Red versus blue divides Americans today, but in the 1800s, pumpkin pie versus sweet potato pie signaled political and cultural discord. The pumpkin was a symbol of Yankee virtue and small, sustainable farming that didn’t rely on enslaved labor.
“There was a huge plumb pudding, custards and pies of every name and description ever known in Yankee land; yet the pumpkin pie occupied the most distinguished niche,” Sarah Josepha Hale, an abolitionist and the 1800s version of a lifestyle influencer, wrote in 1827.
“In the 19th century,” said Cindy Ott, a historian at the University of Delaware, “some of the people that wrote the most saccharine sweet stories and themes about pumpkins were also really powerful abolitionists. They saw these pumpkin landscapes in terms of the moral virtue embedded in them, versus the South.”
Good and true Thanksgiving
Hale called pumpkin pie “an indispensable part of a good and true Yankee Thanksgiving; the size of the pie usually denoting the gratitude of the party who prepares the feast,” in her 1827 novel “Northwood: a Tale of New England.”
While the pumpkin pie was an iconic part of New England cooking, the South went another direction. For Southerners, pumpkin was food of the poor, not “this romantic, Yeoman farmer” or a “Jeffersonian ideal.”
In the South, Ott said, pumpkins “had different meanings. The idea of the small-scale farm was associated with tenant farmers, and could be, you know, a term of derision against Black people.”
She added, “To this day, they eat sweet potato pie for Thanksgiving instead of pumpkin pie, because it just meant something different.” Sweet potato pie was “what African American women under enslavement and then afterward” made because sweet potatoes are an African plant.
It was Hale, the lifestyle guru of Victorian America, who championed Thanksgiving as a unified, national holiday. She was a famous writer — ever heard of “Mary Had a Little Lamb”? — an activist and the editor of “Godey’s Lady’s Book,” the most widely circulated magazine in America before the Civil War.
Her odes to the pumpkin and pumpkin pie — the symbols she used in her 40-year campaign for a national Thanksgiving holiday — were the Pinterest boards of their time.
Eventually, her letter that hit its mark was sent in 1863 to President Abraham Lincoln, asking him to make Thanksgiving on the same day for all the states so that it will “become permanently, an American custom and institution.”
Lincoln’s proclamation
Lincoln, looking for ways to unite a tattered country amid the Civil War, issued a proclamation that Americans all sit down together.
“In the midst of a civil war of unequaled magnitude and severity, which has sometimes seemed to foreign states to invite and provoke their aggressions,” the proclamation said, not shying away from the strife at hand and suggesting the bounty of the harvest comes despite “our national perverseness and disobedience.”
If there were bumper stickers, flags and pins with pumpkins to support that, the Northerners would’ve been all over them.
The South, however, hated the proclamation. Not only because of the in-your-face pumpkin worship that Hale and her supporters were using, but because they also saw it as a states’ rights issue. The editorials berating the proclamation were scathing.
“The darling scheme of Lincolnites is to obliterate the States — to silence them as organs and mediums of communication with the people,” the Macon Telegraph wrote on Oct. 14, 1863. States had already been celebrating less formal Thanksgivings, they said. So why would Lincoln ask for a national day?
It was, the paper declared, “to supersede State appointments, and teach the people to look to the Federal Government for hollidays [sic] as well as everything else.”
Virginia was independent about its Thanksgiving, celebrating on Nov. 15, 1855, to set it apart from the Nov. 29 dates other governors had declared. The next year, when Hale sent her annual letter to governors, newly-elected Gov. Henry A. Wise, an enslaver, made his stand on the national holiday clear.
Wise said the “theatrical national claptrap of Thanksgiving has aided other causes in setting thousands of pulpits to preaching ‘Christian politics,’” Diana Karter Applebaum wrote in her book “Thanksgiving: an American holiday, and American tradition.”
By “other causes,” Wise meant abolition. “And Wise was not a man to abet a Yankee abolitionist holiday,” she wrote.
Ire in Washington
Thanksgiving was already causing ire in Washington before Lincoln’s misunderstood intentions.
In 1856, the Evening Star worried that the holiday creep of Thanksgiving would overshadow Christmas. “Gradually, this ‘thanksgiving day’ is weedding [sic] out from among us of the District of Columbia the legitimate christian holiday,” the paper editorialized. The paper worried that “a multitude of horses will be over-ridden and over-driven” and thousands would lose a day’s wages.
The writer also worried that while the devout of D.C. would be in churches, “a much larger portion will be throwing away their time and means in various ways. An astonishing quantity of execrable liquor will be guzzled here. Perhaps ten times as much as on any other day of this year 1856.”
Petula Dvorak is a columnist for The Washington Post’s local team. Her previous article was “RFK Jr. will bring back a culture war that had been won.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.