We tend to for­get that George Wash­ing­ton was a lead­ing pro­po­nent of the civil the­ol­ogy that Mar­tin Luther King, Jr. would later in­voke in his 1963 “I Have A Dream” ad­dress to great ef­fect. It was the con­vic­tion that the true foun­da­tions for the Amer­i­can be­lief in equal nat­u­ral rights of all hu­man be­ings to life, lib­erty, and the pur­suit of hap­pi­ness lay as much, or even more, in the com­mand­ments of the God of the Bible as in the ar­gu­ments of phi­los­o­phers.

He pro­pounded this civil the­ol­ogy in sev­eral state doc­u­ments and ad­dresses, in­clud­ing the first Thanks­giv­ing Proc­la­ma­tion of the United States in 1789. In 2023, as Amer­ica drowns in an­gry po­lar­iza­tion, along with a de­fi­cient ed­u­ca­tion in our civic foun­da­tions and his­tory, can we say that Amer­ica has been bet­ter off ne­glect­ing, or (in some cir­cles) de­rid­ing, the tra­di­tion of civil the­ol­ogy Wash­ing­ton es­tab­lished in hon­or­ing it?

Reli­gious guid­ance

Amer­i­can views of the civic role of re­li­gious be­lief to pro­vide higher guid­ance for, and uni­fy­ing strength to, our coun­try have changed dra­mat­i­cally since Wash­ing­ton’s na­tional call to prayer.

Advertise with us

They’ve changed since Lin­coln’s Second Inau­gu­ral call for “mal­ice to­ward none” and “char­ity for all” so that a vic­to­ri­ous Union would mag­nan­i­mously re­build a free Amer­ica, or even since King’s call in 1963 for equal civil rights so that “the glory of the Lord shall be re­vealed, and all flesh shall see it to­gether,” a quote from the bib­li­cal book of Isa­iah.

As the French ob­server Alexis de Toc­queville saw in the 1830s, Chris­ti­an­ity had taught Amer­i­cans since the early 17th cen­tury to seek po­lit­i­cal lib­erty and also af­firm plu­ral­ism and tol­er­ance across de­nom­i­na­tions in the New World. Thus, in his first in­au­gu­ral ad­dress, Wash­ing­ton re­af­firmed (he did not in­vent), a civil the­ol­ogy for the new con­sti­tu­tional or­der.

He in­voked be­fore the first Con­gress his his prayers to the “Al­mighty Be­ing who rules over the uni­verse,” the “be­nign Par­ent of the hu­man race,” that his bless­ing would be ev­i­dent in “the en­larged views, the tem­per­ate con­sul­ta­tions, and the wise mea­sures” of Amer­ica’s first ef­fec­tive gov­ern­ment.

In Oc­to­ber 1789, Washington called for a “day of pub­lic thanks­giv­ing and prayer” on the fourth Thurs­day in No­vem­ber. It opens with this ra­tio­nale: “It is the duty of all Na­tions to ac­knowl­edge the prov­i­dence of Al­mighty God, to obey his will, to be grate­ful for his ben­e­fits, and hum­bly to im­plore his pro­tec­tion and fa­vor.”

The “People of the United States” should ac­knowl­edge “with grate­ful hearts the many sig­nal fa­vors of Al­mighty God es­pe­cially by af­ford­ing them an op­por­tu­nity to peace­ably es­tab­lish a form of gov­ern­ment for their safety and hap­pi­ness.” The proc­la­ma­tion re­counts fur­ther rea­sons Amer­i­cans should pray to “the be­nef­i­cent Author of all the good that was, that is, or that will be,” such that “we may then all unite in ren­der­ing unto him our sin­cere and hum­ble thanks.”

Advertise with us

The great Lord and ruler

One such gift is “the civil and re­li­gious lib­erty with which we are blessed.” But as well as acknowledging blessings, American should admit faults. The peo­ple also should “be­seech” the “great Lord and Ruler of Na­tions” to “par­don our na­tional and other trans­gres­sions.”

At the 1787 Con­sti­tu­tional Con­ven­tion, Wash­ing­ton pre­sided over the draft­ing of the first con­sti­tu­tion ever to pro­tect re­li­gious lib­erty by for­bid­ding any “re­li­gious Test” for fed­eral of­fice­hold­ers (Ar­ti­cle VI, clause 3). After his in­au­gu­ra­tion, he wrote let­ters to sev­eral de­nom­i­na­tions, in­clud­ing Cath­o­lics and Jews, de­fin­ing re­li­gious lib­erty and “rights of con­science” as both rights and bless­ings for all Amer­i­cans.

We should give thanks for found­ers like Wash­ing­ton, and peo­ple like Lin­coln and King: mod­els of hu­mil­ity and na­tional unity, who el­e­vated Amer­ica by call­ing for obe­di­ence to di­vine truths about justice, peace, for­give­ness, and equal lib­erty for all.

Paul Car­rese is the found­ing di­rec­tor of the School of Civic & Eco­nomic Thought and Lead­er­ship at Ari­zona State Univer­sity.