I believe unironically in 1990s nostalgia. I think the cultural landscape of my youth was better than today’s — objectively better, and not just when seen through the rose-tinted spectacles of middle age. I accept (with certain ideological footnotes) the iPhone theory of current teenage unhappiness.

But even justified nostalgia needs realism about what it’s remembering. For instance, in championing the ’90s against the current era, you can make a solid case that it’s more pro-social and embodied and relaxing to watch garbage TV with your friends in someone’s basement than to sit on your bed texting with a bunch of avatars.

But it’s still important to acknowledge that there was a lot of garbage TV watching in the olden days. Pre-internet teenagers were as likely to be watching “The Sandlot” or “Stand by Me” as to be playing pickup ball or roaming the streets and the woods in search of coming-of-age drama.

Are there ways that high school 20 years ago was less stressed-out than high school is today? Yes, I think so. Was high school as a total experience ever actually chill, as opposed to a zone of often ruthless hierarchy where hormone-addled half-adults rend and wound one another while they compete for dominance? I remember the answer: It was different before the internet, but it wasn’t chill.

Advertise with us

Indeed, depending on how you define “chill,” you could argue things the other way. In certain senses, the world created by the internet has made high school safer than it was in my own youth, by separating kids from one another more than in the past, creating fewer opportunities for physical mayhem and nonvirtual stupidity.

The problem with this separation, with the teenage retreat into the virtual, is that it appears to be deadening, dispiriting, alienating, driving kids to anxiety and depression. But the earlier form of teenage life was physically more precarious — more drinking and driving, more actual sex with actual bodies, more pregnancy, more violence.

This reality is the driving dramatic force in Showtime’s “Yellowjackets,” now in its second season. The show is a literal high-school nostalgia trip, moving back and forth between a contemporary story line and a 1990s-era teenage narrative.

It’s all about the idea of high school as a zone of ruthless physicality, traumatic violence and hyper-embodied peril, to the point of gruesomeness that I wouldn’t recommend to everyone — an effect it achieves by telling the story of a girls’ soccer team whose plane crashes in the Canadian wilderness and has to survive the winter without rescue or relief.

The obvious comparison is “Lord of the Flies.” That William Golding novel is about boys regressing from civilization to the primitive, whereas “Yellowjackets” is about teenage girls enacting a heightened version of the adolescent savagery that civilization doesn’t fully subdue.

Advertise with us

The power of the show comes from the way the familiar stuff of adolescence — the influence of alcohol or shrooms, the specter of a teenage pregnancy, the “ick” of puberty and bodily transformation, the harshness of teenage social hierarchies and the shocks when they turn over, the deep resentments of the not-yet-fully-empowered nerds — becomes more vivid and recognizable under extreme circumstances.

Even the most intense elements, the grisly consequences of the crash and the cannibalism that clearly awaits the characters, are literalizations of a feral, carnal aspect of adolescence that even a bland American suburb doesn’t tame.

For a single season of television or a limited-run series, this is material enough: The first season of “Yellowjackets” doesn’t close its circles or complete its story, but it almost stands alone.

The intention of the show, however, is to combine its grisly adolescent action with the other kind of story its plane-crash narrative evokes, the mysterious island melodrama of “Lost,” with all its mystery boxes and mythology. Woven throughout the teenagers-being-teenagers action are threads of supernaturalism, encoded enigmas, weird signifiers, breadcrumbs for the overeager viewer.

I like this stuff, but I expect it to lead ultimately to dramatic failure. My particular hatred of the ending of “Lost” will never die, but with time and distance I can see that its failure was characteristic of the larger genre of sprawling, mythology-based television.

Advertise with us

This is a style that works really well with serial TV, where the week-to-week watching schedule allows for slow-unspooling storytelling and obsessive fan fixation on clues and red herrings. But the rewards for multiplying mysteries are greater than the rewards for figuring out how to wrap them up, so in almost every case you get an overpromise, an overcommitment, and then a crashing disappointment.

The original Matthew McConaughey/Woody Harrelson run of “True Detective” condensed the arc of mythology show failure into a single season, brilliant until its empty finale. “Westworld” manifested the same pattern in science fiction, with a transfixing first season and complete collapse thereafter.

“Game of Thrones” demonstrated how well this style could work in a literal fantasy world. Yet the presence of magic and dragons didn’t help much with the how-do-we-wrap-this-up problem. Amazon’s “The Rings of Power” series tries to bring the mystery-box style to J.R.R. Tolkien’s world without even initially successful results.

My hope for “Yellowjackets” is that its plane-crash world is built to be more self-contained than the sprawl of “Lost” — a single supernatural force, a single cult, a limited cast, fewer weird four-toed statues crying out for explanation.

My fear, though, is that choices made in the first season — particularly the death of two key characters in the 1990s timeline, deaths that were dramatically effective but substantially shrank the nonsupernatural narrative possibilities — are going to push the story deeper and deeper into its mythos and further from its original insight: that every high school experience is a little like a plane crash.

Ross Douthat is a New York Times columnist. His previous article was “The happy but alienated Republican right.” This article originally appeared in The New York Times.