So about that poll. You know the one: the Times/Siena poll showing Donald Trump with an edge over President Joe Biden in five out of six swing states, and suggesting a softening of support for Biden among Black, Latino and young voters.

It is best to take horse-race polling this far out from Election Day with a boatload of salt. But some of the data points to the unusual dynamics at play with a defeated president challenging the guy that America dumped him for.

Trump’s protest voters

It isn’t just that Biden has weakness among less engaged voters, or that some respondents weren’t embracing Trump so much as rejecting Biden. Despite his own raging unpopularity, Trump is positioned to serve as the repository for protest votes, nostalgia votes and change votes. That’s a weird but potentially potent mashup of support that could make up for a multitude of weaknesses. He could wind up beating Biden almost by default.

Advertise with us

A reelection campaign is fundamentally a referendum on the incumbent. And for all his accomplishments, Biden is presiding over a rough time. Inflation is still taking its bite out of people’s paychecks. The nation is still in a twitchy, sour mood post-pandemic. People are worried about crime and homelessness and the surge of migrants at the southern border.

They are still dealing with the toll COVID took on their kids. And the broader mental health crisis. And the opioid scourge. And the two wars in which America is playing a supporting role. Of course a big chunk of the electorate sees the country as headed in the wrong direction.

When Americans are feeling pessimistic, the president gets blamed. Many voters start itching for change, for someone to come in and shake things up.

Just as Biden sold himself in 2020 as a break from the chaos of Trumpism, Trump can now position himself as the change candidate.To borrow a cliché from Biden, Americans won’t be comparing Trump to the almighty but to the alternative. And for many voters, the alternative in 2024 is a Biden status quo they consider unpalatable.

It does not help Biden that he comes across as doddering and frail. This opens him up to one of Republicans’ favorite charges against Democrats: weakness. And political smears resonate more when they fit within an existing framework.

Advertise with us

Punishing Biden

At an even more basic level, Trump doesn’t have to promise positive change so much as the chance to stiff-arm the current leadership. Plenty of protest voters may not be looking to punish Biden for a particular action, or inaction, so much as for their inchoate disenchantment with the way things are. The economy should be better. Life should be better. The people in charge should be doing better.

Some protest voters will turn out to support anyone running against the object of their distaste. This is what plenty of people did with Trump in 2016 to express their lack of love for Hillary Clinton. Others, especially inconstant voters, may simply decide to sit out the race. If this happens disproportionately among groups who went for Biden in 2020, such as young and nonwhite voters, it works to Trump’s benefit. This is the low-turnout specter keeping Democrats up at night.

Then there is the nostalgia factor. Political nostalgia is a real and powerful thing. People are wired to romanticize the way things used to be and, by extension, the leaders at the time. Usually, voters dissatisfied with a president do not have the opening for such a direct do over. Rarely does a president who loses reelection attempt a comeback, and only one, Grover Cleveland, has ever done so successfully.

But this election is different. Rather than exchanging the incumbent for an unknown quantity, voters can choose to go back to a devil they know, who hails from a pre-COVID age of golden escalators and cheap mortgages.

Advertise with us

Now factor in “thermostatic voting,” the fancy name for a kind of generic buyers’ remorse you see as voters frequently veer toward the opposite party from the one they backed in the previous election. Virginia, for instance, picks its governor the year after a presidential election, and its voters typically go with the candidate whose party did not win the White House. You also see this nationally in midterm elections, in which voters often punish the president’s team.

They were better off

Trump has the added advantage of the economy having been humming before the pandemic upended his last year in office. Inflation was practically nonexistent. Unemployment was low. The nation wasn’t neck deep in scary, sticky wars. If, come fall of 2024, he asks voters that most basic of political questions, “Weren’t you better off when I was president?” an awful lot may answer, “Hell, yeah.”

Twelve months is several eternities in politics. And none of this is to downplay Trump’s glaring flaws — or his manifest unfitness for office. But there are some political fundamentals working in his favor that go beyond his specific pros and cons. Anyone who isn’t at least a little afraid isn’t paying attention.

Michelle Cottle is a member of the editorial board of the New York Times, which this article first appeared. Her previous article was “J.D. Vance's complicated, unexpected, aisle-crossing politics.”