Analysis of the Republican Party’s underperformance in the 2022 midterm elections has considered almost every angle. But it has generally missed two significant issues: engagement of constituency voters and the visceral crisis of war in Ukraine.
In 2016, Donald Trump carried Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Ohio and Florida. It was to a significant extent because of Polish-Americans and other East Europeans, who comprise from 5% to over 10% of these states’ voters. While they are traditional Democrats, they are naturally conservative in their political attitudes and are registered to vote in above average numbers. They are a true swing vote in these states.
In 2016, the Trump campaign actively reached out into these communities. I should know: I was Chairman of Polish-Americans for Trump in 2016, and Co-Chairman in 2020. In 2016, we made thousands of phone calls and activated Polish-American organizations and urged them to vote for Trump in the last weeks of his campaign. President Trump recognized our efforts, credited us with the final push for his victory and thanked us publicly several times.
Unfortunately, he did so to the Polish President and not to Polish-Americans. We were ignored throughout his Administration. He did not even visit the Polish monastery in Pennsylvania where several other victorious presidents had traveled previously. His 2020 campaign likewise was unsatisfactory and actively discouraged participation in favor of centralized activities and campaign concerns, which had little to do with Trump constituencies. The result was disappointing — and the same can be said for 2022.
The second significant issue in the GOP’s defeat in Pennsylvania, and mixed results in other states, was the party’s messaging. The Republican campaign decided to concentrate on generic messages that criticized President Joe Biden’s failed policies in a way tailored to traditional Republican voters. No one sough input from specific constituencies in Pennsylvania to see what their actual concerns were.
If party operatives had done this outreach, they would have found out that the GOP was making a grave mistake by not addressing the visceral issue of the day: the Russian invasion of Ukraine and the necessity of vigorous defense.
In 2016, Donald Trump criticized laggard members of NATO, which did not contribute the required 2% of their GDP for their own defense — particularly its richest member Germany. Democrats interpreted this as his desire to destroy NATO, but it was the opposite.
In his speech to the Polish-American Congress on September 27, 2016, Trump promised to strengthen NATO and to increase security of its eastern flank, especially in Poland. During his presidency, he did just that. He signed an Enhanced Defense Cooperation Agreement with Poland and moved the headquarters of the U.S. Army 5th Corps there to command the whole eastern flank of NATO. He was the first to send lethal weapons to Ukraine.
The Russian invasion of Ukraine has made the security of NATO’s eastern flank a paramount concern. All frontier states fear the war could spill across their borders, or that Russia could threaten them next. The war is also impacting American geopolitical standing with Russia, China and Europe. Yet the GOP barely addressed this issue at all during the midterm campaign, while some candidates gave the impression that they would limit or stop aid to Ukraine, leading to widespread concerns.
This is where the GOP lost Polish-Americans, other East Europeans and many others who sympathize with Ukraine’s valiant struggle to stop Putin’s imperialistic conquest. By failing to aggressively support U.S. assistance to Ukraine, and by even dabbling in undermining that effort, the party is misreading its own electorate’s concerns and positioning itself on the wrong moral side. Voters will make the GOP regret its choice.
Tom Zawistowski, a conservative grassroots leaders in Ohio, put it this way: “After Trump winning in 2016 in part by micro-targeting specific demographic groups with specific messages, in 2018, 2020, and 2022 no such effort was made. . . . Poland is clearly threatened by the Ukraine war, and Polish Americans would vote for candidates who recognized that threat and pledged to help Poland defend itself from the Russians if necessary — but no Republican candidates or campaigns recognized the power of such a message and no outreach was made.”
Polish-Americans and other East Europeans consider support for defense of the eastern flank of NATO one of the key issues of our times — and they’re overrepresented in swing states. No Republican presidential candidate can win this office without these key constituencies. The absence of outreach and of listening will lead to repeated Republican defeats in the years to come.
Dr. Lucja Swiatkowski Cannon was Chairman of Polish-Americans for Trump in 2016 and Co-Chairman in 2020, official coalition groups of the Trump campaign. She is a strategist, expert and author on Eastern Europe, Russia and US-East European relations.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.