Nei­ther a law­yer nor an ac­tor play­ing one on tele­vi­sion, I have my view, none­the­less, of the great­est anti-Black ju­di­cial de­ci­sions in the dis­grace­ful his­tory of the Supreme Court of the United States. The three rul­ings of the high­est court are the shame of a na­tion that presents it­self to the world as be­liev­ing that free­dom and lib­erty are core Amer­i­can val­ues.

The court’s May 23, 2024, rul­ing up­hold­ing South Car­o­lina’s rac­ist vot­ing-dis­trict ger­ry­man­der­ing joins the 1857 Dred Scott and the 1896 Plessy hold­ings in re­mind­ing the world that the prej­u­di­cial treat­ment of Blacks in Amer­ica has been en­dorsed by the high­est court.

Jim Crow re­dis­trict­ing

The story: South Car­o­lina’s state leg­is­la­ture re­lied on an old Amer­i­can play­book in draw­ing the state’s post-2020 Con­gres­sio­nal map — Jim Crow ra­cial seg­re­ga­tion. The over­whelm­ingly ma­jor­ity Black 6th South Car­o­lina con­gres­sio­nal dis­trict has re­turned the leg­end­ary African Amer­i­can Demo­cratic leg­is­la­tor James Cly­burn — the sole Black mem­ber of Con­gress from South Car­o­lina — to the U.S. House of Rep­re­sen­ta­tives 15 times since 1993.

En­sur­ing Black vot­ing power does not get too out of hand even more, the hand­ful of Char­les­ton County African Amer­i­cans not re­sid­ing in the 6th were tar­geted by by the Re­pub­li­can-con­trolled leg­is­la­ture, which scat­tered them among Char­les­ton County’s vot­ing dis­tricts.

Advertise with us

In Al­ex­an­der v. South Car­o­lina Con­fer­ence of the NAACP (the Na­tional As­so­ci­a­tion for the Ad­vance­ment of Col­ored People), the civil rights group ar­gued that the ger­ry­man­der­ing is in­ten­tion­ally driven by race. Em­pir­i­cal statis­tics tell the tale. The Re­pub­li­cans ar­gued that the state’s re­dis­trict­ing ac­tion was po­lit­i­cal and le­gal.

The Supreme Court de­cided in fa­vor of the state, re­quir­ing the na­tion to ac­cept South Car­o­lina’s fake as­ser­tion rather than the NAACP’s hard ev­i­den­tiary data.

The sleight-of-hand she­nan­i­gan of South Car­o­lina was en­cour­aged by a 2013 de­ci­sion (also a ne­far­i­ous dis­grace) that struck down an anti-dis­crim­i­na­tion pro­vi­sion of Sec­tion 5 of the 1965 Vot­ing Rights Act, re­quir­ing states his­tor­i­cally found guilty of vot­ing dis­crim­i­na­tion — like South Car­o­lina — to re­ceive fed­eral ap­proval be­fore chang­ing vot­ing laws.

Now em­bold­ened, and no lon­ger re­strained by the need to get fed­eral ap­proval, the state moved 62% of the Black Char­les­ton vot­ers out of the 1st con­gres­sio­nal dis­trict into the 6th and di­luted their vot­ing power in the city of Char­les­ton.

The de­ci­sion re­minds us of two ear­lier rac­ist de­ci­sions, de­ci­sions that formed Amer­ica and op­pressed Black peo­ple for a cen­tury.

Advertise with us

Two ear­lier de­ci­sions

Prior to the 1865 adop­tion of the 13th Amend­ment, the Supreme Court dis­graced it­self and Amer­ica in the 1857 Dred Scott v. Sand­ford rul­ing. The court held that no African Amer­i­can, ‘’free’’ or en­slaved, had the right to Amer­i­can cit­i­zen­ship.

Dred Scott was born a slave in South­amp­ton County, Vir­ginia in 1799. As a slave, Mr. Scott mainly worked as a por­ter. He and his fam­ily had been taken as slaves from the slave state of Mis­souri to the ‘’free’’ state of Il­li­nois and to the ‘’free’’ Wis­con­sin ter­ri­tory. Mr. and Mrs. Scott sued sep­a­rately in court for free­dom once back in Mis­souri, ar­gu­ing that their Il­li­nois and Wis­con­sin res­i­den­cies ren­dered them eman­ci­pated.

Not only did the SCOTUS rob the Scotts and all African Amer­i­cans of hu­man rights en­joyed by white Amer­i­cans, it scut­tled the 1820 con­gres­sio­nal Mis­souri Com­pro­mise as con­tain­ing what the court re­garded as the un­con­sti­tu­tional ‘’free’’ des­ig­na­tion.

That was the first decision. Here is the second. De­ter­mined that Amer­ica be race-con­scious and rac­ist nearly 40 years later, the court’s brand of Amer­i­can justice shot down Homer Plessy.

Shoe­maker Homer Plessy — the Plessy of 1896’s Plessy v. Fer­gu­son —was only 1/​8 African Amer­i­can, but un­der the na­tion’s one drop prac­tice, that was enough for the the Supreme Court to up­hold Lou­i­si­ana rac­ism and guar­an­tee his di­min­ished African Amer­i­can worth.

Advertise with us

He was born a Cre­ole in 1858, 1862 or 1863 in New Or­le­ans, Lou­i­si­ana, and was reared there dur­ing Re­con­struc­tion. As such, he was never a slave, and he and his fam­ily spoke French in their largely ra­cially in­te­grated Lou­i­si­ana life.

But af­ter the end of Re­con­struc­tion in about 1877, with the with­drawal from the south of Fed­eral troops that pro­tected Black peo­ple, the ac­tiv­ist Citi­zens’ Com­mit­tee planned to get him ar­rested for vi­o­lat­ing the Sep­a­rate Car Act, a rac­ist Jim Crow Lou­i­si­ana state law man­dat­ing ra­cially seg­re­gated rail­road con­vey­ances.

After the state court rul­ing against him by Judge John Howard Fer­gu­son, Homer Plessy ap­pealed to the Supreme Court and lost 7 to 1. The de­ci­sion es­tab­lished the in­fa­mous “sep­a­rate but equal” Amer­i­can apart­heid way of life.

The third out­rage

For nearly the next 60 years, of­fi­cial and de facto seg­re­ga­tion was the Amer­i­can way. Only in 1954, in Brown v. Board of Ed­u­ca­tion, was the NAACP and its top at­tor­ney Thur­good Mar­shall able to convince the court of the un­con­sti­tu­tion­al­ity of the phony “sep­a­rate but equal” form of Amer­i­cana.

Still, to­day — 70 years af­ter Brown — we have the South Car­o­lina Supreme Court out­rage.

Robert Hill is an award-winning Pittsburgh writer and communications consultant. His previous article was “A D-Day hero, he returned to a country where he was still a second class citizen.”