There is controversy over the soundness of several Supreme Court decisions this past term. But there should be no debate over which decision this term was the dumbest. That would be Garland v. Cargill, the case that overturned the federal ban on bump stocks.
Bump stocks turn semi-automatic rifles — think AR-15s — which ordinary people can fire at around 60 rounds per minute, into rapid firing guns that can fire over 400 rounds per minute. They use the gun’s momentum to push the trigger after each shot.
If the shooter in the attempted assassination of former President Donald Trump — I refuse to use the shooter’s name — had used a bump stock on his rifle, not only would Trump be dead, but so would all those around him.
They got it wrong
The Justices got the case wrong by asking the wrong question. After a 2017 mass shooting in which 60 people were killed and hundreds injured by bump-stock enhanced firearms, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives banned bump stocks under a law prohibiting machine guns. All the Justices asked is: Is such a modified rifle a machine gun?
It isn’t. But that was the wrong question.
When Congress prohibits something, people often find loopholes to get around the law. If human ingenuity discovers a genuinely new way to accomplish what Congress has tried to ban, you need a new statute.
Read More
But when people merely modify the technique that Congress has already prohibited in order to escape the exact wording of a statute, the executive branch often closes the loophole by issuing a regulation. This happens in tax law all the time. The IRS is very good at closing loopholes that lawyers and accountants create.
That is what happened here. The ATF closed an unanticipated dodge around the machine gun ban.
Closing loopholes does not raise issues of policy-making that led the Court in another case to abolish Chevron deference — the doctrine of judicial deference to regulations interpreting ambiguous statutes. There, the problem is that bureaucrats, rather than Congress, are making policy decisions.
But in the instance of the bump-stock ban, as Justice Samuel Alito noted in his concurrence, there can be no doubt that the Congress that banned machine guns would have banned bump stocks too, if bump stocks had been known.
Why didn’t Congress just ban rapid-firing guns? Because an expert can fire even a semi-automatic rifle at up to 180 rounds per minute. Congress did not want to raise an issue about semi-automatic rifles and so defined machine guns as firing with one pull of the trigger. Even with a bump stock, a rifle still technically fires only with a new pull on the trigger with each shot. That is why it is not a machine gun but a loophole around the machine-gun ban.
Closing the loophole
If the bump stock turned rifles into machine guns, it was always illegal and the ATF should have banned it all along. Closing a loophole was not mandatory.
But if the bump stock is a loophole, the ATF could have properly decided to tolerate it until a mass shooting showed how deadly it could be.
Justice Clarence Thomas’s majority opinion briefly addressed the loophole issue. But he utilized a standard impossible to satisfy. The executive branch can only close a loophole if it renders the underlying statute “useless.”
Thomas cited no majority opinion for this standard and it makes no sense. Statutes are still useful even when people find loopholes. It would be simpler to just buy a machine gun than to attach a bump stock to a rifle. And some machine guns fire even faster than bump-stock equipped rifles do.
So what if a law is still useful? The standard should be: Does a loophole substantially interfere with the underlying Congressional policy through evasion?
The reason that we allow regulatory action to close a loophole even when an underlying statute is still effective is that Congress cannot be expected to pass a new statute every time someone comes up with a clever way to skirt a law. Even apart from the filibuster, which hopefully will be abolished so that Congressional majorities can pass laws, such a requirement would emasculate Congress, not empower it.
Dumb or not, however, we are now stuck with the bump stock decision. So, what should we do?
Congress would ban them
There has always been a large congressional majority in favor of banning bump stocks. Such a ban raises no Second Amendment issue. This judicial decision would have been reversed immediately except for a threatened filibuster in the Senate.
But, with the attempted assassination, the situation has changed. The Trump Administration banned bump stocks in 2019. Undoubtedly, Trump himself would support legislative action.
In the interest of national unity, the Speaker of the House, Republican Mike Johnson, and the Majority Leader in the Senate, Democrat Chuck Schumer, should jointly introduce The Donald Trump Act banning bump stocks.
If this were done, the threatened filibuster would disappear and our nation and its leaders would be far safer from deadly harm.
Bruce Ledewitz is a professor of law at the Thomas R. Kline School of Law of Duquesne University. His previous article was “The Supreme Court's immunity decision was good for America.” The views expressed do not represent those of Duquesne University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.