It’s not often that Paul Krugman and Donald Trump agree. But the Nobel-prize-winning economist and former (and future?) president have both subscribed to the mainstream consensus that, in the short run, less skilled immigrants are a burden on public finances. They may receive government benefits, including health care, yet they do not always contribute to the economy.

But ac­cord­ing to new re­search, new low-skilled im­mi­grants to the US are a net fis­cal plus. Each adds an es­ti­mated $750 a year to gov­ern­ment cof­fers at the fed­eral, state and lo­cal lev­els. And their con­tri­bu­tion to the en­tire econ­omy is likely larger still.

Help­ing na­tive work­ers

These new mea­sures do not deny the stan­dard as­sess­ments of the po­ten­tial fis­cal costs of im­mi­grants. Rather, they con­sider an ad­di­tional pos­i­tive fac­tor: namely, that low-skilled im­mi­grants en­able na­tive work­ers to move into higher-wage jobs, and in some cases to work more hours.

Con­sider work­ing par­ents who would choose more de­mand­ing and higher-pay­ing jobs if cheaper and more con­ve­nient child care, which typ­i­cally re­quires only a high school di­ploma, were avail­able. If a new im­mi­grant pro­vided that care, those par­ents would be able to earn more money — and would pay more taxes.

Advertise with us

That is an ob­vi­ous and rel­a­tively vis­i­ble story. A more in­di­rect ef­fect in­volves busi­nesses. When cheaper la­bor is avail­able, they may make big­ger and more am­bi­tious plans, which also has ben­e­fits for gov­ern­ment rev­e­nue. In any case, the in­di­rect fis­cal ef­fects of the im­mi­grants will be more pos­i­tive than the di­rect ef­fects.

To be clear, the pos­i­tive fis­cal es­ti­mate does not ap­ply to all im­mi­grants: They ap­ply only to un­skilled im­mi­grants with a high school de­gree. Un­skilled im­mi­grants with­out a high school de­gree still have net neg­a­tive fis­cal ef­fects, though not by nearly as much as pre­vi­ous re­search sug­gests.

The ev­i­dence

This re­search doesn’t con­sider two im­por­tant fac­tors.

First, it doesn’t com­pare im­mi­grants who ar­rive le­gally to those who don’t. Based on eco­nomic prin­ci­ples, how­ever, there is a pre­sump­tion that those who ar­rive le­gally will be more ef­fec­tive in add­ing value to the econ­omy, fis­cal fac­tors in­cluded. They can make bet­ter and lon­ger-range plans, and they are more likely to as­sim­i­late in a pro­duc­tive man­ner.

Second, it does not ac­count for the pos­si­bil­ity that greater im­mi­gra­tion raises hous­ing prices in a re­gion. That typ­i­cally leads to higher prop­erty tax pay­ments.

Advertise with us

Such an out­come may or may not be de­sir­able — but it is an­other way im­mi­grants may have a net pos­i­tive fis­cal im­pact. Again, from a strictly bud­ge­tary point of view, the new ar­riv­als are more than pay­ing for them­selves.

It’s also im­por­tant not to over­inter­pret these re­sults. As my col­league Bryan Caplan likes to say, “Trust lit­er­a­tures, not sin­gle pa­pers.”

That said, other re­cent ev­i­dence in­di­cates that im­mi­grants to the US boost both wages and em­ploy­ment for na­tive work­ers. That re­search counts skilled im­mi­gra­tion as well, also find­ing that it re­sults in an oc­cu­pa­tional up­grad­ing of the jobs held by na­tives. It is thus broadly con­sis­tent with find­ing pos­i­tive fis­cal re­sults from a greater num­ber of less skilled im­mi­grants.

At the very least, it seems pru­dent to dis­card the as­sump­tion that low-skilled im­mi­gra­tion is bad for pub­lic bud­gets. The most vis­i­ble fis­cal ef­fects are neg­a­tive — such as im­mi­grants ar­riv­ing in cit­ies by bus and re­quir­ing im­me­di­ate aid — but it is a fun­da­men­tal prin­ci­ple of eco­nom­ics to look past the seen and con­sider the un­seen.

Neg­a­tive con­se­quences

Other un­seen con­se­quences may be rel­e­vant too, not all of them pos­i­tive.

Advertise with us

More un­skilled im­mi­grants could also cre­ate po­lit­i­cal back­lash, and aid the rise of harm­ful pop­u­list pol­i­ti­cians. That can have lon­ger-term neg­a­tive con­se­quences, many of them se­ri­ous in na­ture, and some of them fis­cal as well, since pop­u­lists typ­i­cally are not fis­cally re­spon­si­ble.

So the led­ger of ef­fects of less skilled im­mi­gra­tion is far from com­plete. None­the­less, when you next hear the com­plaint that low-skilled im­mi­grants are costing the gov­ern­ment money, treat it as a hy­poth­e­sis, not a fact.

Tyler Cowen, a columnist for Bloomberg Opinion, is professor of economics at George Mason University. His previous article was “Why conservatives oppose lab-grown beef.”