The Secretary General of NATO, Mark Rutte, has said that the West is not prepared for the challenges that will come over the next five years and that it’s time to “shift to a wartime mindset.”
Kori Schake, who directs foreign and defense policy studies at the American Enterprise Institute, writes that “a world war is approaching.” The closer cooperation between China, Russia, Iran and North Korea make a coordinated attack more likely, meaning we may have to fight three or four regional wars simultaneously.
The weak U.S. industrial base has hollowed out American resilience. China’s shipbuilding industry has a capacity more than 230 times greater than that of the United States. When experts recently conducted war games with China, the United States ran out of long-range anti-ship missiles within three to seven days.
The Chinese have developed a powerful microwave weapon that has the intensity of a nuclear explosion and can disrupt or destroy electronic components of our weapons systems. H.R. McMaster, the former national security adviser, recently said, “I think China is laying the groundwork for a first-strike nuclear capability against the United States.”
In 2023, the RAND Corp. issued a report on U.S. military that what we expect it to do exceeds “the means that are available to accomplish those tasks.”
Unasked questions
Now, if you are holding hearings for a prospective secretary of defense, you would think you might want to ask him about these urgent issues. This did not happen at the Pete Hegseth hearings.
We live in a soap opera country. We live in a social media/cable TV country. In our culture you don’t want to focus on topics that would require study; you focus on images and easy-to-understand issues that generate instant visceral reactions.
You don’t win this game by engaging in serious thought; you win by mere attitudinizing — by striking a pose. Your job is not to advance an argument that might help the country; your job is to go viral.
Pete Hegseth is of course the living, breathing embodiment of this culture. The world is on fire and what’s his obsession? Wokeness in the military. During the hearings he repeatedly said he was going to defend the meritocracy. In what kind of meritocracy is being a Fox TV host preparation for being secretary of defense?
Democrats played their own culture war games. Sen. Elizabeth Warren submitted over 30 pages of written question to Hegseth before the hearing. They had to do with things like drinking, accusations of sexual assault, threats to LGBTQ rights and veterans benefits. She didn’t show much interest in topics like how to deter and fight a war — which are kind of central.
Some good questions
The hearings got better as they went along and more junior senators got to speak. Sen. Mazie Hirono was excellent, asking substantive questions: If the president ordered you, would you order troops to shoot protesters in the legs? Would you follow an order to use the military for mass deportations?
Sen. Tammy Duckworth was outstanding, too, asking about the big responsibilities of the job: Does Hegseth know anything about the ongoing international negotiations? Does he know which countries are in the ASEAN bloc? (The answers are no and no.)
The lesson for Democrats over the next four years is clear: Don’t fly into moral outrage every day. Focus on Trumpian incompetence.
Overall, Republicans were the more serious party at these hearings. The committee chair, Sen. Roger Wicker, did note that we live in the most dangerous security environment since World War II. Sen. Tim Sheehy did mention shipbuilding. Sen. Ted Budd did ask about warplanes. Sen. Eric Schmitt did ask about drones.
We need to come up with a better way to think about expertise. Hegseth’s core populist conviction — repeated ad nauseam — is that the grunts on the ground know what they are doing and the pencil-necked geeks in air-conditioned offices just write nonsense regulations that get in the way.
The man wasted years at Princeton and Harvard when he could have learned everything he knows by watching that Col. Jessup speech at the end of “A Few Good Men.”
We don’t want to live in a populist paradise in which expertise is suspect and ignorance a sign of virtue. Nor do we want to live in an elitist world in which technocrats try to rule the world.
We need to settle upon a place where experts are respected and inform decision-making, but civilians make the ultimate calls. In a healthy democracy, people revere great learning on substantive issues.
Short attention spans
They understand the world is too complex to be captured in bite-size slogans, but they also appreciate the wisdom that comes from concrete experience and know that most hard calls have to be made in light of the deeply held values that have made America what it is.
All of this has been corrupted by the war for short attention spans. In the 19th century we had the Lincoln-Douglas debates.
Today it would be the Lincoln-Douglas TikTok wars followed by “Three Takeaways From the Lincoln-Douglas Debates” followed by a panel of pundits (like me) analyzing whether Stephen Douglas helped himself with swing voters in DuPage County.
Can this kind of country prevail in a global conflict of systems? Maybe, but maybe not.
David Brooks is a columnist for the New York Times.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.