Last week, Tucker Carlson, the former Fox News star who now hosts one of America’s top podcasts, had an apologist for Adolf Hitler on his show. Darryl Cooper, who runs a history podcast (and newsletter) called “Martyr Made,” considers Winston Churchill, not Hitler, the chief villain of World War II.

In a social media post that he’s since deleted, Cooper argued that a Paris occupied by the Nazis was “infinitely preferable in virtually every way” to the city on display during the opening ceremony of the recent Summer Olympics, where a drag queen performance infuriated the right.

Carl­son in­tro­duced him to lis­ten­ers as “the most im­por­tant pop­u­lar his­to­rian work­ing in the United States to­day.”

Cooper’s ab­sur­di­ties

Over the course of a wide-rang­ing two-hour con­ver­sa­tion, Cooper pre­sented the main­stream his­tory of World War II as a my­thol­ogy shrouded in ta­boos in­tended to prop up a cor­rupt lib­eral po­lit­i­cal or­der. The idea that Nazi Ger­many rep­re­sented the epit­ome of evil, he ar­gued, is such a “core part of the state re­li­gion” that we have “emo­tional trig­gers” pre­vent­ing us from ex­am­in­ing the past dis­pas­sion­ately.

Advertise with us

This clever rhe­tor­i­cal for­mu­la­tion, fa­mil­iar to var­i­ous strands of right-wing pro­pa­ganda, flat­ters lis­ten­ers for their will­ing­ness to re­ject all they’ve learned from main­stream ex­perts, mak­ing them feel brave and savvy for im­bib­ing ab­sur­di­ties.

Cooper pro­ceeded, in a soft-spo­ken, faux-rea­son­able way, to lay out an al­ter­na­tive his­tory in which Hitler tried might­ily to avoid war with Western Europe, Chur­chill was a “psy­cho­path” propped up by Zion­ist in­ter­ests, and mil­lions of peo­ple in con­cen­tra­tion camps “ended up dead” be­cause the over­whelmed Na­zis didn’t have the re­sources to care for them.

Some on the right found Carl­son’s turn to­ward Ho­lo­caust skep­ti­cism sur­pris­ing, but Nazi sym­pa­thy is the nat­u­ral end­point of a pol­i­tics based on glib con­trar­i­an­ism, right-wing trans­gres­sion and eth­nic griev­ance.

There are few bet­ter trolls, af­ter all, than Ho­lo­caust den­iers, who love to pose as het­ero­dox truth-seek­ers op­pressed by Or­well­ian elites. The wildly an­tise­mitic Com­mit­tee for Open De­bate on the Ho­lo­caust named its jour­nal “An In­con­ve­nient His­tory: A Quar­terly Jour­nal for Free His­tor­i­cal In­quiry.”

Those who deny or down­play the Ho­lo­caust of­ten ex­cel at mim­ick­ing the forms and lan­guage of le­git­i­mate schol­ar­ship, us­ing them to un­der­mine rather than ex­plore re­al­ity. They blitz their op­po­nents with out-of-con­text his­tor­i­cal de­tail and bad-faith ques­tions, and they know how to use crude prov­o­ca­tion to get at­ten­tion.

Advertise with us

Long be­fore 4Chan ex­isted, dis­graced Ho­lo­caust-de­ny­ing au­thor David Irv­ing urged his fol­low­ers, in an early 1990s speech, to break through the “ap­pall­ing pseudo-re­li­gious at­mo­sphere” sur­round­ing World War II by be­ing ag­gres­sively taste­less. “You’ve got to say things like: ‘More women died on the back seat of Sen. Edward Ken­nedy’s car at Chappaquid­dick than died in the gas cham­ber at Ausch­witz,’” he said.

Aban­doned guard­rails

Un­til quite re­cently, Amer­i­can con­ser­va­tives mostly main­tained an­ti­bod­ies against Irv­ing-style dis­in­for­ma­tion. Right-wing thought lead­ers gen­er­ally shared the same broad his­tor­i­cal un­der­stand­ing of World War II as the rest of so­ci­ety, felt pa­tri­otic pride at Amer­ica’s role in it and viewed Hitler as meta­phys­i­cally wicked.

