As we may be approaching federal charges against Donald Trump, it could be useful to review the experiences of another country where top level politicians have been charged with crimes, and some convicted and incarcerated.
Israel, which has both a prime minister and a president, has tried and imprisoned both former Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and former President Moshe Katsav. Both left politics because of the crimes for which they were later convicted. Another former prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, is currently on trial.
Some worry about the effect of charging a former American president. The trials and incarcerations of Olmert and Katsav did not seem to have any adverse impact on Israel’s society or government.
With Mr. Netanyahu, the situation is complicated. Though he was forced out as prime minister more than a year ago, he is still obstinately campaigning to regain power. If he holds office while on trial, he could continue in office until he is fully and finally convicted or acquitted.
The cases against him (like with Mr. Trump, there is more than one) have inched along for more than five and a half indecisive years. As police and prosecutors appeared at times to be dragging their feet, the politicization of accusations against Netanyahu has left the country so divided that the political system has been largely incapacitated.
In Israel, this gives rise to repeat elections. The fifth will be held in November. Tensions surrounding Mr. Netanyahu’s fate have inspired street demonstrations, vandalism, incitement, threats, and sometimes violence, but in the upcoming election he will still be one of the strongest contenders for the prime minister’s office.
Read More
Comparing the cases of Olmert, Katsav and Mr. Netanyahu, it is apparent that the Netanyahu proceedings have been disruptive, not because a former prime minister is on trial. It has been disruptive because the process has been conducted so slowly and hesitantly that the country has been left in a prolonged limbo while Mr. Netanyahu and his supporters agitate for his return.
The situation in America is similar. Like Olmert and Katsav, President Richard Nixon left political life during Watergate. He took responsibility for his misdeeds, reconciled himself to a public display of the consequences he faced, and allowed the country to move on.
Like Mr. Netanyahu, Mr. Trump refuses to leave quietly. While many of the proceedings against him are just picking up steam, Mr. Trump appears to be positioning himself to run again. He continues to deny wrongdoing, to undermine confidence in American democracy, to insist that the election was “stolen,” and to inflame the tensions that divide America and that contributed to the insurrection at the Capital.
Should Mr. Trump become a candidate and criminal defendant simultaneously, as Mr. Netanyahu is, it will further agitate the divisions and tensions that have disrupted American society, as Mr. Netanyahu’s case has in Israel.
It is legitimate to worry about setting a precedent of election winners taking legal vengeance against political opponents. Israel’s experience demonstrates, however, that even heads of state can be tried and incarcerated without destabilizing the underlying democratic system.
What is dangerous, though, is indecisive and prolonged proceedings against politicians who continue public campaigns mobilizing throngs of supporters with entranced, religious dedication. If the Justice Department is going to act, it needs to act soon and it needs to act quickly in order to swiftly and decisively seal the question of Mr. Trump’s fate, so that it is not left as an open wound that is allowed to go on subsuming American society.
Charging a former president who is still a likely future presidential candidate would make any prosecutor tread carefully, making sure to dot every “i,” but Mr. Trump’s cases inspire deranged supporters to do crazy things. Slower and steadier becomes bloodier and more riotous if it drags on.
Squirrel Hill native Baruch Stein has lived in Jerusalem for 15 years.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.