Let’s pick on James Dolan, the guy who so un­der­sold the New York Lib­erty that he made them work in an arena that hosted cat shows. It now looks as if Dolan lost about $120 mil­lion when he sold the team. Who knew karma could smell so strongly of a lit­ter­box.

For years Dolan and other own­ers treated the WNBA as a mis­di­rected lit­tle ex­er­tion that came at their per­sonal ex­pense. They whined in­ter­mi­na­bly about hav­ing to con­trib­ute to its mar­ket­ing and sab­o­taged it with sneers — and now they’re pat­ting their pock­ets, while the league’s All-Star Game is one of the most com­pel­ling events of an Olym­pic sum­mer.

Dolan sold the Lib­erty in 2019 to Joe and Clara Tsai of the Brook­lyn Nets for a re­ported $10 to $14 mil­lion. The Lib­erty is now val­ued at $130 mil­lion. In May, the team set a record for rev­e­nue from a sin­gle game with over $2 mil­lion when Cait­lin Clark and the In­di­ana Fever came to town.

Mak­ing a mint

No­body has called out this blinded fis­cal bun­gling with more glee than Alexis Ohanian, the Red­dit co-founder, en­tre­pre­neur and hus­band of Ser­ena Wil­liams, who is mak­ing a mint off the fact that so many leg­acy male sports own­ers chose the con­di­tion of stu­pid­ity.

Advertise with us

“I’ve said it be­fore, and I’ll say it again — the leg­acy of the un­der­in­vest­ment of women’s sports isn’t just bla­tant sex­ism (which it is), it’s also a les­son in gross busi­ness in­com­pe­tence,” Ohanian posted on so­cial me­dia in 2023.

When Ohanian be­came the co-founder and prin­ci­pal in­ves­tor in the NWSL’s An­gel City in 2020, all kinds of peo­ple told him he would take a bath. “I just won­der where those peo­ple are now,” he said tri­um­phantly on the red car­pet of the ESPY’s last week.

Word had leaked out of an im­mi­nent deal for Wil­low Bay and Bob Iger to pur­chase a con­trol­ling stake in An­gel City at a $250 mil­lion val­u­a­tion. The club has been gen­er­at­ing about $30 mil­lion a year in rev­e­nue, high­est in the na­scent Na­tional Women’s Soc­cer League.

When Ohanian first looked around for an in­vest­ment op­por­tu­nity in women’s sports back in 2019, he had the same con­ver­sa­tions over and over with the same type of guys: they had stakes in the WNBA or women’s soc­cer only be­cause they had daugh­ters who liked sports, and wanted to sell. They treated them like “char­ity-pity,” Ohanian says.

They put zero mar­ket­ing or en­ergy into them as busi­nesses. “Like, why are you sur­prised it’s do­ing poorly?” Ohanian wanted to know. They’d swear it wasn’t their lan­guor or dis­mis­sive­ness; peo­ple sim­ply didn’t want to watch women.

Advertise with us

“They had cre­ated an al­most kind of Stock­holm syn­drome of me­di­oc­rity,” Ohanian re­lated in a video posted on In­sta­gram. “… I re­al­ized, this has been com­pound­ing for de­cades. … And that is the part that this new gen­er­a­tion of own­ers have ex­posed.”

Once un­der­val­ued

Ohanian saw what was there to be ob­served: an un­der­val­ued stock. If women’s games at big events like March Mad­ness, the World Cup and the Olym­pics could com­mand huge num­bers, that meant with some real mar­ket­ing those au­di­ences could be­come ha­bit­ual.

The only rea­son they hadn’t so far, in Ohanian’s view, was be­cause they were “un­der-re­sourced, un­der-mar­keted, un­der­val­ued, un­der­ap­pre­ci­ated, un­der­sup­ported.” All of which was cat­nip to an in­ves­tor who likes to be early.

What a con­trast with Dolan, who in 2018 moved the Lib­erty, who av­er­aged al­most 10,000 at Madi­son Square Garden, to a 2,300-seat arena in Westchester and then sold them as a fail­ure. Now he’s cry­ing be­cause an­other thing he to­tally missed was the stream­ing rev­o­lu­tion and viewer cord cut­ting.

Last week, Dolan raged at the NBA be­cause its new me­dia rights deal doesn’t pro­tect his MSG re­gional sports net­work — as if Adam Sil­ver can stop con­sum­ers from can­cel­ing a ca­ble chan­nel run by a guy who in­her­ited his old man’s one good idea.

Advertise with us

The NBA has sub­si­dized the WNBA from the out­set — and as a whole the league hasn’t reached prof­it­abil­ity yet. But com­mis­sioner David Stern saw the league not as a rev­e­nue tool but an in­vest­ment in global au­di­ence growth strat­egy — and that has worked. The WNBA is set to bring in $2.2 bil­lion in a new me­dia rights deal.

It’s hard to be­lieve, but five of the orig­i­nal eight teams in the WNBA are now de­funct, shut down by own­ers who were sim­i­larly un­will­ing to fund or mar­ket, or wait. When Stern preached it was a lon­ger-term in­vest­ment, they didn’t lis­ten.

As one league source told me a few years ago, they sim­ply saw “no up­side” in it. Their at­ti­tude in and of it­self was the profit killer.

The mar­ket speaks

Here’s what they left on the ta­ble: The con­sult­ing-au­dit firm Deloitte pre­dicts that by the end of 2024, rev­e­nue gen­er­ated by elite women’s sports will sur­pass $1 bil­lion for the first time. That’s a 300% in­crease over its last pre­dic­tion in 2021.

As Ohanian has ob­served, “The mar­ket is speak­ing loud and clear, and folks catch up real quick when dol­lars are in­volved.” The mar­ket is not just speak­ing — it’s roar­ing. And laugh­ing.

Sally Jenkins is a sports columnist for The Washington Post.