Rather than rec­og­niz­ing the way right-wing pol­i­tics, taken to ex­tremes, could shade into Na­tional So­cial­ism, they would hurl Nazi com­par­i­sons at the left, as con­ser­va­tive col­um­nist Jonah Gold­berg did in his 2008 book “Lib­eral Fas­cism.”

Gold­berg’s ap­proach was dis­hon­est, but it was rep­re­sen­ta­tive of a broad anti-fas­cist con­sen­sus in Amer­i­can pol­i­tics. Cooper is, in fact, cor­rect that ab­hor­rence of Na­zism has helped struc­ture Western so­ci­et­ies. If we could agree on noth­ing else, we could agree that part of the job of lib­eral de­moc­racy was to erect bul­warks against the emer­gence of Hitler-like fig­ures.

For parts of the con­tem­po­rary right, how­ever, the so­cial con­sen­suses un­der­gird­ing lib­er­al­ism are ar­ti­fi­cial and even ty­ran­ni­cal. After all, the “Ma­trix”-de­rived met­a­phor of be­ing “red-pilled” im­plies a re­al­i­za­tion that all you’ve been told about the na­ture of re­al­ity is a lie, and thus ev­ery­thing is up for grabs.

Advertise with us

Once you dis­card all epis­te­mo­log­i­cal and moral guard­rails, it’s easy to de­scend into bar­ba­rous non­sense.

Can­dace Owens, an­other anti-woke right-wing ce­leb­rity who has lately be­come Hitler-cu­ri­ous, has also come to ques­tion re­ceived wis­dom about the shape of the earth. “I’m not a flat-earther,” she said in July. “I’m not a round-earther. Ac­tu­ally, what I am is I am some­body who has left the cult of sci­ence.”

Ob­vi­ously, not ev­ery red-pilled con­ser­va­tive ends up ar­gu­ing, as Owens did, that Hitler gets a bad rap.

But the weak­en­ing of the in­tel­lec­tual quar­an­tine around Na­zism — and the MAGA right’s fe­tish for ideas their en­e­mies see as dan­ger­ous — makes it eas­ier for in­flu­en­tial con­ser­va­tives to sur­ren­der to fas­cist im­pulses. When they do, they pay no pen­alty in po­lit­i­cal rel­e­vance, be­cause there’s no con­ser­va­tive es­tab­lish­ment ca­pa­ble of dis­ci­plin­ing its ideo­logues.

Carl­son has just em­barked on a na­tional tour with spe­cial guests at each stop, including Alex Jones, vice pres­i­den­tial nom­i­nee JD Vance and Don­ald Trump Jr.

Advertise with us

Not his­tory but per­mis­sion

Ul­ti­mately, Ho­lo­caust de­nial isn’t re­ally about his­tory at all, but about what’s per­mis­si­ble in the pres­ent and imag­in­able in the fu­ture. If Hitler is no lon­ger widely un­der­stood as the ne­ga­tion of our deep­est val­ues, Amer­ica will be soft­ened up for Don­ald Trump’s most au­thor­i­tar­ian plans, in­clud­ing im­pris­on­ing masses of im­mi­grants who are in the coun­try il­le­gally in vast de­ten­tion camps.

Toward the end of their con­ver­sa­tion, Carl­son and Cooper dis­cussed how the “post­war Euro­pean or­der” has en­abled mass im­mi­gra­tion, which has, in Carl­son’s tell­ing, de­stroyed Western Europe. “So why not have a Nur­em­berg trial for the peo­ple who did that?” asked Carl­son. “I don’t un­der­stand. I mean, that’s such a crime.”

“Well,” Cooper re­sponded, “we have to win first.”

Michelle Goldberg is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. Her previous article was “The Democrats must make a move.”