This month, a Pew Re­search Center sur­vey showed that the be­liefs and at­ti­tudes of the 45% of Amer­i­cans who had heard about Chris­tian na­tion­al­ism were re­mark­ably static. After months of de­bates in the me­dia, the opin­ions of Amer­i­cans, fa­vor­able and un­fa­vor­able, re­mained al­most com­pletely un­changed.

How could this be? The Chris­tian na­tion­al­ism de­bate has flooded on­line spaces since Jan. 6, 2021, if not ear­lier. Is it ac­tu­ally pos­si­ble that all of those ar­ti­cles, pod­casts and speeches have made no dif­fer­ence at all?

The poll re­sult makes per­fect sense. Amer­i­cans have been hav­ing a fu­ri­ous on­line con­ver­sa­tion about Chris­tian na­tion­al­ism — yet an on­line con­ver­sa­tion isn’t the same thing as a na­tional con­ver­sa­tion.

The po­lit­i­cal mi­nor­ity ar­gues on­line

I’m re­minded of one of the most il­lu­mi­nat­ing stud­ies I’ve ever read. It came from the Hid­den Tribes of Amer­ica proj­ect, which was put to­gether by a group called More in Com­mon.

Advertise with us

It sur­veyed 8,000 Amer­i­cans to try to ex­plore their at­ti­tudes and con­flicts be­yond the red-blue di­vide. One of its cen­tral con­clu­sions is crit­i­cal to un­der­stand­ing the mod­ern mo­ment: Only a mi­nor­ity of Amer­i­cans are truly ac­tive in po­lit­i­cal de­bates, and they’re ex­haust­ing and alien­at­ing the rest of the coun­try.

In 2019 my New York Times col­leagues Nate Cohn and Kevin Quealy used this data to ex­pose the vast dif­fer­ence be­tween on­line and off­line Dem­o­crats. One-third of Dem­o­crats post po­lit­i­cal con­tent on so­cial me­dia; two-thirds do not. And the dif­fer­ences be­tween the two groups were sig­nifi­cant. On­line Dem­o­crats were far more lib­eral, dis­pro­por­tion­ately white and far more likely to en­gage in ac­tiv­ism, such as at­tend­ing a pro­test or do­nat­ing to a can­di­date.

Don’t think for a mo­ment that this di­chot­omy ex­ists only on the left. More in Com­mon found that both wings of Amer­i­can life — the highly po­lar­ized left and the highly po­lar­ized right — shared char­ac­ter­is­tics. For ex­am­ple, the most po­lar­ized con­ser­va­tives are also dis­pro­por­tion­ately white and are al­most twice as likely to list pol­i­tics as a hobby.

To­gether, these po­lar­ized wings are the most united, most tribal and least per­suad­able Amer­i­cans. Or, as More in Com­mon put it, mem­bers of the wings are “the most cer­tain of their po­si­tions.” The rest of Amer­i­cans — the other two-thirds — con­sti­tute an “ex­hausted ma­jor­ity.” They’re deeply dis­con­tented with Amer­i­can pol­i­tics, and many are also largely dis­en­gaged.

So, then, the Pew poll on Chris­tian na­tion­al­ism makes sense. Yes, there’s been a fu­ri­ous ar­gu­ment, but it’s been con­ducted both within and be­tween the po­lar­ized wings. Few peo­ple in those groups ever change their minds. Ev­ery­one else doesn’t even know the de­bate is hap­pen­ing.

Advertise with us

The ma­jor­ity isn’t en­gaged

This kind of ex­haus­tion mag­ni­fies our po­lit­i­cal in­er­tia. If the wings aren’t chang­ing their minds and the ma­jor­ity is checked out, then sta­sis can set in.

The en­gaged mem­bers of the wings are neg­a­tively po­lar­ized. There is no way they’re switch­ing teams. The ex­hausted ma­jor­ity is dis­con­tent with the sta­tus quo, but it’s largely pas­sive. It doesn’t ex­ert nearly enough en­ergy to re­pair our po­lit­i­cal cul­ture, even though it wants change.

To bet­ter un­der­stand the dy­namic, imag­ine our po­lit­i­cal con­tro­ver­sies as a court case in which the law­yers ar­gue with each other but most of the jury doesn’t even ar­rive un­til the end of the case. Yes, they cast votes, but their de­ci­sions are rooted in their ex­ist­ing bi­ases, not the ev­i­dence.

The law­yers are livid at the ab­sent ju­rors. The ju­rors are re­pulsed by the law­yers’ hos­til­ity, and noth­ing changes.

This large-scale dis­en­gage­ment can cause us to mis­di­ag­nose ig­no­rance as in­dif­fer­ence. For ex­am­ple, a YouGov sur­vey con­ducted this year found that most Re­pub­li­cans don’t know or aren’t sure whether Don­ald Trump was found li­a­ble for sex­u­ally as­sault­ing and de­fam­ing E. Jean Car­roll. They don’t know or aren’t sure whether Trump has been sued for fraud or charged with mis­han­dling clas­si­fied in­for­ma­tion or at­tempt­ing to un­law­fully over­turn the re­sults of the 2020 elec­tion.

Advertise with us

Ex­pe­ri­ence teaches us that most dis­en­gaged Re­pub­li­cans would quite likely stay Re­pub­li­can even if they knew the truth about Trump. It’s also true, how­ever, that ab­sent new in­for­ma­tion, they have no good rea­son to change their votes. Yet when they dis­en­gage, they re­move them­selves from the in­for­ma­tion that could change their minds.

Dis­en­gage­ment is rea­son­able but bad

The de­ci­sion to un­plug from the news is of­ten quite ra­tio­nal and per­haps even pru­dent — com­pound­ing the prob­lem. Dis­en­gage­ment is a rea­son­able re­sponse to the un­rea­son­able vit­riol that dom­i­nates our po­lit­i­cal con­ver­sa­tions. Weigh­ing in on pol­i­tics on­line or even watch­ing it pas­sively is like vol­un­tar­ily choos­ing to re­ceive an elec­tric shock.

One friend told me, “I got sick of the con­stant rage.” So he de­leted his so­cial me­dia ac­counts, turned his ca­ble tele­vi­sion from Fox News to ESPN and never looked back. “My blood pres­sure is down,” he said, “and I’m a bet­ter hus­band and father.”

Good for him, I thought, but bad for us. Another de­cent man has dis­en­gaged. Another mem­ber of the jury has left the court­room.

David Brooks is a columnist for the New York Times, where this article originally appeared. His previous article was “Things are better for the Democrats than they look.”