One of my dearest friends responded with horror, like so many other well-intentioned white Americans, when he learned of the most recent mass slaughter of Black persons. “Terrible, senseless carnage in Buffalo over the weekend,” he texted. “What have we become?”
What we have become follows from what we have been. Larry Goodwyn, a civil rights reporter-turned-historian, and a son of the white South, had a classroom and bar-side mantra when I was his student and teaching assistant 40 years ago at Duke. “When it comes to racism, pardner,” he would say, “there ain’t nothin’ worse than the naiveté of white people.”
Goodwyn knew that such naiveté obliterated the past, deflected responsibility, and allowed new crimes to be committed. This also was his gloss on what arguably is the greatest of all American short stories, “Benito Cereno,” by Herman Melville. In my careers as a reporter, historian and teacher, I often tried to convey the importance of what Goodwyn said and Melville wrote.
But the fact remains that the execution of Patrick Lyoya on April 4 in Grand Rapids, no less than Payton Gendron’s assassination of 10 Black persons in Buffalo on May 14, stand as sickening recurrences of the centuries-old practice of white Americans’ killing people of color. And now, in Akron, the name of Jayland Walker can be added to the list of Black persons gunned down by the police.
Walker’s death ought to remind us that the killing of Black persons is not something new, and that their deaths do not signal what white persons have “become,” as my friend put it: it is something that we are, something that defines us.
We have the video of Mr. Walker’s death and of Mr. Lyoya’s death, and on the web there remain traces of Gendron’s live-streaming of his rampage. Both events, and dozens more in recent years, register as beyond the horrific. And while we have been quick to categorize the Russian assault on Ukraine as genocidal, when will white Americans come to see their liquidation of millions of persons of color, native and forced immigrant alike, as worthy of a monetary commitment to help make things right?
Read More
In thinking about the hurried eulogies delivered on air by the loved ones of Buffalo’s newly deceased, I have been drawn to revisit a telling event that I stumbled across in doing research for a book on race and identity. Its central figures are a family of self-identified Black Americans who embarked upon long journeys in search of autonomy and safety, from the 1780s into the mid-20th-Century.
They emigrated from Maryland and the Southern Piedmont to Ohio, Indiana, and Michigan, to Canada, and then to Haiti, before returning to North America. Today, their descendants live in Akron, across the mid-West, and in New York City.
The event I have noted occurred in Oxford, Ohio, an important site on the Underground Railroad. There, in 1862, the man who had led his family from the South, William Proctor, was executed. Contemporary accounts of his murder are contradictory: either Proctor was shot by white Union soldiers, or by the local sheriff and his deputies.
A skilled blacksmith, he and his wife, Nancy East, had built a solid life for their family. On the evening of September 13, he stepped out onto his porch and was shot dead. This happened at about the same time that his nephew, Joseph Proctor, had helped lead the charge against the Confederates in Fort Wagner, South Carolina, by the first Black regiment to fight in the war, the Massachusetts 54th. Joseph Proctor was killed in the assault.
A few years later, Alexander Proctor, his father and the brother of William, died in Haiti, where he and his wife, Margaret Chavous, and two of their children had hoped to escape white supremacy.
The direct descendants of Alexander and Margaret Chavous Proctor settled in Southwestern Michigan after the Civil War. One led a large Black congregation, but two struggled to eke out a living as farmers and fruit pickers. The Great Depression was especially hard on them and on millions of other persons of color.
At the time, the poet Langston Hughes, a Black person and a gay person who attended high school in Cleveland declared that, someday, America would fulfill its promise and become America: “O, yes, / I say it plain, / America never was America to me, / And yet I swear this oath — / America will be!”
The histories of the Proctors and their families stand together as testimonies to the myriad sources, tragic and heroic, of America’s violent and racialized past and to “a dream deferred,” as Hughes put it in another poem.
In light of the thousands of anti-Black terrorist murders that mark American history, the killing of William Proctor hardly seems surprising. It also is not surprising that relatives of William Proctor chose to emigrate to Haiti, a nation of self-liberated enslaved persons which promised freedom and land — and protection from marauding whites.
Prior to Haiti’s devastating earthquake of 2010, I traveled there in search of the traces of the Proctors’ lives. I found none. But I saw first-hand that, like the freedom dreams of the Proctors, Haiti’s, too, have remain deferred — but not, as The New York Times reported recently, because of natural disasters. The Western powers deliberately kept Haiti immiserated.
These efforts are rooted in the very racism of European expansion and enlightenment which brought more than 10 million Africans to the “New World” — 1.5 million died in the passage from Africa — and which resonates still in the killings of black persons in and beyond Oxford, Ohio, Buffalo, Grand Rapids. And now, Akron.
Paul Krause, a native of Pittsburgh, is a former journalist, the author of "The Battle for Homestead," the definitive history of the Homestead Lockout of 1892, and a retired professor of African American and US History.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.