What does not kill me makes me stronger. Friedrich Nietzsche’s aphorism has always inspired me as a great life hack for snatching optimism from the jaws of despair. Might it also apply to democracy?

For lovers of freedom and democracy (I’m equating the two for these purposes) the news has been grim for at least 18 years, according to Freedom House. That’s how long the world has been in a democratic recession, with more countries each year trampling on, rather than cherishing, civil rights and political liberties.

Backsliding

The downward trend seems to be accelerating, not only in places like coup-wracked Africa but also in the West. In Hungary, Viktor Orban has methodically subdued checks and balances in the media, courts, universities, parliament and business to turn the country into an autocracy in all but name. That’s made him a role model for Donald Trump, who appears bent on doing something similar in his second term as American president.

The strongmen have lots of copycats. South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol just made a hash of his grasp for authoritarian power. An unpopular incumbent who (like Trump) has described his opposition as domestic “enemies,” he attempted a de facto coup last week by declaring martial law out of the blue. Fortunately, parliament, the press and the country rose up in defiance, and the putsch was over in a matter of hours.

Advertise with us

Elsewhere, democracies long considered stable and mature keep playing into a populist narrative by showing themselves to be feckless travesties. In eerie synchronization, governments in both France and Germany have recently collapsed while trying to pass a bog-standard budget. The French one lost a parliamentary motion of no confidence last week, the German one will do so next week. Democracy, it may appear to cynics, not only fails to solve problems: It sometimes is the problem.

Temptation to pessimism

Among the causes for this spreading disenchantment, the easiest to identify is deliberate disinformation spread by the enemies of democracy, above all Russian President Vladimir Putin. His trolls, bots and meme sorcerers have been messing with Western voters’ minds so deviously that many citizens in democracies surrender to the nihilism that, as one author frames Putin’s strategy, “nothing is true and everything is possible.”

Others turn their backs on democracy because it rarely seems to cure the larger banes of life, such as inequality and the resulting alienation and frustration of entire segments of societies. If democracies can’t rectify glaring injustices, why not give your local autocrat a spin or two?

And then, of course, there’s that subcutaneous but potent serum which the French call ennui. If you’ve always lived in a democracy and still don’t like your life, you might be drawn to charismatic and radical authoritarians out of sheer boredom and disillusionment. Whatever else you think about the Trump-Musk reality show, it’s more entertaining than the current White House.

Pessimism is tempting. It often does seem as if modern democracy is dying a slow death before our eyes. But there’s still Nietzsche: Our democracies are definitely being tested, and battered in the process. But if they survive, they may yet come out stronger.

Advertise with us

Invigorated democracy

The intuition underneath Nietzsche’s aphorism is that we should view life’s challenges as antigens which provoke an immune response. Remove all antigens, and the immune system may turn on itself and cause autoimmune diseases; in the context of democracy, I’ll call that ennui. Overwhelm the system with a killer bug, and it may fail. Keep it busy, though, and it will sustain and invigorate us.

Let’s take another look at South Korea. Older citizens are still traumatized by their earlier experiences with dictatorship and martial law (last imposed in 1980), and South Koreans are proud of the vibrant democracy they’ve built since then. Yoon didn’t understand that. When he went on television to announce his coup, something clicked and all of society rallied: not only the opposition but also most of Yoon’s own base in parliament, the press and the population. Yoon will probably be impeached now; in any event, his name and career are ruined.

What about America? Intellectuals are already in the weeds trying to figure out whether its Insurrection Act, say, does or does not resemble South Korea’s martial law, and whether Trump will pull a Yoon. The answer is: If Trump installs enough cronies (he’s certainly trying), he could.

The more pertinent question then becomes how the immune system of the oldest continuous democracy will react. Will conservatives — in the media, Congress and electorate — join with other Americans, even ones they’ve become accustomed to loathe, and resist? Will Republicans in the Senate and House — or Fox News — veto the coup as their analogs in South Korea did this week?

It’s an open question. Which is good, because it remains possible that in time freedom in the United States, and by extension the world, emerges stronger than ever before.

Andreas Kluth is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. His previous article was “We're no longer as threatened by terrorists as we used to be.”