It’s of­fi­cial: par­ent­ing is dif­fi­cult. So much so that U.S. Sur­geon Gen­eral Vivek Murthy has is­sued an ad­vi­sory about the stress and men­tal health is­sues par­ent­ing cre­ates.

Par­ent­ing joins so­cial me­dia for chil­dren, health-care worker burn­out and fire­arm vi­o­lence as is­sues the Depart­ment of Health and Human Ser­vices felt it needed to for­mally ad­dress.

Devolv­ing par­ent­hood

Ac­cord­ing to the sur­geon gen­eral’s ad­vi­sory, par­ent­ing has de­volved in ways both ob­vi­ous and sub­tle.

Of course, there’s the cost. The U.S. Depart­ment of Ag­ri­cul­ture, which has es­ti­mated the cost of rais­ing a child since 1960, says low-in­come fam­i­lies will spend $120,000 per child from birth through age 17, and high-in­come fam­i­lies at least $380,000. The Brook­ings In­sti­tu­tion es­ti­mates mid­dle-class fam­i­lies spend $310,000 on av­er­age. Then there’s the cost of col­lege. Not sur­pris­ing, 1 in 4 par­ents strug­gle to af­ford food and hous­ing.

Advertise with us

Money is an ob­vi­ous stres­sor, but par­ent­ing has never been cheap. The real ac­ce­l­e­r­ants of pa­ren­tal stress are the mod­ern wor­ries that prior gen­er­a­tions couldn’t even imag­ine.

Con­sider that the No. 1 killer of chil­dren in the U.S. is guns. Un­like al­most ev­ery other cause of death among chil­dren, gun deaths have been ris­ing ev­ery year for the past de­cade.

Even though few of child deaths from guns are re­lated to school shoot­ings, such events and their vic­tims are on the rise. These shoot­ings have an out­size im­pact on pa­ren­tal stress and fear. In 1977, just 24% of par­ents re­ported to Gallup that they were wor­ried about their child’s safety at school. Last year it was 38% (with spikes af­ter large-scale school shoot­ings, reach­ing 55% fol­low­ing Col­um­bine).

Par­ents must also han­dle their chil­dren’s fear, one in four of whom have been in an ac­tive shooter lock­down. And new re­search is emerg­ing that shows sim­ply prac­tic­ing for ac­tive shoot­ers in drills can psy­cho­log­i­cally harm chil­dren.

Gun vi­o­lence is a ter­ri­fy­ing pos­si­bil­ity, but mon­i­tor­ing and man­ag­ing ac­cess to so­cial me­dia is a daily strug­gle. Par­ents are try­ing to not only wade through the quandary of how much screen time is rea­son­able for their chil­dren but also whether al­low­ing them ac­cess to so­cial me­dia will ac­tively harm them.

Advertise with us

That’s es­pe­cially true af­ter a Face­book whis­tle­blower came for­ward in 2021 with ev­i­dence that the com­pany’s re­search con­cluded In­sta­gram was harm­ful for teen girls, even as the com­pany was de­ny­ing such claims to the pub­lic.

Out­matched par­ents

Many par­ents also find them­selves out­matched when it comes to pre­par­ing chil­dren for the job mar­ket. Col­lege, once con­sid­ered a sure in­vest­ment for any­one who made it through, is now un­der­stood to have vary­ing re­turns based on gen­der, eth­nic­ity and pa­ren­tal in­come.

Young peo­ple are be­com­ing dis­en­chanted with higher ed­u­ca­tion, with 1 in 5 grad­u­ates de­clar­ing it wasn’t worth the time and cost. As such, the so-called col­lege pre­mium is de­clin­ing.

How­ever bad the econ­omy has been at times over the past 80 years, there is lit­tle to com­pare with the har­bin­ger of po­ten­tial job de­struc­tion that is ar­ti­fi­cial in­tel­li­gence. Gold­man Sachs Group Inc. pre­dicted it will de­stroy 300 mil­lion jobs world­wide. It’s al­ready show­ing up in lay­off data.

Sure, the econ­omy is al­ways evolv­ing, de­stroy­ing jobs that are no lon­ger rel­e­vant while cre­at­ing new ones, but that doesn’t make it any eas­ier for par­ents as they try to steer their chil­dren to­ward eco­nomic se­cu­rity.

Advertise with us

These chal­lenges come as par­ents spend more time with their chil­dren than prior gen­er­a­tions. In time-use stud­ies, both moth­ers and fathers re­port spend­ing more hours of the day car­ing for chil­dren, in­creases of 40% and 154% re­spec­tively, since 1985. Time-in­ten­sive par­ent­ing has be­come the norm be­cause it’s now broadly con­sid­ered the stan­dard for “good par­ent­ing.”

The up­shot is par­ents are stressed and that has con­se­quences for ev­ery­one, ra­di­at­ing out through wors­en­ing men­tal and phys­i­cal health, sub­stance abuse, mar­i­tal con­flict, fam­ily break­ups, set­backs for child de­vel­op­ment, child be­hav­ior, child safety and child men­tal health.

Help­ing the econ­omy

Even from the cold lens of the econ­omy’s needs, none of that is pref­er­a­ble to sta­ble fam­i­lies with mem­bers in good health, es­pe­cially if it de­ters in­di­vid­u­als from hav­ing chil­dren and re­duc­ing fer­til­ity.

The sur­geon gen­eral’s ad­vi­sory of­fers pol­i­cies as di­verse as re­duc­ing pov­erty and build­ing more com­mu­nity spaces as ways to make par­ent­ing less stress­ful and lonely. It’s not clear any pol­icy, with the ex­cep­tion of re­duc­ing costs, would be suc­cess­ful.

But there is noth­ing to gain by re­fus­ing to help, no eco­nomic di­a­mond bur­ied in stressed, de­pressed, over­whelmed par­ents that we can mine for later use. It’s pure loss. Pol­icy isn’t a cure — it’s an aid, and if it can help par­ents, it can help the econ­omy.

Kathryn Anne Edwards is a labor economist and independent policy consultant. Her previous article was “Social Security doesn't just help the old.”