In writing about “Dune,” book and movie, I want to highlight the larger civilizational dynamic that the book sets up and how it speaks to our own moment. In particular, it speaks to the ways that the developed world today feels stuck in a loop of decadence and disappointment and sterile repetition, from which (some) people look upward and outward in search of hope — seeking it in the promise of artificial intelligence, in genetic engineering and the dream of “transhumanism,” or in a new age of spaceflight or a revival of religion.

“Dune” the novel, somewhat more clearly than its adaptation, presents a galaxy-spanning society that has wrestled with each of these possibilities and made very concrete choices.

Civilization’s choices

Space travel, obviously, has been the engine of this civilization’s development and spread. AI has been invented, embraced and then explicitly rejected through the long-ago convulsion called the “Butlerian Jihad,” which establishes, as a commandment, “Thou shalt not make a machine in the likeness of a human mind.”

Advertise with us

Transhumanism, meanwhile, has been rejected in some ways and embraced in others. In place of computers, Herbert’s galactic imperium has cultivated what we would consider superhuman mental powers, often via the use of mind-altering drugs — Google Gemini, absolutely not; psychedelics, maybe so.

At the same time, the imperium’s powerful Bene Gesserit sisterhood has pursued a vast eugenic project, but one that’s hedged about with various taboos. When a Bene Gesserit reverend mother in “Dune Messiah” is offered the chance to continue her eugenic work via artificial insemination rather than arranged pairings of men and women, she recoils from the idea, since “no word or deed could imply that men might be bred on the level of animals.” Selective mating, yes; cloning and IVF, maybe not.

Finally, religion has flourished in this spacefaring future via a kind of syncretistic creativity: The novel’s main scripture, the Orange Catholic Bible, is the kind of ecumenical holy book that probably seemed a bit more plausible in the 1960s, when “Dune” first appeared, than it does today. The religions of the future are mostly remixes of Old Earth faiths, complete with names like “Zensunni,” “Navachristianity” and “Buddislam.”

So you can see “Dune” as presenting a civilization that has achieved galactic takeoff while working through, in weird but recognizable ways, our own cultural-technological debates. But then Herbert further portrays his far-future world as having fallen into decadence itself, with a stable but cruel order based on corporate feudalism, religious manipulation and other interlocking exploitations.

And here some of the debates around the movie adaptation, about whether the main character, Paul Atreides, is a liberator or an oppressor, a hero or a villain, miss the harsher argument at work in the original story: namely, that sometimes the only path out of a corrupt status quo involves convulsion and fanaticism and death. So the book’s Paul is both a hero and a villain, both a destroyer and a savior; he’s taking a terrible path that’s also the only plausible path for humanity to take. (And to readers of the later books: Yes, I know that eventually this path requires a long period of even deeper decadence under a human-sandworm hybrid god-emperor in order to prepare humanity for a new explosion of interstellar migration, and also to breed a line of humans immune from prophecy and prescience. Look, I’m not a nerd; you’re a nerd.)

Advertise with us

Villeneuve’s new movie (mild spoilers ahead) tries to slip away from that dynamic by making Paul’s romance into more of a road not taken. His love interest, Chani, is presented as a kind of secular nationalist in contrast to the religious fundamentalists among her people, the desert-dwelling Fremen, and she wants Paul to join their cause without leading them into a galactic holy war. (In the novel, she doesn’t seem to have these kinds of qualms.) And the later Herbert books sometimes try to have their cake and eat it too, hinting that this period of fanaticism and dictatorship and messianic rule was necessary to liberate humanity from still worse, potentially species-ending forms of dictatorship and messianic control. The Great Man of History, but just this once and never again.

But in the original book — which is the only good book — you root for the Great Man, the bloody-handed messiah, because the order he’s up against deserves to fall. And even in the movie, that basic architecture is still in place: Paul’s main enemies, the Harkonnens, are portrayed as satanic totalitarians, and the only clear political alternatives are a galaxy misgoverned by cruel despots and a galaxy where he accepts his destiny and unleashes his jihad. Permanent decadence or bloody remaking — choose your poison wisely.

Ross Douthat is a columnist for The New York Times. His previous article was “A case for aiding Ukraine when Ukraine won't win.”