Earlier this week, Donald Trump posted one of his signature slam poetry missives on MAGA social media. For those trained in the art of deciphering his work, the post called out Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and his voters for potentially casting a “wasted protest vote.”

And just that effortlessly, Trump aligned himself perfectly with President Biden and the leadership of the Democratic Party.

It’s not a new phenomenon. Attacking competition to the two-party system is one of the few areas where Democrats and Republicans agree.

The reigning duopoly

It’s been true for decades. This year, Democrats are apparently buoyed by their successful effort to derail the attempt by the nonpartisan No Labels group to field a “unity ticket” in the 2024 presidential race, where they unloaded the trifecta of arguments — wasted votes, stolen votes, and spoiled elections — routinely used to undermine independent candidates.

Advertise with us

This bipartisan claim that political competition is a bad thing seems to be rooted in the shared self-serving argument that nothing is better for America than a perpetuation of two-party rule.

To the reigning duopoly, it’s an entitlement, a birthright. Republican and Democratic Party leaders alike parrot this line, notwithstanding the fact that most Americans want more choices at the ballot box.

The wasted vote argument — the idea that if you vote for an independent candidate, you’re wasting your vote because the independent can’t possibly win — is their mainstay. Not only do partisans regurgitate it every chance they get, but it gets repeated by the mainstream media and by political scientists as an article of faith. I believe it is one of the biggest myths in our political lexicon.

Not surprisingly, in the legacy media’s not-so-subtle attempt to elevate their favorite partisan candidate, they never use the wasted vote argument when talking about Joe Biden voters in Alabama or Donald Trump voters in California. If what defines “wasting” a vote is voting for a candidate that can’t possibly win, those votes are equally futile.

When you dig deeper into the wasted vote canard, you realize that by partisan definitions, all votes are wasted. No single vote will determine the outcome of a presidential race.

Advertise with us

That’s not just a supposition. In political science terms, it can be considered as immutable as the law of gravity.

Your vote matters

Since the signing of the Constitution, there has only been one statewide election decided by a single vote: the 1839 governor’s race in Massachusetts. That race is the sole anomaly in American history, and it occurred over 180 years ago. In 1839, that outcome was more likely as half as many Bay Staters voted in that statewide race as vote today in a single congressional contest.

That’s not to say that your vote doesn’t matter. It does, but not for the reason politicians want you to believe. While your one vote won’t change the outcome of the presidential contest, it is valuable as a reflection of who you are and what you care about.

In that sense, all votes are about sending a message. That message might be a positive one about policies that align with your views or candidates who inspire you. Or it’s often a negative one, a protest of the choices offered by the two-party system or, more likely in this race, a vote against the candidate you hate and fear the most.

But there’s a problem with negative votes. They let the politicians off the hook. If we all vote against the candidates we dislike the most, to win reelection, a politician doesn’t need to solve problems or improve your life or even honor the promises they made while campaigning. They simply need to make you afraid of their opponent.

Advertise with us

That’s a bridge to nowhere. It’s the root cause of the stagnation in our country. It’s the reason we may be the first generation to fail to honor the sacred social contract that’s at the foundation of the great American Idea – that we leave a better country to future generations.

Send a message

So, if Bobby Kennedy Jr. or any other independent or third-party candidate inspires you, vote for him. You won’t be wasting your vote. You’ll be sending a powerful message — that neither party is entitled to your vote.

It can’t be stolen or wasted, only earned. And you earn it by inspiring voters and improving their lives, not by scaring them.

Greg Orman is a Kansas entrepreneur, author of “A Declaration of Independents,” and a former independent candidate for governor and senator of his state. His website is www.greg-orman.com.