It was the first domestic insurrection against the newly formed federal government, and it happened in Pittsburgh’s own backyard. It was known as the Whiskey Rebellion, and one of its most radical leaders was David Bradford, a prominent lawyer from Washington, Pa.

In 1791, local farmers began protesting the excise tax on whiskey levied by Alexander Hamilton, Treasury secretary under President George Washington. Whiskey was the main barter and source of income for many poor farmers in this frontier region, so it was roundly protested as taxation without representation.

It was not hard for the likes of David Bradford to whip up a crowd to a fever pitch. He had served briefly in the Pennsylvania Assembly, where he was called by a fellow legislator named Albert Gallatin, “an empty drum, as ignorant, indolent and insignificant as he is haughty and pompous ”

To me it was understandable why poor farmers were so exercised over the excise tax on whiskey. But why would a man of his wealth risk everything in total defiance of the government? His protest did not appear to be conceived out of some kind of principled resistance to the new government.

Advertise with us

It seemed to be a brazen attempt to spark a populist rebellion with himself as the anointed leader. He might have been the first to contemplate a violent, self-serving assault on the Constitution and the federal government. (But he certainly has not been the last!)

Ron Schuler, writing in his grand, history-packed book “The Steel Bar: Pittsburgh Lawyers and the Making of America,” noted that as protests spread and tempers flared, Bradford delivered what one eyewitness described as a “violent and inflammatory oration, urging the formation of an army and the setting up of guillotines against those who opposed the rebels. (The French Revolution with its reign of terror was very much on the mind of the rebels at that time.)

Read More

Bradford felt sure that the army he called forth would defeat any army that President Washington could raise. A fellow lawyer, Hugh Henry Brackenridge of Pittsburgh, the founder of the future University of Pittsburgh, tried to calm the troubled waters, wondering whether he might actually fall victim to the riled-up crowd.

While Brackenridge was urging moderation and nonviolence, Bradford was calling for a militia to march on the city to show their mettle and possibly seize the ammunition stored there in the federal garrison.

When 7,000 angry protestors responded to Bradford’s call, Brackenridge was ready for them. He had thoughtfully bought four barrels of whiskey, which he graciously offered the crowd that was descending on the city. He succeeded not only in having them down the spirits but also in squelching their rebellious spirit. The crowd noisily retreated. Brackenridge wrote later that “I thought it better to be employed in extinguishing the fire of their thirst, then the fire of my house.”

Advertise with us

With all this upheaval, President Washington decided to act. He called out an army of 13,000, which made Bradford recognize that the better part of valor was to make a quick exit. By the time the federal army reached Pittsburgh, the rebellion had petered out and Bradford was gone, having fled down the Mississippi to Spanish Florida and another life.

President Washington issued pardons to all the ringleaders of the rebellion but not to Bradford. That was a bridge too far. But a few years later, President John Adams, perhaps setting an example for Gerald Ford’s pardon of Richard Nixon, did issue Bradford a pardon.

Visit the Bradford House and the Whiskey Rebellion museum in Washington, Pa. It’s well worth the trip. This first insurrection was not successful. The Constitution and our democracy prevailed. Let’s hope history repeats itself.

Barbara Burstin (burstin@pitt.edu) teaches history at the University of Pittsburgh and is the author of “Sophie, the Incomparable Mayor Masloff.” Her previous article was “The Next Page: Two old rivals, overachievers and old friends,” about the friendship of political rivals Cyril Wecht and Jim Roddey.