Heal­th­care costs are a big is­sue in the pres­i­den­tial elec­tion, ac­cord­ing to Pew Re­search rank­ing just be­low in­fla­tion and po­lit­i­cal po­lar­iza­tion. Yet nei­ther party seems to be fo­cus­ing on a ma­jor driver of sky­rock­et­ing health­care spend­ing: hos­pi­tal costs.

At over 30% of health­care spend­ing, hos­pi­tal costs are the larg­est com­po­nent. Nat­u­rally, this is­sue is very im­por­tant to se­nior cit­i­zens who vote with a 72% turn­out rate and is cer­tainly wor­thy of at­ten­tion from our po­lit­i­cal lead­ers.

Ris­ing costs

A JAMA study found that be­fore the pan­demic, hos­pi­tals were op­er­at­ing at 2.8% mar­gin. But dur­ing 2020 and 2021, that more than dou­bled to an all-time high of 6.5%. Since, ac­cord­ing to gov­ern­ment re­search, hos­pi­tal costs make up the larg­est share of health­care spend­ing at 30%, this is the ma­jor cause of ris­ing health­care costs.

On be­half of the hun­dreds of thou­sands of se­niors we rep­resent, we are ex­tremely con­cerned about this trou­bling trend.

Advertise with us

Fur­ther, we have ob­served a dis­tress­ing na­tion­wide pat­tern where hos­pi­tals use abu­sive ne­go­ti­at­ing tac­tics in or­der to ex­tract higher pay­ments from in­sur­ers in the pri­vate sec­tor, where most Amer­i­cans get their health­care. This af­fects the ma­jor­ity of se­niors and Amer­i­cans with dis­abil­i­ties who have cov­er­age through Med­i­care Ad­van­tage, and the three-quar­ters of low-in­come Amer­i­cans in Med­ic­aid who have cov­er­age through man­aged care plans.

Hos­pi­tals are in­creas­ingly im­ple­ment­ing what their high-priced ad­vi­sors call an “out-of-net­work strat­egy” to get higher pay­ments from em­ploy­ers and con­sum­ers. One con­sul­tant bragged, “Two of our cli­ents re­cently le­ver­aged an out-of-net­work strat­egy that ul­ti­mately re­sulted in con­tract rates dou­ble the stan­dard an­nual in­crease.”

When they ne­go­ti­ate prices with in­sur­ers, these ever-grow­ing hos­pi­tal be­he­moths leave or threaten to leave the in­surer’s net­work. Notably, hos­pi­tals are re­mov­ing them­selves from Med­i­care and Med­ic­aid net­works even when rates in those con­tracts are not in dis­pute.

A cruel strat­egy

They then take to so­cial me­dia and lo­cal news out­lets to scare vul­ner­a­ble pa­tients — like se­niors — that ac­cess to their fa­vor­ite doc­tors and pro­vid­ers will be dis­rupted. Fright­ened, they, in turn, “put pres­sure on the payor” to agree to higher rates in the com­mer­cial mar­ket.

This strat­egy is cruel, in es­sence tak­ing se­niors and other vul­ner­a­ble pop­u­la­tions hos­tage and add­ing un­nec­es­sary stress and worry to peo­ple al­ready con­cerned about their health.

Advertise with us

Sadly, this is be­com­ing in­creas­ingly com­mon. In the third quar­ter of 2023, pub­lic con­tract dis­putes with hos­pi­tals nearly dou­bled from the pre­vi­ous year. For pa­tients cov­ered by Med­i­care Ad­van­tage — which is, again, how the ma­jor­ity of se­niors ac­cess their Med­i­care ben­e­fits — con­tract dis­putes in 2022 in­creased by 115% from the year prior. Ex­perts be­lieve this con­cern­ing trend will con­tinue.

Another ma­jor fac­tor is that hos­pi­tals have con­sol­i­dated to the point of mar­ket dom­i­nance in many lo­ca­tions, mak­ing it pos­si­ble for them to force un­rea­son­able in­creases in their prices. And more and more doc­tors’ prac­tices are be­ing bought up by large hos­pi­tal groups.

That’s hap­pen­ing be­cause Med­i­care pays hos­pi­tals more than phy­si­cian of­fices for the same ser­vices, so hos­pi­tals are in­cen­tivized to buy them, re­sult­ing in higher Med­i­care rates and ad­di­tional fees on pa­tients.

Stop con­sol­i­da­tion

Law­mak­ers must take steps to elim­i­nate the in­cen­tives that en­cour­age hos­pi­tals to con­sol­i­date for the wrong rea­sons and pre­vent fu­ture hos­pi­tal con­sol­i­da­tion through in­creased an­ti­trust en­force­ment. And they should ban hos­pi­tals from us­ing an­ti­com­pet­i­tive con­tract­ing terms. There is no place in the sen­si­tive health­care sec­tor for ma­li­cious tac­tics like the “out-of-net­work” strat­egy.

This should be im­por­tant to pol­i­ti­cians from both par­ties. Re­cent poll­ing shows that five of the six health-re­lated is­sues that older Amer­i­cans found most con­cern­ing had to do with health­care costs. With se­nior vot­ers up for grabs, it could de­cide the out­come of the elec­tion.

Saul Anu­zis is Pres­i­dent of 60 Plus As­so­ci­a­tion, Amer­i­can As­so­ci­a­tion of Se­nior Citi­zens.