Kirk Johnsen unzipped his khaki tent and popped just his head out first. “They want to criminalize us,” said the 38-year-old, who has been living in an encampment about two miles from the Supreme Court, which on Monday heard arguments on anti-camping laws in Oregon. The case could have sweeping implications for homeless encampments across the United States.
The encampment where Johnsen lives is a small community in the middle of federal D.C., a leafy, green triangle between the massive U.S. State Department and the Interior Department. There is a hodgepodge of multicolored porch chairs at most tent openings, bric-a-brac lawn ornaments, picnic tables and shopping carts parked in neat rows under tarp canopies.
One squat tent is cramped under a wild cat’s cradle of rope and string. Another sits at the end of a long runner with a bold floral pattern and a yard fenced off with scavenged ropes and poles. The setups are as varied as the reasons the dwellers found themselves there.
A growing reality
This scene is a growing reality in cities across the United States, big and small, red and blue. In D.C., the encampments grow and shrink, the people and their tents get pushed around, sometimes violently, such as the time a bulldozer scooped up a tent with a man inside.
As housing prices soar, wages stagnate and tents mushroom in the decay of America’s dying promise of opportunity, local governments faced with inadequate, unaffordable housing and temporary shelter for all of their residents are struggling with what to do about the growing crisis.
It seems housing would be the answer to homelessness. But in Grants Pass, Ore., city leaders decided to fine and jail the people — from veterans to housekeepers — who drop through the social safety net and end up sleeping outside.
The case focuses on whether treating tent-sleeping as criminal conduct constitutes the “cruel and unusual punishment” that our Eighth Amendment bans.
“This isn’t camping,” explained Shelley Byars, 46, one of the most vocal residents of the Virginia Avenue encampment, pulling out the padlock that she puts on her tent whenever she leaves. “I camped as a kid. I camped with my son. What I’m doing here is surviving. Living.”
Rocks the size of cantaloupes were once hurled at her tent when she pitched it on a median in Northeast Washington. Another time, her tent was slashed.
On Sunday night, hours before the nation’s highest court was scheduled to hear arguments in the Oregon case, firefighters arrived when the tent next to Byars’s went up in flames. “That wasn’t an accident,” Byars said. “Someone meant to do that.” A spokesman for the D.C. fire department said investigators couldn’t find the cause.
Not an aspiration
The Supreme Court case arguments will belabor why people like Byars and Johnsen are living outside, as though it were a choice or luxury someone aspired to. No matter where you go, the answers are varied, but the pattern is the same. A job was lost. An eviction notice came. A mental illness was diagnosed. An addiction was voracious and unrelenting.
In many cases, death gashed the biggest hole in a safety net that had held a vulnerable person for so long. “My sister. She was my backbone,” said Frederick, 56. Born and raised in D.C., Frederick worked on and off in construction most of his life. Since his sister died a year ago, he has been living in a tent pitched in a freeway underpass on Capitol Hill, just five blocks from the Supreme Court.
“My sister helped me with everything. She was like my mother,” he said, through the bug screen of his tent window. “Now I’m trying to get a housing voucher without her help.”
Next to him is Jose Lopez, 42. He’s got a voucher and just did an intake interview a couple of weeks ago. Originally from Puerto Rico and Florida, Lopez said he came to D.C. for a court case, then didn’t have the money to return south after it was over. He wants to work, but living in a tent doesn’t make it easy.
Lopez, Byars, Johnsen: None of them dreamed of living in a tent. This wasn’t what they wanted.
Forced into homelessness
That was the message from a lineup of speakers outside the Supreme Court on Monday. Occasionally, they’d get live updates from inside.
“People do not choose to be homeless,” Donald Whitehead, who heads the National Coalition for the Homeless, said outside the Supreme Court. “They are forced into homelessness by a safety net riddled with holes.”
A few blocks away, the man who is lost without his sister’s help wondered why any court would punish his struggle. “Is that a crime?” he said. “Just trying to live?”
Dvorak is a columnist for The Washington Post’s local team. Her previous article was “Hamas's attack on Israel makes the high tide of American antisemitism even higher.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.