In the modern world, meritocracy has mostly replaced nepotism, the practice of doing special favors for family and friends. But it continues to thrive in two high profile areas — entertainment and politics.

The film business was founded by exuberant nepotists such as Carl Laemmle, the co-founder of Universal Pictures, who was known as "Uncle Carl" because he brought so many family members on board. Leading clans such as the Fairbanks, Houstons, Douglases, Barrymores and Redgraves hogged leading roles down the generations.

The problem is arguably getting worse and certainly isn't getting any better. The Dec. 19 issue of New York magazine popularized the term "nepo babies" to describe the children of Hollywood stars who are themselves stars. "She has her mother's eyes — and agent" reads the cover caption next to photographs of eight prominent nepo babies cropped onto infant bodies in bassinets.

American politics has long been dominated by a collection of regionally based dynasties: Roosevelts and Cuomos in New York, Tafts in Ohio, Kennedys in Massachusetts, Stevensons in Illinois, Browns in California, DuPonts in Delaware, La Follettes in Wisconsin, and Bushes in Connecticut and Texas. George W. Bush was after all the first presidential son to make it to the White House since 1824.

Advertise with us

Brand names give family members a head start — hence the focus on the young Bushes, Clintons and Trumps. Dual-career couples such as the Clintons and the Cheneys boost each other's careers and produce political children. Congress people run politics as a family business, giving jobs to the children of friends in return for their friends giving jobs to their children.

Why does any of this matter? The obvious answer is that social justice matters in all walks of life: Professions dominated by insiders, particularly family dynasties, deserve scrutiny.

Several nepo babies have hit back at New York magazine by arguing that actors have to pass a neverending performance test: A family connection might get your foot inside the door, but it doesn't sustain you over an acting career. The same might be said of politics given that politicians have to perform in public.

All the same, getting your foot in the door ranks high on the list of privileges. What about all those who didn't get a look in because the children of privilege had hogged all the opportunities?

And there are plenty of prominent figures who owe their prominence to family connections rather than innate talent. A more telling answer is that social justice matters even more in entertainment and politics than in other walks of life. It can't be good for democracy if representative positions are hogged by people who belong to a narrow, privileged caste. Democracy withers if it doesn't have deep roots in the soil of society.

Advertise with us

As for entertainment, its leading lights perform a quasi-public role because they tell us the stories that help to make sense of our lives. They are also taking on an increasingly prominent role in public life by pronouncing on great public issues, usually from a left-liberal position.

Most professions are intensifying the war against family privilege in the light of worries about stalled social mobility and wider economic stagnation. A growing number of corporations have introduced "CV blind recruitment" (whereby candidates' names, schools and universities are stripped out). Family companies force family members to pass meritocratic tests if they are to have a hands-on role.

The worlds of politics and entertainment are lagging badly behind. There is some talk of improving recruitment into British politics with blind CVs, for example. But the mood in both American politics and global entertainment is resistant to change.

"The current conversation about nepo babies is just designed to diminish and denigrate and hurt," says Jamie Lee Curtis, the daughter of Hollywood royalty Tony Curtis and Janet Leigh. "There are many of us. Dedicated to our craft. Proud of our lineage. Strong in our belief in our right to exist." Hardly an attitude that leads to industry-changing reform. U.S. politics also has many people who were born at third base and think they've hit a triple.

The most powerful weapon in the arsenal of populism is the accusation that the world is controlled by a self-dealing elite that applies one set of rules to itself (look after your family first!) and another to the rest of the world. Entertainers and politicians play an outsized role in creating this impression, partly because they occupy the public stage and partly because they are, indeed, guilty of so many of the sins they are accused of.

Advertise with us

They could also play an outsized role in calming the populist fury if they took a more responsible role in improving recruitment and promotion in their professions.

Adrian Wooldridge is the global business columnist at Bloomberg Opinion.