This article is one of a series of articles the Post-Gazette will be running until the election, addressing the issues at stake from a diversity of views.
For about 15 years, while my children were younger, I was underemployed, because we could not afford full-time, year-round child care for 4 children. If two fairly comfortable earners couldn’t afford care, I can only imagine how hard it would be to afford quality care for anyone earning less. Many of the same issues we faced when I was using child care intensely remain issues today, namely, affordability, access, and adequate pay for child care teachers.
For us, the proximate child care centers for the full-time, year-round care that working families need ran about $15,000 a year. At one point, with 3 children of child care age, we would have needed $45,000 a year just for child care. Some two-earner families might eventually earn enough to pay that amount, but most families early in their careers, when they most need intensive child care, won’t.
Imagine the challenges of single-earner households or the vast majority of households who will never earn enough to pay such a steep price. Some would argue a nanny would have been a more economical choice for us, but even if that were an option, we would have missed the lifelong benefits that education at an early childhood care center imparts.
Research tells us the most critical time of brain development occurs in the first three years of life, so the need for high-quality child care is great. Once children move to school, the typical work day and the typical school day do not align, meaning morning care, after school care, and full-time summer assistance are necessary. Summer programs in our area were an average of about $300/week. With 4 children and 10 weeks of summer, that's another $16,000/year, for about ten years per child.
We were lucky to have an employer-related child care site, but getting in wasn't guaranteed. Even before COVID, there were triple-digit wait-lists for care, and the issue of access is even more challenging now.
Read More
Over 1,000 child care centers in Pennsylvania closed permanently during COVID. Even with almost 800 new centers opening, we are still running at a deficit of over 500. Many centers run at reduced hours and can no longer offer care for an entire traditional working day due to staffing shortages. Even when child care centers have adequate staffing, they are seeing high rates of turnover.
Part of the instability in child care is related to low rates of pay. The average salary of a child day care teacher in Pennsylvania is under $11.00 an hour. Most child care workers can’t afford to send their own children to the very places they work.
We know that investing in child care offers a 13:1 return on investment, as reported by education economics research, The Heckman Equation. My underemployment meant I was not fully contributing to an employer’s productivity, to taxes, or to our own financial well-being. It was a loss to society as well as to our family. This problem has only been exacerbated as the “great resignation” predominantly affected working mothers, forcing them out of the workforce during the pandemic.
This November we have a choice. We must elect state and federal candidates who prioritize stabilizing child care and the needs of working families and value the work of early childhood educators. By voting for candidates who will invest in child care, we make an important choice for our young children, working families, and the future of our economy.
Kate Rothstein is a (full-time, paid) manager at the National Council of Jewish Women/Pittsburgh and a working mother of four.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.