Paul Pressler’s story is eerily similar to that of Harvey Weinstein. Both were powerful men so brazen about their misconduct that it was an “open secret” in their respective worlds. Yet they were also so powerful that an army of enablers coalesced around them, protecting them from the consequences of their actions.

A single individual can be a predator, but it takes a village to protect him from exposure and punishment.

The scandal

Late last month, the Southern Baptist Convention settled a sex abuse lawsuit brought against Pressler. The lawsuit alleged that he had raped a man named Duane Rollins for decades, beginning when he was only 14 years old. (Pressler has not admitted guilt.)

Advertise with us

While relatively unknown outside of evangelical circles, Pressler is one of the most important American religious figures of the 20th century. He and his friend Paige Patterson were two of the key architects of the so-called “conservative resurgence” within the SBC.

The movement, launched in the 1970s, wrested control of the SBC from more theologically liberal and moderate voices. The SBC lurched to the right and exploded in growth, ultimately becoming the largest Protestant denomination in the United States.

Pressler and Patterson were heroes within the movement. Patterson led Baptist seminaries and became president of the convention. Pressler was a Texas state judge and a former president of the Council for National Policy, a powerful conservative Christian activist organization.

Both men are now disgraced. In 2018, the board of Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary fired Patterson after it found that he’d grossly mishandled rape allegations — including writing in an email that he wanted to meet alone with a woman who had reported being raped to “break her down” — at two Baptist seminaries.

Pressler’s story is even worse. People were aware of allegations against him. In 2004, for example, First Baptist Church of Houston investigated accusations that he had groped and undressed a college student, deemed his behavior “morally and spiritually inappropriate” and warned him, but took no other action.

Advertise with us

Rollins’ lawsuit set off a sprawling investigation into SBC sexual misconduct by The Houston Chronicle and The San Antonio Express-News. Their report, called “Abuse of Faith,” documented hundreds of sex abuse cases in the SBC and led to the denomination commissioning an independent investigation of its handling of abuse.

For decades, survivors of sex abuse “were ignored, disbelieved or met with the constant refrain that the SBC could take no action due to its polity regarding church autonomy — even if it meant that convicted molesters continued in ministry with no notice or warning to their current church or congregation.”

This is why we’re polarized

It’s important to write about this abuse even if we can only bear witness to the injustice. But the coverage, or lack thereof, of Pressler’s fall also helps explain why we’re so very polarized as a nation.

The American right exists in a news environment that reports misconduct on the left or in left-wing institutions loudly and with granular detail. When Weinstein fell and that fall prompted the cascade of revelations that created the #MeToo moment, the right was overrun with commentary on the larger lessons of the episode, including scathing indictments of a Hollywood culture that permitted so much abuse for so very long.

Advertise with us

Much of this commentary was good and necessary. Hollywood deserved the indictment. But the coverage on the right also fit a cherished conservative narrative: that liberal sexual values such as those in Hollywood invariably lead to abuse. In Christian America, it was more ammunition for the sense that a righteous “us” was taking on a villainous “them.”

But stories such as Pressler’s complicate this narrative immensely. If both the advocates and enemies of the sexual revolution have their Harvey Weinsteins — that is, if both progressive and conservative institutions can enable abuse — then all that partisan moral clarity starts to disappear.

We’re all left with the disturbing and humbling reality that whatever our ideology or theology, it doesn’t make us good people. The allegedly virtuous “us” commits the same sins as the presumptively villainous “them.”

How does a typical conservative activist deal with this reality? By pretending it doesn’t exist.

Shortly after the Pressler settlement was announced, I looked for statements or commentary or articles by the conservative stalwarts who cover left-wing misconduct with such zeal. The silence was deafening. If you mainly receive your information from right-wing sources, the odds are good that you haven’t seen this news at all.

Advertise with us

Cultivated ignorance

It’s a cultivated ignorance, in which news outlets and influencers and their audiences tacitly agree not to share facts that might complicate their partisan narratives.

Of course, the dynamic is even worse when stories of conservative abuse and misconduct break in the mainstream media. Conservative partisans can simply cry “media bias!” and rely on their followers to tune it all out. To those followers, a scandal isn’t real until people they trust say it’s real.

But the truth — the whole truth — is indispensable. When our own institutional and individual sins are so appalling, humble repentance and reform should replace our partisan rage.

David French is a columnist for the New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “When cancer turns your life from peace to war, you need friends.”