There is con­tro­versy over the sound­ness of sev­eral Supreme Court de­ci­sions this past term. But there should be no de­bate over which de­ci­sion this term was the dumb­est. That would be Gar­land v. Cargill, the case that over­turned the fed­eral ban on bump stocks.

Bump stocks turn semi-au­to­matic ri­fles — think AR-15s — which or­di­nary peo­ple can fire at around 60 rounds per minute, into rapid fir­ing guns that can fire over 400 rounds per minute. They use the gun’s mo­men­tum to push the trig­ger af­ter each shot.

If the shooter in the at­tempted as­sas­si­na­tion of for­mer Pres­i­dent Don­ald Trump — I refuse to use the shooter’s name — had used a bump stock on his ri­fle, not only would Trump be dead, but so would all those around him.

They got it wrong

The Justices got the case wrong by ask­ing the wrong ques­tion. After a 2017 mass shoot­ing in which 60 peo­ple were killed and hun­dreds in­jured by bump-stock en­hanced fire­arms, the Bureau of Al­co­hol, Tobacco, Fire­arms and Ex­plo­sives banned bump stocks un­der a law pro­hib­it­ing ma­chine guns. All the Justices asked is: Is such a mod­i­fied ri­fle a ma­chine gun?

Advertise with us

It isn’t. But that was the wrong ques­tion.

When Con­gress pro­hib­its some­thing, peo­ple of­ten find loop­holes to get around the law. If hu­man in­ge­nu­ity dis­cov­ers a gen­u­inely new way to ac­com­plish what Con­gress has tried to ban, you need a new stat­ute.

But when peo­ple merely mod­ify the tech­nique that Con­gress has al­ready pro­hib­ited in or­der to es­cape the ex­act word­ing of a stat­ute, the ex­ec­u­tive branch of­ten closes the loop­hole by is­su­ing a reg­u­la­tion. This hap­pens in tax law all the time. The IRS is very good at clos­ing loop­holes that law­yers and ac­coun­tants cre­ate.

That is what hap­pened here. The ATF closed an un­an­tic­i­pated dodge around the ma­chine gun ban.

Clos­ing loop­holes does not raise is­sues of pol­icy-mak­ing that led the Court in an­other case to abol­ish Chev­ron def­er­ence — the doc­trine of ju­di­cial def­er­ence to reg­u­la­tions in­ter­pret­ing am­big­u­ous stat­utes. There, the prob­lem is that bu­reau­crats, rather than Con­gress, are mak­ing pol­icy de­ci­sions.

Advertise with us

But in the in­stance of the bump-stock ban, as Justice Samuel Alito noted in his con­cur­rence, there can be no doubt that the Con­gress that banned ma­chine guns would have banned bump stocks too, if bump stocks had been known.

Why didn’t Con­gress just ban rapid-fir­ing guns? Be­cause an ex­pert can fire even a semi-au­to­matic ri­fle at up to 180 rounds per minute. Con­gress did not want to raise an is­sue about semi-au­to­matic ri­fles and so de­fined ma­chine guns as fir­ing with one pull of the trig­ger. Even with a bump stock, a ri­fle still tech­ni­cally fires only with a new pull on the trig­ger with each shot. That is why it is not a ma­chine gun but a loop­hole around the ma­chine-gun ban.

Clos­ing the loop­hole

If the bump stock turned ri­fles into ma­chine guns, it was al­ways il­le­gal and the ATF should have banned it all along. Clos­ing a loop­hole was not man­da­tory.

But if the bump stock is a loop­hole, the ATF could have prop­erly de­cided to tol­er­ate it un­til a mass shoot­ing showed how deadly it could be.

Justice Clar­ence Tho­mas’s ma­jor­ity opin­ion briefly ad­dressed the loop­hole is­sue. But he uti­lized a stan­dard im­pos­sible to sat­isfy. The ex­ec­u­tive branch can only close a loop­hole if it ren­ders the un­der­ly­ing stat­ute “use­less.”

Advertise with us

Tho­mas cited no ma­jor­ity opin­ion for this stan­dard and it makes no sense. Stat­utes are still use­ful even when peo­ple find loop­holes. It would be sim­pler to just buy a ma­chine gun than to at­tach a bump stock to a ri­fle. And some ma­chine guns fire even faster than bump-stock equipped ri­fles do.

So what if a law is still use­ful? The stan­dard should be: Does a loop­hole sub­stan­tially in­ter­fere with the un­der­ly­ing Con­gres­sio­nal pol­icy through eva­sion?

The rea­son that we al­low reg­u­la­tory ac­tion to close a loop­hole even when an un­der­ly­ing stat­ute is still ef­fec­tive is that Con­gress can­not be ex­pected to pass a new stat­ute ev­ery time some­one comes up with a clever way to skirt a law. Even apart from the fil­i­bus­ter, which hope­fully will be abol­ished so that Con­gres­sio­nal ma­jor­i­ties can pass laws, such a re­quire­ment would emas­cu­late Con­gress, not em­power it.

Dumb or not, how­ever, we are now stuck with the bump stock de­ci­sion. So, what should we do?

Con­gress would ban them

There has al­ways been a large con­gres­sio­nal ma­jor­ity in fa­vor of ban­ning bump stocks. Such a ban raises no Second Amend­ment is­sue. This ju­di­cial de­ci­sion would have been re­versed im­me­di­ately ex­cept for a threat­ened fil­i­bus­ter in the Senate.

Advertise with us

But, with the at­tempted as­sas­si­na­tion, the sit­u­a­tion has changed. The Trump Ad­min­is­tra­tion banned bump stocks in 2019. Un­doubt­edly, Trump him­self would sup­port leg­is­la­tive ac­tion.

In the in­ter­est of na­tional unity, the Speaker of the House, Re­pub­li­can Mike John­son, and the Ma­jor­ity Leader in the Senate, Dem­o­crat Chuck Schu­mer, should jointly in­tro­duce The Don­ald Trump Act ban­ning bump stocks.

If this were done, the threat­ened fil­i­bus­ter would dis­ap­pear and our na­tion and its lead­ers would be far safer from deadly harm.

Bruce Ledewitz is a professor of law at the Thomas R. Kline School of Law of Duquesne University. His previous article was “The Supreme Court's immunity decision was good for America.” The views expressed do not represent those of Duquesne University.