In a Gallup Poll asking which taxes were the most unfair, 42% of respondents said property taxes. It’s worse for a state like Pennsylvania, where nearly one in five residents is over the age of 65, and rising tax burdens can endanger their financial security and independence.
For someone who purchased a home in 1970 for the average price of $17,000, a current assessed value of $400,000 means a tax liability much higher than previously faced. Worse, they are being taxed on an asset with unrealized capital appreciation. They’ll benefit eventually, but now it costs them money they may well be unable to afford. The 18.7% rise in the cost of housing last year has made that worse. Lower income home-owners are similarly vulnerable to increases.
In February, Republican State Representative Frank Ryan released a 314-page bill aimed at eliminating property levies statewide. “House Bill 13 would end Pennsylvania’s archaic reliance on property taxes that unfairly burden our growing population of seniors and stifle our economy,” he said.
Pennsylvania property taxes continue to burden citizens of the Commonwealth. In Allegheny County, some 10,000 residents received property-assessment appeals from the school district. The districts want to raise the assessment they had relied on when their bought their homes. To some residents, such as Flavia Laun, 61, of Churchill, this could mean a drastic increase in their annual property tax burden — in her case, an additional $2,500 annually.
Only 38% of Pennsylvania school districts’ revenue comes from the state, and a paltry 4% comes from the federal government. This places Pennsylvania 44th in the country in state share of funding for public schools. The remaining 58% is provided by local governments, and property taxes make up the lion’s share of that portion (45%). If local governments derive a bulk of their revenue from property taxes, then any replacement system would need to be equal in value, if more equitable at scale.
If HB 13 passes and eliminates state property taxes, critics argue that local education revenue will evaporate overnight. But the bill’s stated purpose is to “shift a source of local school district funding away from school district property taxes in a manner that does not negatively impact school districts.”
Read More
The bill outlines a plan to make up the lost revenue by increasing income taxes by 1.85%, taxing retirement income, and raising the sales tax by 2% for food and clothing, all to be placed into a separate fund in the state treasury specifically for education funding.
Unsurprisingly, there has been pushback in Harrisburg. With inflation crushing Americans at the checkout line, a 2% increase in grocery taxes is not welcomed.
GOP gubernatorial candidate Doug Mastriano thinks he has an answer to the shortfall: reducing per-pupil spending. Speaking on WRTA Radio in March, he said, “I think instead of 19,000 [dollars], we fund each student around 9,000 or 10,000 and they can decide which school to go to, public school, private school, religious school, cyber school or home school.”
Critics called it outlandish to imagine Pennsylvania trimming its per-pupil spending to be on par with Mississippi. Mastriano believes that the per-pupil figure is inflated by overstaffing and administrative costs. Quoting a 2012 EDChoice report, he stated, “from 1950 to 2009, student populations increased by 96%, while non-teaching staff increased by 702%.”
If legislators can continue to find ways to decrease areas of perceived unnecessary school overfunding, the Keystone State could be on track to make a groundbreaking reform. With reduced bloated education spending, perhaps some additional proposed taxes could be trimmed from HB 13. And if the bill passes, Pennsylvania could pioneer a new era for state residents — giving them true ownership of their homes by eliminating the property tax.
Jarrett James Lash writes on east coast housing issues for Real Clear Politics.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.