In Los An­ge­les, where I live, well over 140 mil­lion av­o­ca­dos were sold. While I love gua­ca­mole and av­o­cado toast as much as the next An­ge­l­eno, this con­sump­tion is com­ing at a ter­ri­ble cost to Mex­ico.

Over the last year, I vis­ited more than 25 com­mu­ni­ties in Michoacán and Jalisco, two moun­tain­ous states in west­ern Mex­ico that sup­ply four out of five av­o­ca­dos sold in the United States. My re­search there found that ex­pand­ing av­o­cado pro­duc­tion to meet U.S. de­mand is fu­el­ing wide­spread de­foresta­tion and wa­ter scar­city.

Loss of for­ests and wa­ter

The de­struc­tion of the for­ests to in­stall av­o­cado or­chards was plainly vis­i­ble from the re­gion’s main high­ways. So was the mas­sive amount of wa­ter that pro­duc­ers are us­ing for ir­ri­ga­tion: pri­vate res­er­voirs, some as big as two NFL foot­ball fields, are com­mon sights in the two drought-prone states, where many com­mu­ni­ties are con­front­ing wa­ter short­ages.

But just be­cause the en­vi­ron­men­tal deg­ra­da­tion was ob­vi­ous didn’t mean it was easy to talk about. Many res­i­dents were too ter­ri­fied to do so. Their fear is well founded. Ef­forts by In­dig­e­nous com­mu­ni­ties and other res­i­dents to pro­tect for­ests and wa­ter from av­o­cado pro­duc­tion have re­peat­edly been met with threats and vi­o­lence.

Advertise with us

Despite these risks, many peo­ple in Michoacán and Jalisco con­tinue to doc­u­ment, de­nounce and re­sist the de­struc­tion, in­clud­ing In­dig­e­nous lead­ers, en­vi­ron­men­tal­ists, jour­nal­ists and ac­a­dem­ics. But their ef­forts are no match for the prof­its to be made sell­ing av­o­ca­dos to cor­po­ra­tions that ex­port the fruit, which is of­ten sourced from de­for­ested land.

The Los An­ge­les area is home to three such cor­po­ra­tions: Calavo Grow­ers Inc., Mis­sion Pro­duce Inc. and West Pak Avo­cado Inc. — all lead­ing ex­port­ers and im­port­ers of av­o­ca­dos from Mex­ico. They pub­licly trum­pet their sus­tain­abil­ity ef­forts, but are tak­ing lit­tle to no ac­tion to pre­vent their sup­ply chains from be­ing com­pro­mised by de­foresta­tion and un­sus­tain­able wa­ter prac­tices.

Inadequate protections

The re­cent re­search re­port I wrote for Cli­mate Rights In­ter­na­tional doc­u­mented ev­i­dence that these com­pa­nies — and oth­ers ex­port­ing and im­port­ing to the U.S. mar­ket — have sourced a por­tion of their av­o­ca­dos from Mex­i­can or­chards con­tain­ing il­le­gally de­for­ested land. When we asked them what they were do­ing to en­sure that their sup­pli­ers do not raze for­ests or steal wa­ter, none pro­vided in­for­ma­tion in­di­cat­ing they were tak­ing ade­quate mea­sures.

The Hass Avo­cado Board, also based in the L.A. area, is a fed­eral gov­ern­ment en­tity whose mis­sion is to in­crease U.S. mar­ket de­mand for do­mes­tic and im­ported av­o­ca­dos. Its 2024 busi­ness plan em­pha­sizes the need to com­mu­ni­cate its “sus­tain­abil­ity story” to con­sum­ers and build “trust” in how av­o­ca­dos are good for the en­vi­ron­ment. But it is short on pro­pos­als to re­duce the in­dus­try’s heavy en­vi­ron­men­tal im­pact.

What’s needed isn’t more spin, but ac­tions to make Mex­ico-U.S. av­o­cado sup­ply chains truly sus­tain­able. The U.S. gov­ern­ment should pre­clude the sale of av­o­ca­dos if they were grown on re­cently de­for­ested land. This would not be dif­fi­cult to carry out.

Advertise with us

Under the cur­rent U.S.-Mex­ico cer­ti­fi­ca­tion pro­gram — which fo­cuses ex­clu­sively on pest con­trol — both gov­ern­ments al­ready main­tain GPS maps of ev­ery sin­gle av­o­cado or­chard that is cer­ti­fied for U.S. ex­port. They could com­pare those maps with time-se­quenced sat­el­lite im­ag­ery to de­ter­mine whether an or­chard was es­tab­lished on re­cently de­for­ested land — and, if it was, block its cer­ti­fi­ca­tion for ex­port.

Cor­po­ra­tions have ac­cess to the same GPS maps, and should also use them to iden­tify re­cently de­for­ested or­chards and refuse to buy fruit from them.

Con­tin­u­ing de­struc­tion

Elim­i­nat­ing mar­ket ac­cess for av­o­ca­dos grown on re­cently de­for­ested land wouldn’t wreck the av­o­cado in­dus­try — most ex­ist­ing Mex­i­can or­chards are on lands that have long been ded­i­cated to farm­ing. But these reg­u­la­tions and pol­i­cies would help end the con­tin­u­ous de­struc­tion of for­ests for av­o­cado pro­duc­tion.

Un­til ac­tion is taken, the one thing you can trust when you eat gua­ca­mole or av­o­cado toast is that there’s a big risk it has a back­story of en­vi­ron­men­tal deg­ra­da­tion and abuse in Mex­ico.

Max Schoen­ing is a Los An­ge­les-based at­tor­ney who con­ducted the av­o­cado re­search for Cli­mate Rights In­ter­na­tional.