Several vegetarian and vegan friends, and a spate of celebrities including Lizzo, Miley Cyrus and Bear Grylls, have reverted to eating meat, while no one seems to be going the other way. (I’ve been a vegetarian for the last seven years, but I sometimes eat fish and meat.)
Food choices matter, at least on a macro scale. Governments seeking to reach net zero greenhouse gas emissions will have to clean up their nations’ plates.
Diet and gas
In the UK, where I live, agriculture accounted for an estimated 12% of greenhouse gas emissions in 2023. Food makes up about 30% of the carbon footprint of a typical household in high-income European countries. Most of that footprint comes from animal products, with livestock farming accounting for 14.5% of global emissions.
The Climate Change Committee (CCC), an independent advisory body, has recommended that UK meat consumption come down 20% by 2030. A 2019 report for the CCC by Richard Carmichael of Imperial College London says that halving consumption of animal products by avoiding the highest-impact producers would achieve 73% of the emissions reduction made from switching to entirely plant-based diets.
A few years ago it felt like there was a lot of momentum behind the transition to plant-based (or at least plant-heavy) diets. New alternative proteins from companies including Impossible Foods and Beyond Meat were hitting the market, and there was a boom in specialist vegan eateries.
These days, Beyond Meat’s stock price has plummeted, and there’s a rash of stories about vegan restaurants having to add meat to their menus in order to survive.
So what’s happening to our eating habits?
In the UK, total meat consumption has been slowly declining, falling to a record low in 2021. While cheese consumption has increased slightly, consumption of semi-skimmed milk peaked in 2012. Meanwhile, non-dairy milk substitutes have climbed, but still represents only a fraction of cow’s milk being quaffed.
In the past few years, price has almost certainly been a factor. But our diets have changed a lot since the 1970s, and I suspect the long-term declines in meat consumption are thanks in part to the globalization of food. We didn’t just start importing more produce, but we’ve been more exposed to plant-based recipes from different cultures.
Nervous politicians
In that half-century, vegetarianism and veganism have become far easier and more socially acceptable. That has ripple effects as meat eaters can also now enjoy more flexible dining selections. But left to society and markets, things are moving too slowly to meet targets for meat consumption.
Several things swayed my friends back to animal products, including romantic partners, concerns over ultra-processed foods or merely feeling that they were alone in their endeavors. Given governments have generally avoided policies nudging people toward more sustainable diets, it’s no surprise that people are returning to what those around them are doing.
There’s also a lesson for policy in this shift. The failure of vegan restaurants reflects the fact that an exclusive approach is less effective. Vegans and vegetarians socialize with those who eat meat. A social group would likely pick a location where everyone can eat happily.
Having both options also normalizes plant-based meals — they are, after all, just food — and makes them more accessible to those who don’t identify as vegan but may want to try a particular dish. Such an approach could be taken with catering at government-funded institutions such as schools and hospitals, which provide 30% of meals in the UK.
But with meat drawn into the culture wars and farmers already angry about a range of policy changes, this is an area that lawmakers are nervous about. At the United Nations climate conference in Azerbaijan, UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer insisted that he won’t “tell people how to run their lives.”
Flexitarian health
In the end, the impetus to coax people further toward a more flexitarian practice — where meals are more heavily plant-based but meat, dairy and fish are enjoyed in moderation — may come from another source: public health.
Although meat consumption has declined overall, there’s been a steady rise in ready meals and processed meats, which has led to overconsumption of saturated fat and salt. In England, 64% of adults were estimated to be overweight or living with obesity in 2022 to 2023. This puts strain on the National Health Service. Obesity costs it £6.5 billion ($8.1 billion) a year and is the second-biggest preventable cause of cancer.
Helping people eat healthier diets with more fruit, vegetables and fiber would have enormous benefits for human well-being and the planet. Research suggests that reducing average meat consumption to two to three servings a week could prevent 45,000 deaths and save the National Health Service £1.2 billion a year.
Governments can’t ignore the diet question forever.
Lara Williams is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.