Some of the best ad­vice Dem­o­crats have re­ceived re­cently came from Bill Clin­ton in his speech at the Demo­cratic Na­tional Con­ven­tion. First, he warned against hu­bris, but sec­ond, re­lated and even more im­por­tant, he cau­tioned against de­mean­ing vot­ers who don’t share lib­eral val­ues.

“I urge you to meet peo­ple where they are,” said Clin­ton, who knows some­thing about win­ning votes out­side solid blue states. “I urge you not to de­mean them, but not to pre­tend you don’t dis­agree with them if you do. Treat them with re­spect — just the way you’d like them to treat you.”

Fool­ish and of­fen­sive

That’s crit­i­cal coun­sel be­cause too of­ten since 2016, the lib­eral im­pulse has been to de­mo­nize any­one at all sym­pa­thetic to Don­ald Trump as a rac­ist and bigot. This has been po­lit­i­cally fool­ish, for it’s dif­fi­cult to win votes from peo­ple you’re dis­par­ag­ing.

It has also seemed to me mor­ally of­fen­sive, par­tic­u­larly when well-ed­u­cated and suc­cess­ful elites are scorn­ing dis­ad­van­taged, work­ing-class Amer­i­cans who have been left be­hind eco­nom­i­cally and so­cially and in many cases are dy­ing young. They de­serve em­pa­thy, not in­sults.

Advertise with us

By all means de­nounce Trump, but don’t ste­reo­type and be­lit­tle the nearly half of Amer­i­cans who have sided with him.

Since I live in a ru­ral area, many of my old friends are Trump sup­port­ers. One, a good and gen­er­ous woman, backs Trump be­cause she feels be­trayed by the Demo­cratic and Re­pub­li­can po­lit­i­cal es­tab­lish­ments, and she has a point.

When fac­to­ries closed and good union jobs left the area, she ended up home­less and ad­dicted; four mem­bers of her ex­tended fam­ily killed them­selves and she once put a gun to her own head. So when a dem­a­gogue like Trump speaks to her pain and prom­ises to bring fac­to­ries back, of course her heart leaps.

Then her re­solve strength­ens when she hears lib­er­als mock her faith — it was an evan­gel­i­cal church that helped her over­come home­less­ness — or de­ride her as “de­plor­able.”

Then there’s the woman who cut my hair: She has a daugh­ter who was over­come with ad­dic­tion, so she quit the shop to care for a grand­son.

Advertise with us

Her suc­ces­sor cut­ting my hair lost her hus­band to an over­dose and is strug­gling to help a son who is ad­dicted. She isn’t much in­ter­ested in pol­i­tics and didn’t watch any of the Demo­cratic con­ven­tion; she said she dis­trusts Trump and sees him as a bully, but she is mad at Dem­o­crats be­cause food prices are too high.

“I’m not sure how I’ll vote,” she told me, “or if I’ll vote.” She’s a good, hard­work­ing per­son who would ben­e­fit from a Demo­cratic vic­tory, and Dem­o­crats should fight for her — not sav­age her for po­lit­i­cal thought crimes.

The be­trayed work­ing class

Work­ing-class Amer­i­cans have a right to feel be­trayed. After al­most 3,000 peo­ple died in the Sept. 11 at­tacks, we started two wars and al­lo­cated tril­lions of dol­lars to the re­sponse.

But ev­ery three or four days we lose as many Amer­i­cans to drugs, al­co­hol and sui­cide as died in the Sept. 11 at­tacks, yet the na­tional re­sponse has been pa­thet­i­cally weak. The so­cial fab­ric in many blue-col­lar com­mu­ni­ties has un­rav­eled, and peo­ple are an­gry and frus­trated.

Since the Obama pres­i­dency, Dem­o­crats have in­creas­ingly be­come the party of the ed­u­cated, and the up­shot has of­ten been a whiff of con­de­scen­sion to­ward work­ing-class vot­ers, es­pe­cially to­ward vot­ers of faith. And in a coun­try where 74% of Amer­i­cans re­port a be­lief in God, ac­cord­ing to Gallup, and only 38% older than 25 have a four year col­lege de­gree, con­de­scen­sion is a los­ing strat­egy.

Advertise with us

Mi­chael Sandel, the em­i­nent Har­vard phi­los­o­pher, con­demns the scorn for peo­ple with less ed­u­ca­tion as “the last ac­cept­able prej­u­dice” in Amer­ica. He’s right: Elites some­times in­dulge in open dis­dain for work­ing-class vot­ers that they would never ac­knowl­edge about other groups.

I worry about Dem­o­crats ne­glect­ing their proud her­i­tage since at least the time of Frank­lin Roosevelt of stand­ing up for work­ing-class Amer­i­cans. Maybe it’s time for more ed­u­cated lib­er­als to re­read FDR’s fa­mous “For­got­ten Man” speech of 1932, hail­ing “the for­got­ten man at the bot­tom of the eco­nomic pyr­a­mid.”

We lib­er­als to­day are at­tuned to iden­tity and thus to ra­cial and gen­der dis­ad­van­tages, while of­ten seem­ingly obliv­i­ous to class dis­ad­van­tage — even though re­cent re­search by Har­vard econ­o­mist Raj Chetty un­der­scores that race is play­ing a smaller role in op­por­tu­nity gaps while class gaps are yawn­ing wider.

You can’t have a se­ri­ous con­ver­sa­tion about in­equal­ity to­day with­out dis­cuss­ing race. But you also can’t have a se­ri­ous con­ver­sa­tion about pov­erty or op­por­tu­nity with­out con­sid­er­ing class (and for many peo­ple of color, race and class dis­ad­van­tages over­lap).

Kamala Har­ris seems to get this. She chose as her run­ning mate a man who can reach work­ing-class vot­ers with his words as well as his pol­i­cies. And she can pres­ent her­self as the can­di­date who worked at McDon­ald’s while her op­po­nent was ex­ploit­ing his in­her­i­tance — and rent­ers.

Advertise with us

Sum­mon em­pa­thy

I wasn’t plan­ning to write this col­umn, but then I ap­prov­ingly tweeted Clin­ton’s com­ment about not de­mean­ing those we dis­agree with. Plenty of read­ers re­plied hotly: But they de­serve to be de­meaned!

Sure, it’s sat­is­fy­ing to hurl in­vec­tive. But call­ing peo­ple “Na­zis” won’t win over un­de­cided vot­ers.

So let’s take a deep breath, sum­mon FDR’s em­pa­thy for the for­got­ten man, fol­low Clin­ton’s ad­vice — and, for the sake of win­ning elec­tions as well as of ci­vil­ity, re­mem­ber that the best way to get oth­ers to lis­ten to us is to first lis­ten to them.

Nicholas Kristof is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article originally appeared. His previous article was “Which party is really anti-family and anti-child?”