The House of Rep­re­sen­ta­tives fi­nally over­came MAGA op­po­si­tion and ap­proved a new aid pack­age for Ukraine. Like many ob­serv­ers, I was si­mul­ta­ne­ously re­lieved, ashamed, an­gry and wor­ried by what has hap­pened.

I’m re­lieved that a na­tion un­der siege will prob­a­bly sur­vive, at least for a while, some­thing that was in­creas­ingly in doubt given over­whelm­ing Rus­sian ar­til­lery su­pe­ri­or­ity. I’m ashamed that things got to this point — that Amer­ica came so close to be­tray­ing a de­moc­racy in dan­ger.

I’m an­gry at the po­lit­i­cal fac­tion that blocked aid for so many months be­cause they want Vladimir Putin to win. And I’m wor­ried be­cause that fac­tion re­mains pow­er­ful — a ma­jor­ity of Re­pub­li­cans in the House voted against Ukraine aid — and could still doom Ukraine in the years ahead.

The myths

Let me take on some myths about aid to Ukraine.

Advertise with us

No, spend­ing on Ukraine isn’t a huge bur­den on Amer­ica, com­ing at the ex­pense of do­mes­tic pri­or­i­ties. No, Amer­ica isn’t bear­ing this cost alone, with­out help from our Euro­pean al­lies. Yes, U.S. aid is still cru­cial, in part be­cause Europe can sup­ply money but isn’t yet in a po­si­tion to sup­ply enough mil­i­tary hard­ware.

Look at an ob­vi­ous his­tor­i­cal par­al­lel to cur­rent aid to Ukraine: Frank­lin Roosevelt’s Lend-Lease pro­gram. It be­gan de­liv­er­ing aid to Brit­ain and China in 1941, be­fore Pearl Har­bor brought Amer­ica of­fi­cially into World War II.

It is of­ten for­got­ten how con­tro­ver­sial that aid was at the time. An Amer­ica First move­ment op­posed any aid to em­bat­tled Brit­ain, in part be­cause some of its prom­i­nent lead­ers, no­ta­bly Char­les Lind­bergh, were openly sym­pa­thetic to the Na­zis.

Even in Con­gress, Lend-Lease was a deeply par­ti­san is­sue. The ini­tial bill, en­acted in early 1941, passed the House with very lit­tle Re­pub­li­can sup­port. Sup­port for was closely cor­related with eco­nomic ide­ol­ogy. Al­most all lib­er­als fa­vored sup­port­ing Brit­ain in its dark­est hour; many con­ser­va­tives didn’t.

Yet Con­gress ap­pro­pri­ated $13 bil­lion be­fore the at­tack on Pearl Har­bor. This was an im­mense sum at the time — about 10% of Amer­ica’s an­nual gross do­mes­tic prod­uct. Some­what sur­pris­ingly, how­ever, not much of that to­tal con­sisted of weap­onry. As the Amer­i­can His­tor­i­cal As­so­ci­a­tion noted: “Our mu­ni­tions in­dus­try was still largely in the tool­ing up state. And the flow of fin­ished weap­ons was at first only a trickle.”

Advertise with us

Indeed. Europe had be­gun re­arm­ing years be­fore World War II started, while an iso­la­tion­ist United States hadn’t de­vel­oped much of a de­fense in­dus­try. To take a fa­mous ex­am­ple, the Sher­man tank didn’t go into pro­duc­tion un­til 1942. As a re­sult, most of Amer­ica’s ini­tial aid took the form of food — at first we were less the ar­se­nal of de­moc­racy than its bread­bas­ket.

Lend-lease then, Ukraine aid now

How does aid to Ukraine com­pare with that ex­pe­ri­ence?

First, it’s vastly smaller rel­a­tive to the size of our econ­omy. The just-passed pack­age will roughly dou­ble the cu­mu­la­tive aid we’ve given Ukraine, but at about $60 bil­lion it’s less than one-fourth of 1% of GDP — around one-for­ti­eth the size of the ini­tial Lend-Lease ap­pro­pri­a­tion.

Any­one claim­ing that spend­ing on this scale will break the bud­get, or that it will se­ri­ously in­ter­fere with other pri­or­i­ties, is in­nu­mer­ate, dis­in­gen­u­ous or both.

What about claims that Amer­ica is bear­ing too much of the bur­den? Last week Don­ald Trump ac­cused Europe of fail­ing to pay its share: “Why is it that the United States is over $100 Bil­lion Dol­lars into the Ukraine War more than Europe, and we have an Ocean be­tween us in sep­a­ra­tion? Why can’t Europe equal­ize or match the money put in by the United States of Amer­ica in or­der to help a Coun­try in des­per­ate need?”

Advertise with us

His as­ser­tions are false. As the Kiel In­sti­tute re­ports, “to­tal Euro­pean aid has long over­taken U.S. aid — not only in terms of com­mit­ments, but also in terms of spe­cific aid al­lo­ca­tions sent to Ukraine.” Notably, many though not all Euro­pean na­tions are spend­ing sub­stan­tially more in sup­port of Ukraine as a per­cent­age of GDP than we are.

Amer­ica’s con­tin­u­ing role

The United States has pro­vided more mil­i­tary aid than Europe. Why? In the first year of Lend-Lease, Amer­ica couldn’t sup­ply much in the way of weap­ons, be­cause years of low mil­i­tary spend­ing had left us with an un­der­de­vel­oped mil­i­tary-in­dus­trial base.

It took a cou­ple of years to trans­late Amer­ica’s over­all in­dus­trial might into com­pa­ra­ble mil­i­tary might. Europe is in a sim­i­lar sit­u­a­tion. It has the money to help Ukraine, and for the most part the will, but it doesn’t have the pro­duc­tion ca­pac­ity to meet Ukraine’s mil­i­tary needs. U.S. aid re­mains es­sen­tial.

So as I said, I’m re­lieved that Amer­ica has fi­nally re­leased es­sen­tial aid, but still very wor­ried about the fu­ture. For now, at least, U.S. sup­port re­mains cru­cial to Ukraine’s sur­vival.

Paul Krugman is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “Why Ohio is moving right and turning red.”