Everybody is looking for someone to blame for inflation. But is anyone really to blame, and if someone is, who? Here’s an explanation for those of you who aren’t economists.
Inflation occurs when there is too much money chasing too few goods.
We pay for what we buy with cash or with a check drawn our checking account balance. The cash in your wallet are Federal Reserve Notes. Those notes are legal tender that, by law, others must accept to settle your debts and to pay your taxes. A check a check drawn on your checking account balance orders your bank to pay cash on demand to whomever you gave the check.
The cash we all have in our pockets together with the claims to cash that we all have deposited in our checking accounts is the supply of money in circulation. Since all of the money supply consists entirely of Federal Reserve Notes printed by the Federal Reserve and of claims to those notes, it is the Federal Reserve, not the federal government, that determines the size of the money supply. The Federal Reserve does this by buying and selling bonds.
It puts more money into the economy when it buys bonds on the open market, paying for them by promising to give the seller of those bonds a claim to more Federal Reserve notes. It reduces the supply of money in circulation by selling some of the bonds it owns on the open market and accepting in exchange some of the claims to Federal Reserve Notes that the buyer of those bonds owns.
So, how did we get too much money chasing too few goods and services? The pandemic caused both death and havoc. In January, 2020 the unemployment rate was 3.5%. Three months later, the rate had peaked at 14.7% The federal government increased government spending during the pandemic to protect us from the drop in income that we would otherwise have surely experienced. It got the money to do so by selling bonds.
Read More
The Federal Reserve, in turn, did not want interest rates to increase when unemployment was increasing. So, it bought bonds, keeping interest rates low, but increasing the money supply. This was sensible. Higher interest rates at that time would have led to reduced demand for goods and services and increased unemployment.
The U.S. economy made a rapid recovery from the pandemic and the unemployment rate fell to one of the lowest levels ever experienced in this country. By October, 2021 the unemployment rate was below its pre-pandemic level. All of this was welcomed by most Americans.
Throughout this period the Federal Reserve, which controls the money supply, let the money supply grow. Indeed, the money supply was growing more rapidly than the nation’s output. The Federal Reserve knew that this could not go on indefinitely, as it would lead to inflation.
But unusual circumstances made it difficult to know just when it should stop letting the money supply increase. Most prominently, the pandemic precipitated not only unemployment, but also a dramatic decline in the percentage of the population looking for work. While the unemployment rate recovered quickly, by October, 2021 the number of people employed was still less than in 2019. In addition, there were still bottlenecks in supply chains created by the pandemic.
The Federal Reserve had to decide whether a further increase in the money supply would draw additional workers back into the labor force, allowing output to grow without further price increases, or whether it should stop buying bonds. This was a difficult call.
In hindsight, the Federal Reserve could have begun reducing the money supply before October 2021. It could have increased the rate at which it reduced the money supply once it had started to do so. But not many people last year questioned the Federal Reserve’s hesitance in reducing the money supply.
Nor is the Biden administration to blame. There is nothing the federal government could have done other than raising taxes that could have reduced the demand for goods and services. That is an action that no one was, or is, asking the federal government to do.
The Federal Reserve is doing what needs to be done. The increase in the price level in past three months has been very small. If the same rate of increase is sustained over for the next nine months, we will no longer be talking about inflation.
So no one is directly responsible for inflation. The cause was a combination of a natural event and Federal Reserve moves to protect Americans from the effects of the pandemic.
Now’s not the time to blame anyone. Now is the time to be thinking about what can be done to address problems that we will face for a long time beyond next year.
How do we cope with the strains on our social security and health insurance programs created by an aging population? How do we cope with climate change? What do we do regarding immigration policy? How do we address the continuing increase in the concentration of wealth? How do we keep the country from fracturing apart?
Jack Ochs is professor of economics, emeritus, at the University of Pittsburgh (jochs@pitt.edu). He lives in Point Breeze.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.