One of history’s first personal computers with an easy-to-use interface was called the “Lisa.” Launched in 1983, it was hailed as the most advanced personal computer in the world. With brand new features such as the mouse and copy-and-paste function, it promised to change the way we — the general public — could benefit from computers.
However, the new consumer-oriented computer cost too much (the equivalent to $27,000 today), didn’t offer enough features, and couldn’t be relied on to work right. The Lisa was a commercial failure, and the project leader was fired.
In any environment that does not reward experimentation and risk taking, that would be the end of the story. But that leader was Steve Jobs, and he lived in an optimal mix of education, culture and timing. Jobs moved onto his next product: the Macintosh. Today, over two billion iPhone and seven billion smartphone users leverage many of the innovations from the Lisa and Macintosh.
Last week, when I heard self-driving car company Argo AI would cease operations, I was saddened to learn that the work of this pioneering start-up, its founders Bryan Salesky and Peter Rander, and their thousands of employees would not reach its full potential.
Then, another domino fell as vertical farming pioneer Fifth Season announced they too were closing operations. Founded as Robotany by Austin Lawrence, Austin Webb and Brac Webb, the company used advanced robotics to produce 300 acres of vegetables (500,000 pounds per year) in a 20,000 square foot vertical farm … in Braddock, no less.
Start-ups are incredibly difficult endeavors. Creating one in entirely new industries like autonomous vehicles and vertical farming is even harder. These companies are trailblazers and innovators that play a dynamic and vital role in growing Pittsburgh’s entrepreneurial environment. They built enviable cultures, and they were committed community and civic leaders. They will be missed.
Read More
But I’m reminded that setbacks such as these are commonplace in leading entrepreneurial regions, and that failure is a necessary hallmark of a successful innovation economy.
Steve Jobs and other well known entrepreneurs bounce back from disappointment and challenges, not just because they are visionaries with brilliant technologies, but because they operate in optimal environments for innovation.
In Jobs’ case, he was located in the Bay Area at a time when computing was about to make a giant leap, surrounded by innovators and companies like Hewlett Packard, Bell Labs and Shockley Semiconductor. The area was also primed with a pipeline of research, inventions and talent from Stanford and Berkeley.
Fortunately, the team Argo assembled in Pittsburgh has the same opportunity. Pittsburgh has long been a center for academics, innovation, research and development. Aiding current and next-generation pioneers are Carnegie Mellon’s world-renowned robotics programs, engineering leaders from the University of Pittsburgh, commercial centers such as the National Robotics Engineering Center (NREC) and the Advanced Robotics Manufacturing (ARM) Institute, and more than 100 companies which are developing market solutions in robotics and automation.
This unique robotics “ecosystem” has already created an industry with more than 7,000 jobs in 18 different markets. Add in $62.7 million in new federal grants recently allocated to Southwestern Pennsylvania to upskill workers; develop career pathways; expand robotics adoption; and create opportunities for people of color, women and rural residents, and you get an industry that is transforming our entire region.
For these reasons, I think the robotics ecosystem we have built here has immense value, a value the world recognizes. As leader of the Pittsburgh Robotics Network, I have to know the robotics industry around the world, and our area is one of the best places for innovation and growth.
Economic setbacks are nothing new for western Pennsylvania. But the resiliency of our people and communities are central to how we bounce back. From our industrial past to the eds, meds and bots that drive our economy today, we as Pittsburghers evolved to create the entrepreneurial environment necessary to persist and grow.
I share in the disappointment of Argo and Fifth Season shutting down. They took a great risk in uncertain industries. Their talented employees accepted the challenge respectively to help develop safer vehicles through autonomous driving and to address food insecurities through new, more efficient farming methods.
But now I look forward to what those employees will accomplish next, either as highly contributing employees or as leading entrepreneurs themselves. There is already some promising news that Ford may look to retain many Argo employees in Pittsburgh.
Not every startup will succeed. Argo and Fifth Season will not be the last Pittsburgh-based robotics companies to come and go. But because of the unique robotics cluster we have in Pittsburgh and the hardworking traits built into the DNA of our region, I am confident that the next big leap is already happening right here in our home town.
Joel Reed is the executive director of the Pittsburgh Robotics Network.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.