Neither a lawyer nor an actor playing one on television, I have my view, nonetheless, of the greatest anti-Black judicial decisions in the disgraceful history of the Supreme Court of the United States. The three rulings of the highest court are the shame of a nation that presents itself to the world as believing that freedom and liberty are core American values.
The court’s May 23, 2024, ruling upholding South Carolina’s racist voting-district gerrymandering joins the 1857 Dred Scott and the 1896 Plessy holdings in reminding the world that the prejudicial treatment of Blacks in America has been endorsed by the highest court.
Jim Crow redistricting
The story: South Carolina’s state legislature relied on an old American playbook in drawing the state’s post-2020 Congressional map — Jim Crow racial segregation. The overwhelmingly majority Black 6th South Carolina congressional district has returned the legendary African American Democratic legislator James Clyburn — the sole Black member of Congress from South Carolina — to the U.S. House of Representatives 15 times since 1993.
Ensuring Black voting power does not get too out of hand even more, the handful of Charleston County African Americans not residing in the 6th were targeted by by the Republican-controlled legislature, which scattered them among Charleston County’s voting districts.
In Alexander v. South Carolina Conference of the NAACP (the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People), the civil rights group argued that the gerrymandering is intentionally driven by race. Empirical statistics tell the tale. The Republicans argued that the state’s redistricting action was political and legal.
The Supreme Court decided in favor of the state, requiring the nation to accept South Carolina’s fake assertion rather than the NAACP’s hard evidentiary data.
The sleight-of-hand shenanigan of South Carolina was encouraged by a 2013 decision (also a nefarious disgrace) that struck down an anti-discrimination provision of Section 5 of the 1965 Voting Rights Act, requiring states historically found guilty of voting discrimination — like South Carolina — to receive federal approval before changing voting laws.
Now emboldened, and no longer restrained by the need to get federal approval, the state moved 62% of the Black Charleston voters out of the 1st congressional district into the 6th and diluted their voting power in the city of Charleston.
The decision reminds us of two earlier racist decisions, decisions that formed America and oppressed Black people for a century.
Two earlier decisions
Prior to the 1865 adoption of the 13th Amendment, the Supreme Court disgraced itself and America in the 1857 Dred Scott v. Sandford ruling. The court held that no African American, ‘’free’’ or enslaved, had the right to American citizenship.
Dred Scott was born a slave in Southampton County, Virginia in 1799. As a slave, Mr. Scott mainly worked as a porter. He and his family had been taken as slaves from the slave state of Missouri to the ‘’free’’ state of Illinois and to the ‘’free’’ Wisconsin territory. Mr. and Mrs. Scott sued separately in court for freedom once back in Missouri, arguing that their Illinois and Wisconsin residencies rendered them emancipated.
Not only did the SCOTUS rob the Scotts and all African Americans of human rights enjoyed by white Americans, it scuttled the 1820 congressional Missouri Compromise as containing what the court regarded as the unconstitutional ‘’free’’ designation.
That was the first decision. Here is the second. Determined that America be race-conscious and racist nearly 40 years later, the court’s brand of American justice shot down Homer Plessy.
Shoemaker Homer Plessy — the Plessy of 1896’s Plessy v. Ferguson —was only 1/8 African American, but under the nation’s one drop practice, that was enough for the the Supreme Court to uphold Louisiana racism and guarantee his diminished African American worth.
He was born a Creole in 1858, 1862 or 1863 in New Orleans, Louisiana, and was reared there during Reconstruction. As such, he was never a slave, and he and his family spoke French in their largely racially integrated Louisiana life.
But after the end of Reconstruction in about 1877, with the withdrawal from the south of Federal troops that protected Black people, the activist Citizens’ Committee planned to get him arrested for violating the Separate Car Act, a racist Jim Crow Louisiana state law mandating racially segregated railroad conveyances.
After the state court ruling against him by Judge John Howard Ferguson, Homer Plessy appealed to the Supreme Court and lost 7 to 1. The decision established the infamous “separate but equal” American apartheid way of life.
The third outrage
For nearly the next 60 years, official and de facto segregation was the American way. Only in 1954, in Brown v. Board of Education, was the NAACP and its top attorney Thurgood Marshall able to convince the court of the unconstitutionality of the phony “separate but equal” form of Americana.
Still, today — 70 years after Brown — we have the South Carolina Supreme Court outrage.
Robert Hill is an award-winning Pittsburgh writer and communications consultant. His previous article was “A D-Day hero, he returned to a country where he was still a second class citizen.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.