the rest of the distribution system are not happy with this either and they collectively reduce their prices by 4% such that the net increase to the consumer is only 3%. Consumers then buy 3% less product, while paying 3% more for it.

No one’s completely happy

None of the participants in these adjustments are happy. But they all share in the cost, and the government collects that 10% in revenue. Domestic producers also likely increase their prices a bit and make a little more profit. Domestic companies may be a little protected from competition.

We might like to think the government will reduce our taxes accordingly, but don’t count on that.

In the end, tariffs — reasonable, not extreme tariffs — are neither a direct tax on you nor a pain-free way to protect domestic companies and raise money for the government. They are a tool used by nation-states for several purposes. Any given tariff can have both positive and negative impacts.

David Butler is a business executive and entrepreneur.