In 2016, both Donald Trump’s shocking victory and Bernie Sanders’ socialist insurgency created In 2016, both Don­ald Trump’s shock­ing vic­tory and Ber­nie Sanders’ so­cial­ist in­sur­gency cre­ated a sud­den swell of ide­o­log­i­cal am­bi­tion. Con­ser­va­tive think­ers rushed to fill in the out­lines of Trum­pian pop­u­lism, build­ing var­i­ous in­tel­lec­tual frame­works for an in­cip­i­ent “post-lib­eral” age.

Mean­while among pro­gres­sives there were two big proj­ects: a cul­tural rev­o­lu­tion in the name of an­ti­ra­cism and so­cial justice that gath­ered force through­out Trump’s pres­i­dency, and a Sanders-in­spired re­vival of big-spend­ing so­cial demo­cratic blue­prints.

These ef­forts seemed to prom­ise that a great clash of vi­sions would de­fine the 2020s, pit­ting some ver­sion of a “new right” against some kind of post-ne­o­lib­eral left. But what­ever the cur­rent elec­tion sea­son is de­liv­er­ing, it isn’t a grand ide­o­log­i­cal de­bate.

Flight from ide­ol­ogy

In­stead, there is a flight from ide­o­log­i­cal am­bi­tion on both sides, with the Demo­cratic can­di­date of­fer­ing a mix of poll-tested in­cre­men­tal­ism and non­spe­cific pab­u­lum and the Re­pub­li­can can­di­date clos­ing out his cam­paign with in­con­sis­tent pan­der­ing — tax cuts for some, le­gal­ized mar­i­juana for oth­ers, mass de­por­ta­tions but also free in vitro fer­til­iza­tion treat­ment.

Advertise with us

So where do the ide­ol­o­gies that took shape be­tween 2016 and 2020 ac­tu­ally stand in 2024?

Start with the Great Awo­ken­ing that swept through Amer­i­can in­sti­tu­tions in the sum­mer fol­low­ing the mur­der of George Floyd. So­cial justice pro­gres­siv­ism’s po­si­tion at the mo­ment might be char­ac­ter­ized as a mix­ture of re­treat and con­sol­i­da­tion. The re­treat is most ob­vi­ous in na­tional pol­i­tics, where Kamala Har­ris would clearly like ev­ery­one to for­get some of the more outré po­si­tions she staked out dur­ing the Demo­cratic pri­ma­ries four years ago.

But it’s ap­par­ent else­where in the cul­ture as well: The rep­u­ta­tions of ac­tiv­ist writ­ers Ibram X. Kendi and Robin DiAn­gelo have fallen on hard times, cor­po­rate Amer­ica is cut­ting DEI jobs and uni­ver­sity lead­ers are try­ing to tip­toe back to­ward po­lit­i­cal neu­tral­ity.

At the same time the Awo­ken­ing is hardly giv­ing up all the ter­ri­tory it claimed. When The Econ­o­mist pro­duced a spe­cial re­port this past week on wo­ke­ness’s sup­posed eclipse, the trends in var­i­ous in­di­ca­tors — the use of ide­o­log­i­cal buzz­words in me­dia and academia, say — were more likely to show a lev­el­ing-off or mod­est di­min­ish­ment than a real de­cline.

This sug­gests that wo­ke­ness is more in abey­ance than full re­treat, still po­tent de­spite be­ing held at arm’s length by lead­ing Dem­o­crats.

Advertise with us

No more neo-so­cial­ism

The same can’t be said of its fel­low trav­eler, the neo-so­cial­ism that crested ei­ther with Sanders’ 2020 cam­paign or with the ini­tial Biden ad­min­is­tra­tion spend­ing spree. The Sanders left notched some pol­icy vic­to­ries in the lat­ter pe­riod, but as a for­ward-look­ing move­ment it looks rud­der­less, its grand am­bi­tions frus­trated by di­vided gov­ern­ment and by the left’s an­cient en­emy, in­fla­tion.

Maybe neo-so­cial­ism will re­vive in the later 2020s un­der Al­ex­an­dria Oca­sio-Cortez or in the 2030s un­der an ar­ti­fi­cial-in­tel­li­gence sim­u­la­crum of a younger Ber­nie Sanders. But for now the dream of “Med­i­care for All,” a uni­ver­sal ba­sic in­come or a Euro­pean-scale wel­fare state feels al­most as dis­tant as it did be­fore Sanders’ first pres­i­den­tial cam­paign.

And whereas wo­ke­ness can en­dure and thrive with­out di­rect po­lit­i­cal power be­cause it’s a cul­tural move­ment above all, so­cial­ists with­out a path to con­trol­ling the means of pro­duc­tion are al­ways in dan­ger of turn­ing into a pri­vate de­bat­ing club.

Finally, what of the post-lib­eral right? In one sense it seems well po­si­tioned: Trump has a good chance at a res­tora­tion. He’s mak­ing na­tion­al­ist prom­ises on im­mi­gra­tion and tar­iffs once again, and his run­ning mate is a fel­low trav­eler of the pop­u­list in­tel­li­gent­sia.

But in an­other sense, much of the work that in­tel­li­gent­sia tried to do to pre­pare for this mo­ment ap­pears ster­ile or un­pal­at­able or sim­ply in­com­plete. The new right’s prom­ise was that a lot more would be added to Trump’s 2016 cam­paign: big ideas for in­dus­trial and fam­ily pol­icy; a re­vived so­cial con­ser­va­tism push­ing back against lib­er­tar­ian ex­cess; a post-Rea­gan­ite vi­sion of the com­mon good.

Advertise with us

The re­al­ity is that Trump 2.0 has stiff-armed so­cial con­ser­va­tism, his vi­sion of blue-col­lar re­vival hasn’t pro­gressed much be­yond build­ing the wall and pay­ing for it with tar­iffs, and he re­mains more fo­cused on state­craft as score-set­tling than as soul­craft. Mean­while, the ide­ol­o­gists of the new right can’t agree on what they’re for — some try­ing to sta­ple pol­icy ideas to Trump’s cam­paign, oth­ers mar­i­nat­ing in var­i­ous para­noias, and oth­ers sub­sid­ing into dis­il­lu­sion­ment.

The most ef­fec­tive part of the new right might be the cul­tural move­ment that is build­ing up clas­si­cal ed­u­ca­tion and es­tab­lish­ing beach­heads in red-state uni­ver­sities. But rel­a­tive to pro­gres­siv­ism’s cul­tural cadres, this is just a small guer­rilla force.

What do we think now?

So what world­views have gained ground in the 2024 cam­paign? I think you would have to say the ideas that were in­flu­en­tial be­fore Trump and Sanders up­set ev­ery­thing — a small-ball form of pro­gres­sive pol­i­cy­mak­ing, sup­ply-side eco­nom­ics for Re­pub­li­cans and cul­tural lib­er­tar­i­an­ism.

Tax cuts and tax cred­its and abor­tion rights, a Dem­o­crat brag­ging about own­ing a hand­gun while her Re­pub­li­can ri­val en­dorses le­gal pot: I don’t ex­pect it to last, but for at least the next six weeks, it’s spring­time for ne­o­lib­er­al­ism.

Ross Dout­hat is a col­um­nist for The New York Times.

Ross Douthat is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “The two good reasons some voters are still undecided.”