On  September 2, 1887, a short news item appeared in the Pittsburgh Dispatch (as this newspaper was then called) announcing the creation of Labor Day in New York state. It commented only: “‘Labor Day’ is an odd name to apply to an occasion upon which no one is expected to labor, but the workingmen who want its recreations will not be likely to split hairs on this point.”

Following are some excerpts from Labor Day editorials since then.

The newspaper’s first Labor Day editorial, titled “Labor’s Celebration,” appeared on Tuesday, September 3, 1889. Its short two paragraphs ran:

The celebration of Labor Day throughout the country yesterday afforded the labor organizations of the country an opportunity to show their strength. From the reports which were given in our news columns it appears that the opportunity was more thoroughly improved elsewhere than in Pittsburgh. This is possibly due to the impression that in this city the strength of labor organizations is so well known that there is no need of making a formal display of it.

Advertise with us

At all events, independent action by the different trades unions, made the fact that the day is a legal holiday the most uniform feature of the celebration; and those horny-handed toilers, the bankers and the brokers, joined with the carpenters in being the most scrupulous observers of the holiday. The celebration of Labor Day by the banking interest and its non-observance by the iron workers was one of the unique features, on which comment is useless.

The editors in 1930, in the first year of the Depression, praised government and business leaders. “Never before was a braver or more intelligent effort made to reduce the effects of a depression to the minimum.” The editors in 1932 were not so optimistic. Their editorial began:

There is a certain benighted school of thought which holds the the depression would be cured if the great mass of American people would return to the frugal standards of an earlier day. According to this kind of eighteenth century mind, American workers had things too easy in the prosperity years. ...

Faulty distribution and concentration of wealth in the hands of a few lie at the base of the depression. The type of thinker we have described would cure the depression by concentrating wealth in still fewer hands. ... This type of mind was vastly concerned with the welfare of the customer, but not with that of labor.

The editorial concluded:

Advertise with us

It has taken business and industry a long time to recognize that Labor and the Customer are one and the same man, and that what hurts Labor hurts the Market and, accordingly business.

In 1942, as America began supplying the war effort, the editors noted that the workers in most war industries had given up their holiday to work. They continued:

The machinist at his lathe, the miner underground, the mill worker at the door of his furnace — they ... are aware that by working on this day instead of parading or picnicking, they are helping to preserve the free and wipe out the slave status of labor in every part of the world. ... This Labor Day may produce fewer words, but it will make up for that in deeds.

In 1959, the editors praised the “decent union movement” while declaring “the Labor Day celebration of tradition is mostly gone.” 

Its disappearance is evidence of how far we’ve come in establishing the economic rights of man. ... His union has helped him get a large share of the expanding productivity of the country; and it has done something even more important. It has established his rights as a free American citizen. He has no need to debase himself before a bullying employer, in order to keep his job.

Advertise with us

Two years ago, the editors quoted Samuel Gompers answer to the question “What does labor want?”

We want more schoolhouses and less jails; more books and less arsenals; more learning and less vice; more leisure and less greed; more justice and less revenge; in fact, more of the opportunities to cultivate our better natures, to make manhood more noble, womanhood more beautiful, and childhood more happy and bright.

This article was prepared with the help of the Post-Gazette’s librarian, Stephen Karlinchak.