Medical disinformation has more than political consequences. It costs lives. Pseudoscience debunker Peter Hotez calculates that as many as 200,000 Americans may have perished because of COVID after the vaccines were introduced because anti-vaccine propaganda dissuaded them from getting the shots.
Cases of measles, which should have been eradicated in the U.S. years ago, are appearing again because of disinformation about the vaccines. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention counts more than 20 measles cases so far this year in at least 11 states. That's about one-third of the 58 cases recorded in all of last year, in only the first six weeks of 2024, suggesting that a more serious epidemic may be coming.
Six cases have occurred in a single school in Florida, a state whose Republican governor, Ron DeSantis, has placed anti-vaccine propaganda at the center of his public health policies. The school's measles vaccination rate is about 89%, well below the 95% level thought to provide communal immunity protecting even the unvaccinated.
It comes from the government
The politicization of anti-COVID measures has turbocharged health care disinformation more generally. In part, the reason may be that the pandemic brought public health efforts out of the shadows.
"Often, public health has been an invisible force for good," Tara Kirk Sell of Johns Hopkins University's Center for Health Security told me. "People don't really notice it because they don't notice not getting sick and not getting food poisoning." During the pandemic, however, "people saw public health acting in a more visible way, that made them aware, and sometimes a little bit scared, that sometimes public health measures can be restrictive."
Read More
The battle against disinformation has gotten harder. One reason is that now it comes from government sources. One of the nation's most assiduous dispensers of anti-vaccine claptrap is Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo, who was inserted into his post by DeSantis, who may be the nation's second-most-dangerous official offender against good sense and sound public health policy.
The CDC places vaccination at the very top of its recommendations for preventing the disease and advises isolating those who may transmit the virus. Ladapo's approach to the Florida measles outbreak includes downplaying the need for children to be vaccinated and allowing parents to make their own decision about sending even unvaccinated children to schools experiencing an outbreak.
A problem for anti-disinformation crusaders is explained in Brandolini's Law, coined in 2013 by Alberto Brandolini, an Italian software engineer: "The amount of energy needed to refute [B.S.] is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it."
Disinformation peddlers need only make a claim that sounds plausible or might even have a small kernel of truth to influence the unwary. Debunking or refuting their assertions often requires offering nuanced or technical information that doesn't have the same pizzazz.
Rules of engagement
Recognizing disinformation techniques and how they implant sticky but erroneous concepts in the minds of laypersons, Sell says, points to some useful rules of engagement. One is the value of "prebunking" — "addressing or refuting potential false information" before it's widely disseminated.
"People are not that creative," she says. "They use the same stories over and over again with different health threats. You can expect that with any vaccination campaign there will be an infertility rumor, no matter what vaccine it is, or a rumor that a vaccine has been experimented on children. We see that every time. They work because they resonate" with target audiences, such as pregnant women or parents of small children.
"People need to be shown how to recognize disinformation tactics, such as an appeal to emotion" or personal stories of adverse side effects that are claimed to be representative of patients as a whole rather than rare occurrences.
It may also help to highlight the motivations of anti-science propagandists, who spread disinformation "often for social, political or financial gain."
Indeed, as the Washington Post recently documented from tax records, four nonprofit organizations that marketed medical misinformation during the pandemic saw their contributions leap by more than $100 million from 2020 to 2022. Among them is Children's Health Defense, the anti-vaccine group founded by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who is currently trying to ride his anti-vaccine crusade to the Oval Office.
The lessons of the pandemic may help the public health community avoid some of the mistakes that allowed the disinformation lobby to undermine the public's trust in scientists and medical experts, a crucial factor in its campaigns. The CDC and other public health agencies sometimes changed their recommendations on anti-COVID policies.
That was hardly an unexpected occurrence, since so little was known at first about the virus, its effects and the most suitable treatments. But it gave their adversaries the opening they needed to question the severity of the outbreak or the policy recommendations themselves, and to promote useless nostrums.
Transparent public health
"Public health needs to be transparent about the reasons why advice is changing," Sell says, "explaining that if you didn't change with new evidence, you would be doing a disservice to the public. Maybe we didn't do a good enough job in this pandemic in saying we're going to learn more, and our advice may change. And we'll do our best to keep you as informed as possible as that advice changes."
“There are things to be done,” Sell says, “and we can't give up. Attacking misinformation in as many different ways as possible is something we're going to have to do."
Michael Hiltzik is a columnist for the Los Angeles Times. His previous article was “The NCAA wants to keep making money off unpaid student athletes.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.