We’ve been here before. In the decade following the Master Settlement Agreement with the tobacco companies, states received over $200 billion. They were supposed to use that money to prevent smoking, particularly in young adults.
They didn’t. Some states spent as little as 1.6% of its portion on smoking prevention, using much of the rest to plug short-term budget holes. That’s why, nearly 25 years after the agreement, tobacco is still killing nearly 500,000 Americans a year.
As the money from the opioid settlements starts flowing to states – and with fentanyl now the leading cause of death for Americans ages 18 to 45 and the epidemic claiming almost 70,000 Americans each year — we cannot make the same mistake. We must resist the temptation to use the funds to patch holes in the budget. We must resist the temptation to spend on pet projects, or even on other critical priorities.
Rather, we must understand that the opioid epidemic is, at its core, an “epidemic of despair,” so the only durable solution is to invest in hope. And while “invest in hope” sounds more like a campaign slogan than a public health strategy, there are concrete, tangible, measurable efforts we can make that can bring optimism to people who otherwise see a bleak future.
Pennsylvania provides some of the clearest evidence that despair is the root cause of the crisis. It had the eighth highest opioid overdose rate (and the fourth highest number of deaths) in the nation in 2022. Some of the highest overdose rates were in the rural areas near Pittsburgh, like Cambria, Fayette, and Lawrence counties; these counties are some of the poorest in the state.
They have higher unemployment rates and lower labor force participation rates than the state overall. The 40-year collapse of employment in the coal industry has meant people growing up in much of Southwest Pennsylvania will likely make less money and have fewer opportunities than their parents did.
Read More
The hopelessness starts early for children in hard-hit communities; once you see childhood through their eyes, opioid addiction becomes easier to understand. Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) scores are a depressingly good predictor of future drug use and behavioral issues. Folks in rural areas hit hardest by the opioid epidemic have some of the worst ACE scores, characterized by physical, psychological, and sexual abuse; exposure to domestic violence; physical and emotional neglect; and/or the incarceration of a family member.
Restoring hope to those at risk should begin before the long-term impacts of childhood trauma become permanent. We have found, for instance, that exposing children to artistic pursuits while they are still in school can have a twofold impact.
First, it can allow children exposed to trauma to work through their pain. Second, it exposes children in rural communities, whether traumatized or not, to a world of professions that they would never otherwise think were an option for them. When kids get to practice with, and then perform alongside, skilled older musicians or work with accomplished artists, they can imagine bigger and brighter lives.
Similarly, people must have a reason to keep the faith even if they or a family member have struggled with drugs. As, according to the Drug Enforcement Agency, opioids are “ubiquitous in Pennsylvania,” a belief that opioid use spelled the de facto end of a life would only compound hopelessness at the individual and community levels.
Recovery hubs can prove to people and communities that there is life after addiction. These hubs provide “wraparound” services to create the social conditions for recovery.
At their best, hubs provide peer coaching, workforce retraining, sober social events, and the often-overlooked issues that nevertheless keep people struggling with substance use disorder from building a new life, like dental care for people who have battled meth use. Recovery hubs provide both an on-ramp to mainstream society and a community of support for people whose substance use has damaged their pre-addiction relationships.
Recovery hubs prove that addiction isn’t the end of the line; indeed, early studies show that the hubs improve quality of life and workforce participation, limit depression and anxiety, and bolster long-term sobriety.
These are just a few examples of how we can restore hope to communities whose residents would otherwise be likely to turn to drugs. Everything from high school career fairs to a renewed emphasis on domestic manufacturing in the heartland could also step into the breach.
Yes, some of the settlement money must inevitably be used to treat the “symptoms” of the opioid epidemic. Some of the money must go to making overdose-reversing Naloxone widely available and increasing the number of beds in substance use facilities.
Yet to solve this problem, we must not think in terms of healthcare. We must think in terms of hope. We cannot prescribe our way out of the opioid epidemic; indeed, we prescribed our way into it. Any long-term solution will demand we give people reason to believe that tomorrow will be better than today, even as the last many decades have placed their communities on a seemingly inevitable downward trajectory.
Investing in hope will take years of patience. In hard-hit communities, we will need to provide services to young and old alike for a generation or more. It won’t be free, either. States have plenty of urgent issues which that $26 billion settlement could help address. But the alternative to investing in hope is unacceptable. We cannot, as we did with the tobacco settlement, look back 25 years later and see hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths.
If we do, we have failed.
Kerry Thomson is the Executive Director of Indiana University’s Center for Rural Engagement.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.